independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > IS PRINCE A RELIGION IN HIS OWN RIGHT?
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 2 of 3 <123>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #30 posted 08/13/04 6:00pm

melinda

avatar

urthighs said:

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music,
so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????


Prince is just a human beeing, genuis only, himself need God like any human being wink
Melinda
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #31 posted 08/13/04 6:13pm

ThePurpleHippi
e

avatar

like a friend (big fan of the beatles) of mine says: the beatles r my god coz i got prove that they exist...and some kind of way i think the same...besides i'm a strong beliver that we were spawned by aliens or some kinda shit like that...what if christ was an alien?...
if prince is a religion or not dunno but we as fams we follow him as some people follow a piece of paper known as the bible which got like 20 different versions...
Say it loud eye'm a Prince fam and eye'm proud! - the purple revolution has begun!
[formerly known as purpleaxxe]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #32 posted 08/13/04 6:14pm

Zelaira

Prince Can EASILY Be a PREACHER.... Maybe he will Be a Preacher One Day...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #33 posted 08/13/04 7:13pm

CalhounSq

avatar

BAIT... at least I hope so for your sake sad disbelief
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #34 posted 08/13/04 7:16pm

CalhounSq

avatar

Marrk said:

Moonwalkbjrain said:



i don't think so...but what ever floats ur boat.....


Naah, don't sit on the fence.

urthighs, you're a nutjob, complete fruitcake. go get yourself sectioned or at least see a shrink. You're heading for a rubber room, ya complete loony.


evillol That's COLD! UrThighs needs help y'all smile Or at least a life outside of Prince hmm comfort
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #35 posted 08/13/04 7:19pm

Emancipation88

avatar

hah!

urthighs said:

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music,
so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????


Worlds most beloved Orger

eye'm like Sam the butcher bringing Alice the meat
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #36 posted 08/13/04 7:28pm

Zelaira

Well, I get ya in the regard that Prince's Music can be Uplifting and make ya High. Yes,Prince can make ya Happy. It's quite a Full Joyous Feeling.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #37 posted 08/13/04 8:08pm

prodigalfan

avatar

SquirrelMeat said:

Isn't this almost exactly how Mark Chapman felt?

nod

It is a sad thing, but I think we have several "Mark Chapman"'s here. I never realize the real risk of being a celebrity is. No wonder they have body guards.

Peace and Sanity, grouphug
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #38 posted 08/13/04 8:15pm

Zelaira

That guy was a Crazy Sick Nutcase who took Lennon's Life..I wish I Could Shoot him for killing another one of my Idols who was Totally About Love and Goodness. He took Music from us....An INNOCENT ARTIST who's Life was Snuffed out by a DERANGED Sould who CLAIMED he was a Fan? What kinda Fan Kills their IDOL? Plus he wrote His name John Lennon.Psycho Chapman thought he was Lennon..What about those Manson Followers? Killing Innocent people? Please Life is so Sick and so Sad.. People don't Love Enough... Ya try 2 be good nd some Mental Meanie Hurts ya...Very Sad...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #39 posted 08/13/04 8:21pm

prodigalfan

avatar

Zogmuffin said:

urthighs said:

what a negative response i thought u all loved him.


We do love him, but we don't think he's a religion.

nod
I will go even further, I love his music and related work... I don't know him to love him.
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #40 posted 08/13/04 8:52pm

sosgemini

avatar

WRONG FORUM!!
Space for sale...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #41 posted 08/14/04 4:09am

Lleena

oneSophia said:

Handclapsfingasnapz said:


is that your "yes" or "no"?


That...is an interpretation. If one were to subscribe to this, then perhaps a 'person' could in fact be another's religion.


not really. By definition, religion is the worship of of a supernatural power or god. Elevating Prince to the realms of a deity just because you like his albums does not qualify him as some sort of divine being.

He's a musician a very talented one, thats all, end of story.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #42 posted 08/14/04 6:19am

DTrickyB

avatar

Does "false idols" ring a bell with anyone here?

If not, ya need to get busy with the King James Version!

I'm not all Holy, but I now the basics.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #43 posted 08/14/04 6:21am

DTrickyB

avatar

P.S.....

Those who feel that Prince is a religion or god, I truly feel sorry for.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #44 posted 08/14/04 8:10am

deebee

avatar

Lleena said:

oneSophia said:



That...is an interpretation. If one were to subscribe to this, then perhaps a 'person' could in fact be another's religion.


not really. By definition, religion is the worship of of a supernatural power or god.

Actually, there is some debate regarding what "defines" a religion, with some accounts being more inclusive than others.

If we were to take the above definition, Buddhism, for example, would not qualify, as its followers do not believe that Buddha was a God, a prophet, or any kind of supernatural being - he was born and died a man. Nor did he teach that a God created the universe, merely that a law (or Dharma) runs through it, and one can find freedom from suffering by living in accordance with this.

