independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Similiar Albums...
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 11/02/05 7:34pm

FrancerulzV99

Similiar Albums...

I was just wondering...in your honest opinion, which Prince album is closest to the sound of Purple Rain. Yeah, it sounds cliche, but P.R. just did it for me, I love it to death and I'm looking for an album with a relatively similar sound.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 11/02/05 7:40pm

monte

you could try around the world in a day. his next album although it was a big change in sound for him (phycadelic, oriental) it still has some of that purple rain sound in it.

then you should try his 90's stuff.
i would recomend the undertaker. a simple guitar, bass drums blues/rock album. it's not like purple rain but it's a great example of prince doing rock

alot of people also like the gold experience because it has straight rock and pop on it but i personally find the production really cheezy.

the next one would be chaos and disorder. another 90's mostly rock album. it's got some great rock but as a whole album it just doesn't work (it's got a couple of shocking songs on it)

that's pretty much it for rock based albums. but i would recomend you don't just try prince's rock (except for the undertaker) and instead seek out his best unified albums,

1999, dirty mind, parade, sign o' the times, lovesexy
[Edited 11/2/05 19:42pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 11/02/05 8:51pm

thekidsgirl

avatar

If you just like Prince for Purple Rain, I'll warn you now
he likes to change things up alot, so not alot of stuff really
sounds the same in my opinion, but in my case, that why I love him wink
If you will, so will I
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 11/02/05 9:57pm

monte

that's what he's all about and i love it. changing his sound. like bowie. he can also do alot of genres too.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 11/02/05 11:40pm

toejam

avatar

The albums before and after Purple Rain are the most similar sounding.

1999 (1982) has songs in a vein of "When Doves Cry", "Computer Blue" and "Let's Go Crazy", but they're less 'rock' and more 'cold/electronic/funk' sounding. On the other side, Around The World In A Day (1985) eleboartes on 'live/warehouse' sound of Purple Rain and it takes it a little further adding a 'psychedelic/world music' influence. "The Ladder" is probably the closest sounding song to "Purple Rain".

As far as more recent stuff, "A Million Days" and "Cinnamon Girl" on Musicology (2004) wouldn't have been too out of place as B-sides to Purple Rain. Also, The Gold Experience (1995) has a similar mix of rock and funk, but it's more 'studio/produced' sounding than Purple Rain.

Basically, Prince's music is always evolving. You gotta keep up with it wink
Toejam @ Peach & Black Podcast: http://peachandblack.podbean.com
Toejam's band "Cheap Fakes": http://cheapfakes.com.au, http://www.facebook.com/cheapfakes
Toejam the solo artist: http://www.youtube.com/scottbignell
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 11/02/05 11:46pm

IstenSzek

avatar

For an exact copy, see "She Gave Her Angels" on the Crystal Ball (1997)
box set. It has an external guitar solo that features one exact same
chord sequence from the "Purple Rain" guitar solo.

weird.
and true love lives on lollipops and crisps
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 11/03/05 1:03am

tane1976

avatar

None really, every album is different. Prince has such a wide ranging scope of songs its impossible to categorise albums in groups, but if I had to say one album, it would be the Gold experience, straight rock and dance with a bit of porn in it. Pussy Control= Darling Nikki, Gold = Purple Rain (especially guitar loops) Shh= Computer Blue, Now! = Baby I 'm a star, Dolphin = When doves cry.
17 Years ago I made a commitment to Prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 11/03/05 1:30am

monte

tane1976 said:

None really, every album is different. Prince has such a wide ranging scope of songs its impossible to categorise albums in groups, but if I had to say one album, it would be the Gold experience, straight rock and dance with a bit of porn in it. Pussy Control= Darling Nikki, Gold = Purple Rain (especially guitar loops) Shh= Computer Blue, Now! = Baby I 'm a star, Dolphin = When doves cry.


when you put it song for song it just makes gold worse for me. comparing gold to purple rain (songs) just makes me sad neutral
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 11/03/05 8:09am

Novabreaker

"The Gold Experience" judged by the "live" sound and the songwriting could be seen as the closest one to "Purple Rain". Of course "Around The World In A Day" since it came basically from the same sessions or the ones that immediately followed the recording of "Purple Rain" does have a lot of the same instrumentation and musical ideas, so in that sense it's the closest one.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 11/05/05 9:18am

BEAUGARDE

1999 or Exodus
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 11/05/05 9:36am

sitruk7

I was also gonna say TGE for lack of a better example(Honorable mention to ATWIAD though).They way I'd see it the closest examples could be..

Endorphinmachine/Let's Go Crazy(explosive rocker)

TMBGITW /Take Me With U (pop appeal)

Shhh/The Beautiful Ones(seductive slow jam)

Eye Hate U/ When Doves Cry(heartbreaking expression)

Shy or 319/Darling Nikki(fictional/carnal expirience)

Dolphin/I Would Die 4 U (pop song with spiritual overtones)

Now/Baby I'm A Star(uptempo dance track)

Gold/Purple Rain(pop/rock anthem)
[Edited 11/5/05 9:54am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 11/05/05 3:05pm

BEAUGARDE

Your better off making 1
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 11/05/05 4:55pm

monte

sitruk7 said:

I was also gonna say TGE for lack of a better example(Honorable mention to ATWIAD though).They way I'd see it the closest examples could be..


