DavidEye said:

Where u at her concert? How many have u paid 2 go see? And yes it does matter 2 u how many people buy her CD's. How many of them do u own? Baby its not that serious 4 u 2 get all pissed off behind your material girl LOL

metalorange said:

Good points.

I remember getting the Entertainment Weekly with P on the cover and the counter ladies had no idea who he was. Now if it was Madonna..I am certain they would know.

But Madonna has never "left" the music scene...she continues to get her stuff played. Music was big and so was Ray of light...putting out songs that will endure for a long time...she still doing classics. Though I am not sure how popular the latest singles were (I don't think that big). American Life, though going number one was actually not that big seller for her.

Even with Musicology, he still has not had a big hit (single) in a long time.

Dumb question.

Of course Madonna is bigger.

Britney Spears is bigger.

Justin Timberlake is bigger.

Even Michael Jackson is bigger.

Does it matter?

No.

priceless said:

Never
in
his
wildest
dreams

...@least he dont 4get the words 2 his songs in concert...

Look what Parade magazine had to say about Prince and Madonna in an August issue:

Q. People once dismissed Prince as a bizarre has-been. Now he’s in the midst of a great musical comeback. How do you account for his sudden new popularity?
—Talia T., Washington, D.C.

A. Dazzling musicianship, brilliant marketing (he funds his own projects, presses his own CDs and sells his music directly to fans) and a newfound spirituality (the singer converted to the Jehovah’s Witness faith). And we’d add another factor: Unlike Madonna—who turns 46 this month and is still trying to woo audiences with showmanship and sexuality—Prince Rogers Nelson, also 46, is making beautiful music.

dustysgirl said:

This is exactly what I have been saying about Madonna and her live performances and this is coming from a unbiased point of view. Not Madonna fans not Prince fans and I have seen many statements like this about The Material Girl. but the Madonna apologists will of course vehemently dispute these statements.

metalorange said:

They influenced pop-culture? They both have claimed it for themselves.

DavidEye said:

Now, that's what i like to hear.

meow85 said:

I didn't ask if he's TALLER!

gman1966 said:

Micheal Jackson is a rip-off himself; what goes around...

lolinex said:

WELL SAID!
This is the most sensible post i've read so far.
Thank you for sharing your honest opinion.

priceless said:

Who said she is being irresoponsible? My mother would always explain things to me that i saw that she thought needed explaintion. She would curse in front of me than appoligize and explain that cursing makes you sound ignorant ad obsence to people. She left it to us to decide when it is apporiate to do that. She also took my brother and I to R rated movies at a very young age and would explain to us what was going on if we couldn't understand it. From what I've seen of Madonna she takes good care of her children, and is there for them when they need her. According to her ABC interview Lourdes has a hard time at school because she can't trust people to be her friends. always wondering if they want to be her friend or meet her mother.
Prince and Madonna both have shaped and influneced pop culture and music.... Madonna just places the emphasis on the Visual. Howerver ask anyone that works for her on tour... the image can not take away from the MUSIC. The songs are what we remember the songs are what brought us there. She writes simple catchy lyrics and has them put on amazing dance tracks. 36 top 5 hits more than anyone else but Elvis. 38 dance #1's more than anyone else. She may not be the worldest greatest Singer but she has written some of the best pop songs of the past 20 years... Live to Tell still gives me goosebumps.

dustysgirl said:

Obviously the writer of this statement hasn't a clue to save their life. They mention Madonna still using sexuality, when she hasn't in such a long time. If the kiss between her and Britney is what they consider sexual, get real cause that's far from sexual. Meanwhile we still have Janet taking off her clothes, and they say nothing about her....

Madonna will probably make Rock&Roll HOF, but thats because shes gonna whine her way there.


She hasn't done jack if you think bout it. Come on, name off her hits for me. They all give credits to someone else. Only thing she gets is credit for her stage performance and her singing. Stage, thats just her ego, like a crazy stripper. Singing? She can't.

LightO****

said:

BITCH! Yes, I like Like a Prayer. But one song, outta about 300, doesn't qualify as anyone with talent or worth listening to.

Luv & Peace,
Alex
Did rock just officially die?

priceless said:

And KISS has more than Madonna. Are you gonna tell me that they're currently bigger than either Madonna or Prince, just cuz they sell a generic coffin?

Luv & Peace,
Alex
Did rock just officially die?

DavidEye said:

'Nuff said. Madonna's a corporate whore. How long 'til she kisses Alicia Keyes?

Luv & Peace,
Alex
Did rock just officially die?

sloopydrew4u said:

And to think how many STDs Spears picked up off that kiss. Just for the publicity...., now thats a ho!

Rockability said:

She BEGGED to perform at the Republican National Convention. Whattdaya expect?

Bush was all for it, until the nazis in the party protested, being that Britney dresses "sinfully."

Luv & Peace,
Alex
Did rock just officially die?

Rockability said:

Ummm if you look at the liner noter, which you have not you would see that she writes and co-produces most of her material. Something not even Elvis did.
Unless you actually know what you're talking about, it's safer to keep quiet.

jayaredee said:

LOL, whats she write then besides shit. IF she manages to get her name on the writing, it was probably because of her powerful ego pull.

She sucks, all there is to it.

Rockability said:

Well that's your opinion, but when you say she doesn't write her own music that's just slander.

"Well that's your opinion"




Thats a fact, you should know what a songwriter is being a member here. Madonna is a performer, nothing more. That isn't a controversial statement and really isn't up for debate. She can dance and had great writers/producers, etc. etc.

I'll give her credit for having enough talent to accept the songs that were written for her as good. Elvis, on the other hand, could at least sing! And in his day, singing the way he was just bout put a bounty on his head. No comparison there.

Rockability said:

Well it's my opinion that she can sing and it's my opinion she can write.

Gonna stop me from having an opinion because you think what you say is a fact?

LOL, i'll agree with you there. You can always have an opinion against a fact. Maybe one day an opinion will turn the fact to false, at least if you listen to it long enough.

Rockability said:

It's not a fact, but you can continue to slander all you wish.

And there's no such thing as an opinion against a fact, it's technicall, ummmm, impossible???

Please stop making yourself look like an ass

Slander? She can't write!!!!!

She can try.


She can't sing, she can try.


You probably don't know that her voice sounds nice through recordings because of the tweaks they have to do during the recording process. I mean, damn, her voice needs to be adjusted, cause she is the closest to tone-deaf of the so-called artists out there.

Good night!!!!

Rockability said:

No, i think she can sing because i've seen her live. I never said she was Mariah or Celine.

Sweet Dreams!