independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Is it Prince's production techniques that dissappoint fans the most?
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 09/29/06 9:51am

skywalker

avatar

Is it Prince's production techniques that dissappoint fans the most?

I don't agree with disappointed fans who say that Prince's songwriting skills and lyrics have gotten worse since 198whatever.


However, I CAN understand disappointment in how Prince's production of his music compared to "the good old days".

Ever since 1990/1991 Prince seems to have shifted to more conventional sounding production of his music. It still sounds a bit off center when compared to other musicians, but it is not nearly as abstract as it used to be. I'm not talking about the linn machine, I mean how Prince used to use odd sound combinations that seemed to come out of no where in his music.

Let me ask you all this-- what are your favorite albums from 1990 onwards in terms of production and why?
"New Power slide...."
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 09/29/06 10:11am

mikek1

The mastering is pretty shit.

I don't understand why prince isn't playing the guitar alot. He's wasting his skills.

I would love to hear some music with lots of solos; bass and guitar!

TRC for the most part is well produced.

The gold experience has amazing points and shitty ones; the keyboard bit in endorphine machine! Someone should of said 'prince that bit ruins the song'!

I wish prince would use effects like page and hendrix did and create unique sounds with his instruments.

Prince also is lacking in epic songs. He could produce something like stairway, voodoo chile, november rain.
[Edited 9/29/06 10:15am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 09/29/06 10:46am

Doozer

avatar

Since 1990, I would single out the following for their production:

The Rainbow Children - Whether or not you like the album, there's no denying the creative production approach and the different "organic" sound never really heard before on a Prince album.

The Gold Experience - Again, maybe a matter of taste, but that thing is such a blown-up glittery mess that you can't ignore it, and I think it was done very purposefully in order to make it sound different from any "Prince" album, being the first proper album released by 0(+>.

One Night Alone...Live! - While missing some of the high points of the tour (i.e. would've been awesome to have Love Rollercoaster after 1+1+1=3 like in the concerts), the minimal overdubs and seamless transition from song to song recorded in different venues is pretty darn well done. The third disc is maybe more questionable.

The Truth - Quite a nice listen.

Low points being:

Emancipation - Lots of stuff to like, but the gooey plastic sound of the whole thing isn't what I would call "the album he was born to make." I think those 3 discs show less range than even Musicology or 3121.

Crystal Ball - More poorly assembled that some fan releases and bootlegs.
[Edited 9/29/06 10:47am]
Check out The Mountains and the Sea, a Prince podcast by yours truly and my wife. More info at https://www.facebook.com/TMATSPodcast/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 09/29/06 11:12am

sexxydancer

I don't get all technical-I just love and appreciate the music!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 09/29/06 11:31am

NouveauDance

avatar

nod

Just IMO, production has definately been lacking on most releases for at least a decade now.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 09/29/06 11:48am

metalorange

avatar

On one hand, Prince's production is magnificient, in the sense that he creates songs with a band feel with ease when it is only him. And I've heard other bands far more stuck in a rut and producing the same type of sound every album, Prince's albums remain extremely varied even after all these years.

On the other hand, there is a slick, smooth production sound that crept into Prince's music around Emancipation and continued through Newpower Soul, Rave, The Chocolate Invasion, The Slaughterhouse and Musicology. I can't really put my finger on what it is, but the sound on all those is too balanced and rhythmically kinda dull (all though of course there are still great songs throughout), they really sound like Prince alone in the studio not making the most of the drum machine.

For my personal tastes I do like music that is somewhat unbalanced, some sound or instrument way too much up in the mix can make it more interesting and carry the song - like the synth carrying When Doves Cry, for instance. Prince rarely puts out stuff that is a bit raw and unpolished, but he should because it usually works better, and one of his strengths is without doubt his guitar playing which he should let reign more on record rather than burying it in the mix.

I actually think 3121 was a step in the right direction for my tastes in the most part, a little bit unbalanced, a little bit more focused on one synth sound or beat rather than creating a boring balanced sound.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 09/29/06 12:20pm

Doozer

avatar

metalorange said:


one of his strengths is without doubt his guitar playing which he should let reign more on record rather than burying it in the mix.


co-sign.

Listen to the guitars in "Joy in Repetition" and ask yourself why they were barely audible. There are many more similar examples of buried guitar in Prince's catalog.

metalorange said:


On the other hand, there is a slick, smooth production sound that crept into Prince's music around Emancipation and continued through Newpower Soul, Rave, The Chocolate Invasion, The Slaughterhouse and Musicology.