Eye Hate U/ When Doves Cry(heartbreaking expression)

Shy or 319/Darling Nikki(fictional/carnal expirience)

Dolphin/I Would Die 4 U (pop song with spiritual overtones)

Now/Baby I'm A Star(uptempo dance track)

[Edited 11/5/05 9:54am]


i personally think gold just shouldn't be compared and when it is it just looks worse. i find eye hate you just a ballad. the link between shy or 319 and darling nikki doesn't fit for me. and now is a 90's rap beat while baby i'm a star is pop funk
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 11/05/05 6:43pm

sitruk7

monte said:

sitruk7 said:

I was also gonna say TGE for lack of a better example(Honorable mention to ATWIAD though).They way I'd see it the closest examples could be..


Eye Hate U/ When Doves Cry(heartbreaking expression)

Shy or 319/Darling Nikki(fictional/carnal expirience)

Dolphin/I Would Die 4 U (pop song with spiritual overtones)

Now/Baby I'm A Star(uptempo dance track)

[Edited 11/5/05 9:54am]


i personally think gold just shouldn't be compared and when it is it just looks worse. i find eye hate you just a ballad. the link between shy or 319 and darling nikki doesn't fit for me. and now is a 90's rap beat while baby i'm a star is pop funk
I'm not saying they sound alike per se. I'm trying to find what I feel best answers the question.That's why I used the term "for lack of a better example".
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 11/06/05 12:10am

tane1976

avatar

sitruk7 said:

monte said:



i personally think gold just shouldn't be compared and when it is it just looks worse. i find eye hate you just a ballad. the link between shy or 319 and darling nikki doesn't fit for me. and now is a 90's rap beat while baby i'm a star is pop funk
I'm not saying they sound alike per se. I'm trying to find what I feel best answers the question.That's why I used the term "for lack of a better example".



Ditto with me, I said at the outset of my post, that none were, but TGE is the closest of a very distant lot, struik has done a more detailed analysis of song comparison than me, and I like it.
17 Years ago I made a commitment to Prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 11/06/05 8:02am

sitruk7

Thanks Tane!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 11/06/05 9:55pm

monte

sorry. i don't mean to critisize you both.

i guess i have a problem with gold. the whole album annoys me and i don't understand why people like it so much. i guess if there never was a purple rain i could appreciate it alot more. purple rain and gold seem so similiar in their idea but in practice i find gold stinks. neutral

i am coming round though. i like pussy control, endorphinmachine shhh and now alot
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 11/07/05 6:35am

Paisley4u

avatar

The Gold Experience.
The sound/production is completly different but
still it has that same"feel'2 it.
Love4oneanother
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 11/07/05 7:41am

Novabreaker

Paisley4u said:

The Gold Experience.
The sound/production is completly different but
still it has that same"feel'2 it.


Yeah. And that feel is called "reverb".
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 11/07/05 3:35pm

BEAUGARDE

I don't understand the comparison either, 'Gold Experience' is no 'Purple Rain'. I can listen 2 'Purple Rain' all the thru, but there R just 2 many songs on 'Gold' that I can't get into like 'We March' & 'Shy'. Songs like 'Now', 'Billy Jack Bitch', 'Gold' and 'P Control' have great potential but still lack something (maybe a slammin' remix). And the original version 4 'The Most Beautiful Girl' is superior 2 this album version. As a matter of fact, it seems as if P wasn't trying 4 a hit album, 'cuz the same goes 4 'Come' and 'Chaos & Disorder'. But U can hear hits all over 'Exodus' and 'Emancipation'.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 11/07/05 5:02pm

sitruk7

monte said:

sorry. i don't mean to critisize you both.

i guess i have a problem with gold. the whole album annoys me and i don't understand why people like it so much. i guess if there never was a purple rain i could appreciate it alot more. purple rain and gold seem so similiar in their idea but in practice i find gold stinks. neutral

i am coming round though. i like pussy control, endorphinmachine shhh and now alot
No offense taken Monte! Everybody's entitled to their own opinion!cool
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 11/07/05 5:03pm

monte

i think the only reason it's compared to purple rain because it's the only other time prince has tried to do pure pop and rock. diamonds and pearls was pop but with very little rock and all the other 80's albums following purple rain explored a tottaly different area

i personally think its really sad prince went and did a song like gold
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 11/08/05 1:34am

tane1976

avatar

Yeah ditto, Monte listen to that album and it really grows on u, I actually listened to Sign o the times for the first and didn't like it, but by the 5th listen I realised it was the Rosetta stone of Prince
17 Years ago I made a commitment to Prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 11/08/05 1:41am

vainandy

avatar

If you love "Purple Rain", then "1999" is the one you need to get. The musical style is very similar except it's much stronger and funkier.
Andy is a four letter word.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 11/08/05 1:52am

vainandy

avatar

toejam said:

1999 (1982) has songs in a vein of "When Doves Cry", "Computer Blue" and "Let's Go Crazy", but they're less 'rock' and more 'cold/electronic/funk' sounding.