If you always make Judeo-Christian beliefs the starting point for any inquiry, and compare everything else to them, then it is a small wonder that they'll always come out on top - seeming more valid than everything else. But this says more about the perspective of the person making the comparison, than it does about the relative "validity" of the belief systems being compared.
[This message was edited Sat Aug 14 8:13:43 2004 by deebee]
"Not everything that is faced can be changed; but nothing can be changed until it is faced." - James Baldwin
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #45 posted 08/14/04 10:52am

BlaqueKnight

avatar

Lleena said:

oneSophia said:



That...is an interpretation. If one were to subscribe to this, then perhaps a 'person' could in fact be another's religion.


not really. By definition, religion is the worship of of a supernatural power or god. Elevating Prince to the realms of a deity just because you like his albums does not qualify him as some sort of divine being.

He's a musician a very talented one, thats all, end of story.



Thank you.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #46 posted 08/14/04 3:33pm

kev1n

avatar

so is prince a kind of god u tell me,


It was not in vain...it was in Minneapolis!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #47 posted 08/14/04 5:06pm

melinda

avatar

deebee said:

Lleena said:



not really. By definition, religion is the worship of of a supernatural power or god.

Actually, there is some debate regarding what "defines" a religion, with some accounts being more inclusive than others.

If we were to take the above definition, Buddhism, for example, would not qualify, as its followers do not believe that Buddha was a God, a prophet, or any kind of supernatural being - he was born and died a man. Nor did he teach that a God created the universe, merely that a law (or Dharma) runs through it, and one can find freedom from suffering by living in accordance with this.

If you always make Judeo-Christian beliefs the starting point for any inquiry, and compare everything else to them, then it is a small wonder that they'll always come out on top - seeming more valid than everything else. But this says more about the perspective of the person making the comparison, than it does about the relative "validity" of the belief systems being compared.
[This message was edited Sat Aug 14 8:13:43 2004 by deebee]


But all prophets were human, they were born and died ,they delivered message , as Buddha delivered one, different but always to make the human beeing happy,good and free.
Melinda
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #48 posted 08/14/04 5:20pm

sumtymes

urthighs said:

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music,
so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????






please be careful how far

u take your admiration

4 prince

prince is a man

men make mistakes

God has blessed him

with tremendous talent

however, he is human

like u and me

love God

all else falls into place

peace
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #49 posted 08/14/04 7:05pm

CalhounSq

avatar

prodigalfan said:

Zogmuffin said:



We do love him, but we don't think he's a religion.

nod
I will go even further, I love his music and related work... I don't know him to love him.


And I will go even further & admit to loving him despite not knowing him personally eek
heart prince I never met you, but I LOVE you & I will forever!! Thank you for being YOU - my little Princey, the best to EVER do it prince heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #50 posted 08/14/04 7:49pm

butterfli25

avatar

You know reading this had made me think, and I remember being this way about prince. Needing to hear his music everyday all day. becoming severely depressed at the end of a tour, feeling down and turning to his music. reading newspapers and billbord magazines to see where he was everyday. travling all over the sate of california to get rare recordings, meeting people who were as obsessed as I was. We used to have sessions in the library at my college watch Prince videos and analyzing them. We used to listen to every word every song and wonder what he meant. I was truly obsessed.
I must say that when I go to concerts it still feels like a religious experience. there is worship going on in there. But as I grew older and really realized what a hard time he has emotionally, spiritually etc..His eary life sucked, he struggled and was hungry, he ran away from home several times, he was a lost child who had to make a way on his own. He was just like several people that I knew, I thought damn he's just a man. I was disappointed when I really realized that, but then I realized that it was the music all along. It was the message that I took from each recording. It was his ability to make the music that appealed to me when i was sad, lonely, happy, amused, joyous and just going through it. I realized that he made the music he chose to what ever his reason and it was what I brought to and got out of that experience that made it so good for me. His music is a huge part of the soundtrack of my life. His music is what matters most to me. I love that man, mainly because his sound and creations have been a part of my life for so long. But he is a man.

I like the point made about taking everything from a Christian point of view. It is true that Christianity is set up to make everything else look inferior. One has to decide what religion is best for them.
That said, the feelings that are experienced by some people could be closely identified with how a religion makes one feel, as scary as that is I understand it. I just hope that when the realization that Prince is a man who does not want to be considered a god comes, it can be handled with out too much disappointment and sadness.

On the John Lennon tip...yeah Mark David Chapman disbelief

what about that "fan" who killed Serena the tejano singer...she was the president of her fan club and worship her.