Very true once again with, I would argue, the exception of The Rainbow Children. There's a piece of work that definitely does not sound like Prince alone in the studio, even though one can be sure it's mostly him.
Check out The Mountains and the Sea, a Prince podcast by yours truly and my wife. More info at https://www.facebook.com/TMATSPodcast/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 09/29/06 12:26pm

kisscamille

mikek1 said:

The mastering is pretty shit.

I don't understand why prince isn't playing the guitar alot. He's wasting his skills.

I would love to hear some music with lots of solos; bass and guitar!

TRC for the most part is well produced.

The gold experience has amazing points and shitty ones; the keyboard bit in endorphine machine! Someone should of said 'prince that bit ruins the song'!

I wish prince would use effects like page and hendrix did and create unique sounds with his instruments.

Prince also is lacking in epic songs. He could produce something like stairway, voodoo chile, november rain.
[Edited 9/29/06 10:15am]


Excellent points Mike. I agree completely.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 09/29/06 1:24pm

mikek1

Doozer said:

metalorange said:


one of his strengths is without doubt his guitar playing which he should let reign more on record rather than burying it in the mix.


co-sign.

Listen to the guitars in "Joy in Repetition" and ask yourself why they were barely audible. There are many more similar examples of buried guitar in Prince's catalog.

metalorange said:


On the other hand, there is a slick, smooth production sound that crept into Prince's music around Emancipation and continued through Newpower Soul, Rave, The Chocolate Invasion, The Slaughterhouse and Musicology.


Very true once again with, I would argue, the exception of The Rainbow Children. There's a piece of work that definitely does not sound like Prince alone in the studio, even though one can be sure it's mostly him.


i know; why the hell does he do that? He's such a great player!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 09/29/06 1:35pm

ElCapitan

avatar

mikek1 said:

Doozer said:



Very true once again with, I would argue, the exception of The Rainbow Children. There's a piece of work that definitely does not sound like Prince alone in the studio, even though one can be sure it's mostly him.


i know; why the hell does he do that? He's such a great player!


People have been complaining about Prince not featuring his guitar enough since forever. Guitar solos can take over a song. I always assumed he had different goals in mind for his albums than showcasing his guitar skills.
"What kind of fuck ending is that?"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 09/29/06 1:41pm

mikek1

ElCapitan said:

mikek1 said:



i know; why the hell does he do that? He's such a great player!


People have been complaining about Prince not featuring his guitar enough since forever. Guitar solos can take over a song. I always assumed he had different goals in mind for his albums than showcasing his guitar skills.


GUITAR SOLOS ROCK! They don't have to be aggressive; just listen to maggot brain.

Everyone wants more guitar from prince!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 09/29/06 1:51pm

sacredwarrior

skywalker said:

I don't agree with disappointed fans who say that Prince's songwriting skills and lyrics have gotten worse since 198whatever.


However, I CAN understand disappointment in how Prince's production of his music compared to "the good old days".

Ever since 1990/1991 Prince seems to have shifted to more conventional sounding production of his music. It still sounds a bit off center when compared to other musicians, but it is not nearly as abstract as it used to be. I'm not talking about the linn machine, I mean how Prince used to use odd sound combinations that seemed to come out of no where in his music.

Let me ask you all this-- what are your favorite albums from 1990 onwards in terms of production and why?


to me, production technique is a reflection of ur state of mind. so if ur asking if fans are disappointed with his state of mind, i dont know. isnt everybody disappointed with something cuz it feels like independent thinking? i dont know.
" the embassy shut to keep the fools out " - as above, so below.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 09/29/06 1:52pm

ElCapitan

avatar

mikek1 said:

ElCapitan said:



People have been complaining about Prince not featuring his guitar enough since forever. Guitar solos can take over a song. I always assumed he had different goals in mind for his albums than showcasing his guitar skills.


GUITAR SOLOS ROCK! They don't have to be aggressive; just listen to maggot brain.

Everyone wants more guitar from prince!


I agree, I'd love to hear more guitar. I'm just saying why I think he doesn't do it as much as might be wanted. I guess it wouldn't be Prince if he just gave us what we wanted. In the meantime, listen to him live I guess..
"What kind of fuck ending is that?"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 09/29/06 2:34pm

origmnd

mikek1 said:

The mastering is pretty shit.

I don't understand why prince isn't playing the guitar alot. He's wasting his skills.

I would love to hear some music with lots of solos; bass and guitar!

TRC for the most part is well produced.

The gold experience has amazing points and shitty ones; the keyboard bit in endorphine machine! Someone should of said 'prince that bit ruins the song'!

I wish prince would use effects like page and hendrix did and create unique sounds with his instruments.