Exactly. Great description.


On the other side, Around The World In A Day (1985) eleboartes on 'live/warehouse' sound of Purple Rain and it takes it a little further adding a 'psychedelic/world music' influence. "The Ladder" is probably the closest sounding song to "Purple Rain".


The closest thing on "Around The World In A Day" to the "Purple Rain" sound, to me, is "Temptation". It's a rock track like "Let's Go Crazy", just not nearly as fast. It also has the screams that Prince was so well known for before this album. Some of the other tracks had the similar sounding drum machines but the foreign vibe about the songs was the turnoff for me. Actually, the B Sides from that era such as "She's Always In My Hair" and "Hello" are the closest things to the "Purple Rain" sound in the ATWIAD era.
Andy is a four letter word.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 11/08/05 11:55am

BEAUGARDE

I think 'Paisley Park' kinda fits in their, the guitar work sounds like the (weird/great) guitar in the beginning & end of 'Computer Blue'.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 11/08/05 5:20pm

monte

tane1976 said:

Yeah ditto, Monte listen to that album and it really grows on u, I actually listened to Sign o the times for the first and didn't like it, but by the 5th listen I realised it was the Rosetta stone of Prince


no worries guys cool

i've listened to it many many times so i guess i must like it some way. i think some kind of complex where i have to appreciate every prince album, i listen to the ones i hate the most over and over again. gold, chaos, nps and exodus and probably my least favorites. hearing some of the original recordings of gold shows that it's not as good as it could have been. too overproduced. i prefer the undertaker but i do love shhh
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #27 posted 11/09/05 1:51am

Rebeljuice

BEAUGARDE said:

I don't understand the comparison either, 'Gold Experience' is no 'Purple Rain'. I can listen 2 'Purple Rain' all the thru, but there R just 2 many songs on 'Gold' that I can't get into like 'We March' & 'Shy'. Songs like 'Now', 'Billy Jack Bitch', 'Gold' and 'P Control' have great potential but still lack something (maybe a slammin' remix). And the original version 4 'The Most Beautiful Girl' is superior 2 this album version. As a matter of fact, it seems as if P wasn't trying 4 a hit album, 'cuz the same goes 4 'Come' and 'Chaos & Disorder'. But U can hear hits all over 'Exodus' and 'Emancipation'.



But TMBGITW was a massive hit for Prince... I think P did try and make a hit album with TGE, albeit somewhat different to his original plan what with all the supposed configurations that we were meant to get. Come was an odd album, it seemed more of an after thought. And in hidsight knowing what we know now, many tracks on that album have much better versions gathering dust which must have been deliberate.

But I have to say, now that the early to mid 90's have a nostalgic feel to them I am finding it his most experimental kickass period of all. There is so much around that time that never saw the light of day. Its just a shame that all he really blessed us with from that whole sound was TGE and Come... Then it all went pear shaped... smile

As for emancipation... well, you say it is full of hits but I have to disagree. Its rubbish and was the beginning of Prince's wilderness years which in my opinion he has not yet returned from. His creativity and experimentation have never really recovered from the whole symbol shambles...

Incidently, I think the closest sound to PR would have to be ATWIAD. They are the closest in terms of production and it is the production which gives a song/album its sound and feel. TGE is a million miles from PR in terms of sound.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #28 posted 11/09/05 5:28am

monte

Rebeljuice said:

BEAUGARDE said:

I don't understand the comparison either, 'Gold Experience' is no 'Purple Rain'. I can listen 2 'Purple Rain' all the thru, but there R just 2 many songs on 'Gold' that I can't get into like 'We March' & 'Shy'. Songs like 'Now', 'Billy Jack Bitch', 'Gold' and 'P Control' have great potential but still lack something (maybe a slammin' remix). And the original version 4 'The Most Beautiful Girl' is superior 2 this album version. As a matter of fact, it seems as if P wasn't trying 4 a hit album, 'cuz the same goes 4 'Come' and 'Chaos & Disorder'. But U can hear hits all over 'Exodus' and 'Emancipation'.



But TMBGITW was a massive hit for Prince... I think P did try and make a hit album with TGE, albeit somewhat different to his original plan what with all the supposed configurations that we were meant to get. Come was an odd album, it seemed more of an after thought. And in hidsight knowing what we know now, many tracks on that album have much better versions gathering dust which must
have been deliberate.

But I have to say, now that the early to mid 90's have a nostalgic feel to them I am finding it his most experimental kickass period of all. There is so much around that time that never saw the light of day. Its just a shame that all he really blessed us with from that whole sound was TGE and Come... Then it all went pear shaped... smile

As for emancipation... well, you say it is full of hits but I have to disagree. Its rubbish and was the beginning of Prince's wilderness years which in my opinion he has not yet returned from. His creativity and experimentation have never really recovered from the whole symbol shambles...

Incidently, I think the closest sound to PR would have to be ATWIAD. They are the closest in terms of production and it is the production which gives a song/album its sound and feel. TGE is a million miles from PR in terms of sound.



clapping well said (although i do enjoy prince music from the last 4 years)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Similiar Albums...