Prince also is lacking in epic songs. He could produce something like stairway, voodoo chile, november rain.
[Edited 9/29/06 10:15am]



Maybe that endorphine keyboard tragedy
is simply because Prince wanted to introduce yet another "version" of the song. He already released the version on
the CD-ROM and then we heard the Arsenio performance.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 09/29/06 2:53pm

Sowhat

avatar

origmnd said:



Maybe that endorphine keyboard tragedy
is simply because Prince wanted to introduce yet another "version" of the song. He already released the version on
the CD-ROM and then we heard the Arsenio performance.



Wasn't it Interactive on the CD-ROM????

Endorphine Machine wasn't on there also was it (it has been years since I played the CD-ROM)?
"Always blessings, never losses......"

Ya te dije....no manches guey!!!!!

mad I'm a guy!!!!

"....i can open my-eyes "underwater"..there4 i will NOT drown...." - mzkqueen03 eek lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 09/29/06 5:47pm

mrmarcus

avatar

ElCapitan said:

mikek1 said:



GUITAR SOLOS ROCK! They don't have to be aggressive; just listen to maggot brain.

Everyone wants more guitar from prince!


I agree, I'd love to hear more guitar. I'm just saying why I think he doesn't do it as much as might be wanted. I guess it wouldn't be Prince if he just gave us what we wanted. In the meantime, listen to him live I guess..



I read an interview where he said he would like to be remembered as a guitar player. I guess he changed his mind.
Good morning Ladies & Gentlemen,
Boys & Motherfuckin' girls
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 09/29/06 5:57pm

christos7

mrmarcus said:

I read an interview where he said he would like to be remembered as a guitar player. I guess he changed his mind.


Yes. Player will do just fine. lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 09/30/06 1:18am

prettymansson

Digital~itis has taken over..thats the problem. confused
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 09/30/06 8:14am

ElCapitan

avatar

mrmarcus said:

ElCapitan said:



I agree, I'd love to hear more guitar. I'm just saying why I think he doesn't do it as much as might be wanted. I guess it wouldn't be Prince if he just gave us what we wanted. In the meantime, listen to him live I guess..



I read an interview where he said he would like to be remembered as a guitar player. I guess he changed his mind.


Is that the interview where he said he was "just a guitar player"? That he considers Johnny Lang more competition than MJ?
"What kind of fuck ending is that?"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 09/30/06 10:31am

Justin1972UK

It's the lyrics which disappoint me.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 09/30/06 10:41am

wlcm2thdwn

Nope, he could sing accoppella for me and it would be right on time!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 09/30/06 10:47am

legendofnothin
g

mikek1 said:

ElCapitan said:



People have been complaining about Prince not featuring his guitar enough since forever. Guitar solos can take over a song. I always assumed he had different goals in mind for his albums than showcasing his guitar skills.


GUITAR SOLOS ROCK! They don't have to be aggressive; just listen to maggot brain.

Everyone wants more guitar from prince!


Hell Yeah!!! I need to get fucked real good by his Guitar! Rock Me! headbang
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 09/30/06 12:03pm

origmnd

Sowhat said:

origmnd said:



Maybe that endorphine keyboard tragedy
is simply because Prince wanted to introduce yet another "version" of the song. He already released the version on
the CD-ROM and then we heard the Arsenio performance.



Wasn't it Interactive on the CD-ROM????

Endorphine Machine wasn't on there also was it (it has been years since I played the CD-ROM)?


A performance video of Endorphine was on the CD-ROM
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 09/30/06 12:08pm

origmnd

Fury on SNL woke up alot of people to his skills.

I was talking to a metal head in Tower Records one day, trying to get him into Prince. I tried to assure him that his radio songs are not atypical of his sound.

He said to me "does he play leads?"
That should tell how much people are aware of him.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 09/30/06 12:25pm

sosgemini

avatar

lyrics, arrangment and production are all missing the "quirk".
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 09/30/06 3:26pm

ufoclub

avatar

mikek1 said:

The mastering is pretty shit.

I don't understand why prince isn't playing the guitar alot. He's wasting his skills.

I would love to hear some music with lots of solos; bass and guitar!

TRC for the most part is well produced.

The gold experience has amazing points and shitty ones; the keyboard bit in endorphine machine! Someone should of said 'prince that bit ruins the song'!

I wish prince would use effects like page and hendrix did and create unique sounds with his instruments.

Prince also is lacking in epic songs. He could produce something like stairway, voodoo chile, november rain.
[Edited 9/29/06 10:15am]


Ive never had a problem with his in your face mastering. I've heard horrible mastering on old Led Zepplin albums...

the keyboard bit in endorphin Machine is h im making the song feature and odd "prince" noise up front, without it, it's a conventinal rock song that fiits with this theory that his 90's music was more conventionally arranged.

solos, bass, and guitars is conventional and goes against the point made in the original post!

TRC is his most conservative album he ever put out musically, it has the most conventional sequence of songs as far as the sound and tone. I asked Femi Jeya about this (when we were "one on one" at the last celebration) and he confirmed that he (Femi) was able to add more input to this album and have it produced in a more conservative fashion than the usual way Prince puts all the intruments including the embellishments up to "11".
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 09/30/06 3:30pm

ufoclub

avatar

Look at PLay in The sunshine or I could never take the place, those are unconventionally produced rock songs... the guitar is "buried" just like Joy in Repitition (personally I don't think it's buried at all!)

I have a feeling you guys want him to go backwards and produce more conservatively....

I say NO.

3121 (title track), Lolita, Black Sweat... these are just fine. Gems.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 09/30/06 4:29pm

metalorange

avatar

ufoclub said:[quote]

mikek1 said:



solos, bass, and guitars is conventional and goes against the point made in the original post!

TRC is his most conservative album he ever put out musically, it has the most conventional sequence of songs as far as the sound and tone.


Bass and guitars are conventional instruments, but that doesn't mean you can't use them in an unconventional way in the production.

Though you may be right, TRC maybe was a return to 'conventional' production with conventional instruments, but that was why it was so refreshing, since either side of it were albums sounding somewhat digitised and computer generated, too obviously Prince alone in the studio not pushing for originality in tone or beat. TRC had a far more organic sound as if an entire band really was playing and had more free reign, more like the production on his earlier albums.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 09/30/06 11:06pm

ufoclub

avatar

metalorange said:[quote]

ufoclub said:

mikek1 said:



solos, bass, and guitars is conventional and goes against the point made in the original post!

TRC is his most conservative album he ever put out musically, it has the most conventional sequence of songs as far as the sound and tone.


Bass and guitars are conventional instruments, but that doesn't mean you can't use them in an unconventional way in the production.

Though you may be right, TRC maybe was a return to 'conventional' production with conventional instruments, but that was why it was so refreshing, since either side of it were albums sounding somewhat digitised and computer generated, too obviously Prince alone in the studio not pushing for originality in tone or beat. TRC had a far more organic sound as if an entire band really was playing and had more free reign, more like the production on his earlier albums.


well, "come on" from new pwer soul overshadows the entire Rainbow children album for me! The one that really stands out on Rainbow is Digital Garden. Other than that, I like the vibe of the title track... but all the others are too conventional to interest me.

3121 the title track, and Lolita are Prince in top form. He has always only had two to three songs that really are gems on each album. The rest grow on me as I forgive their dull or uninspired attributes. SOTT is a prime example. when it came out in 1987, I only liked three tracks on my intitial gut instinct (Sott, housequake, If I was girlfriend) the rest sounded a bit impotent. but with time, and homemade remastering and the movie, many others have come to life in my mind.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #29 posted 10/01/06 2:43am

metalorange

avatar

ufoclub said:


well, "come on" from new pwer soul overshadows the entire Rainbow children album for me! The one that really stands out on Rainbow is Digital Garden. Other than that, I like the vibe of the title track... but all the others are too conventional to interest me.


Well, everybody has a different favourite from Newpower Soul, I don't really see what is so terribly different or unconventional about Come On compared to the other tracks, several of them have that phat drum sound for instance. I would argue that The One with Rhonda's fretless bass and the orchestration is far more unconventional for Prince.

Perhaps there aren't really any stand-out tracks on TRC, but that makes for a more cohesive, consistent sounding album, the whole album is a flowing experience. I just can't hear this 'conventionality' through this album you can, it just goes all over the place, the feedback-bass on Family Name is high-point for me.

3121 the title track, and Lolita are Prince in top form. He has always only had two to three songs that really are gems on each album. The rest grow on me as I forgive their dull or uninspired attributes. SOTT is a prime example. when it came out in 1987, I only liked three tracks on my intitial gut instinct (Sott, housequake, If I was girlfriend) the rest sounded a bit impotent. but with time, and homemade remastering and the movie, many others have come to life in my mind.


Well, surely you can't argue that Sign hasn't unconventional (for the time) production? Plenty of innovative sounds and layered/overlapping vocals. I do like 3121, Prince seemed to make more effort to come up with interesting synth/drum patterns, but totally different to the organic drumming on TRC, shows his breadth of production abilities.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 1 of 2 12>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Is it Prince's production techniques that dissappoint fans the most?