Scary what is out there for the celebrities. very scary

just my twocents
butterfly
We all should know that diversity makes for a rich tapestry, and we must understand that all the threads of the tapestry are equal in value no matter what their color.
Maya Angelou
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #51 posted 08/15/04 4:45am

Lleena

deebee said:

Lleena said:



not really. By definition, religion is the worship of of a supernatural power or god.

Actually, there is some debate regarding what "defines" a religion, with some accounts being more inclusive than others.

If we were to take the above definition, Buddhism, for example, would not qualify, as its followers do not believe that Buddha was a God, a prophet, or any kind of supernatural being - he was born and died a man. Nor did he teach that a God created the universe, merely that a law (or Dharma) runs through it, and one can find freedom from suffering by living in accordance with this.

If you always make Judeo-Christian beliefs the starting point for any inquiry, and compare everything else to them, then it is a small wonder that they'll always come out on top - seeming more valid than everything else. But this says more about the perspective of the person making the comparison, than it does about the relative "validity" of the belief systems being compared.
[This message was edited Sat Aug 14 8:13:43 2004 by deebee]



Equating Prince with a spritual leader such as Buddha is one giant leap I'm not willing to make. According to your logic anyone with talent could be considered a religion, Why not David Bowie or Sting?

Buddha rejected the notion of divinity, he was a spiritual teacher, a sage. Somebody who lived an ascetic life and reached the ultimate enlightenment, i.e Nirvana, he passed on his knowledge through the Dharma. Lets not lose sight of the fact that prince is fundamentally a musician, not a spiritual leader. Although his music may have the power to uplift, this does not a religion make.

He wears heels for gods sake. lol

darn!
[This message was edited Sun Aug 15 5:08:17 2004 by Lleena]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #52 posted 08/15/04 5:01am

Moonwalkbjrain

avatar

melinda said:

deebee said:


Actually, there is some debate regarding what "defines" a religion, with some accounts being more inclusive than others.

If we were to take the above definition, Buddhism, for example, would not qualify, as its followers do not believe that Buddha was a God, a prophet, or any kind of supernatural being - he was born and died a man. Nor did he teach that a God created the universe, merely that a law (or Dharma) runs through it, and one can find freedom from suffering by living in accordance with this.

If you always make Judeo-Christian beliefs the starting point for any inquiry, and compare everything else to them, then it is a small wonder that they'll always come out on top - seeming more valid than everything else. But this says more about the perspective of the person making the comparison, than it does about the relative "validity" of the belief systems being compared.
[This message was edited Sat Aug 14 8:13:43 2004 by deebee]


But all prophets were human, they were born and died ,they delivered message , as Buddha delivered one, different but always to make the human beeing happy,good and free.


yup. hell Jesus was human. he was born and died. who r we to say that prince is no differnt? a prophet of sorts. sending different messages thru his music..especially that whole God vs. sex message...hell i'll go even further to say who r we to say that Prince may not even be the second comming (b4 u all jump on my ass no i do not think this i'm just agreein wit the above point. i believe in God the most high thank u very much)...if this is what urthighs would like to believe i aint goin knock him for it (altho i came reeeeel close)...all i gotta say is don't "worship him" u feel me...if he makes u happy and u like listenin thats all good n gravy..but don't worship as if he IS the second comming or a prophet or anything "godly" u feel me...also since ur not very religious...maybe u should b.
Yesterday is dead...tomorrow hasnt arrived yet....i have just ONE day...
...And i'm gonna be groovy in it!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #53 posted 08/15/04 2:10pm

melinda

avatar

Moonwalkbjrain said:

melinda said:



But all prophets were human, they were born and died ,they delivered message , as Buddha delivered one, different but always to make the human beeing happy,good and free.


yup. hell Jesus was human. he was born and died. who r we to say that prince is no differnt? a prophet of sorts. sending different messages thru his music..especially that whole God vs. sex message...hell i'll go even further to say who r we to say that Prince may not even be the second comming (b4 u all jump on my ass no i do not think this i'm just agreein wit the above point. i believe in God the most high thank u very much)...if this is what urthighs would like to believe i aint goin knock him for it (altho i came reeeeel close)...all i gotta say is don't "worship him" u feel me...if he makes u happy and u like listenin thats all good n gravy..but don't worship as if he IS the second comming or a prophet or anything "godly" u feel me...also since ur not very religious...maybe u should b.

Prince is not a prophet , this i am sure , thank you.
Melinda
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #54 posted 08/17/04 1:45am

wasitgood4u

avatar

Yeah, the original post was pretty whack, and confusing idolization with idolatry is pretty dangerous, but not all that surprising.

OTOH, if we ignore P the man, and look at his oeuvre (his "body of work"), there are fascinating systems of symbols, ideas, philosophies, myths and stories, which link together and form the basis of a fairly coherent world-view. This is not unlike the foundations of many religions. THis is also one thing that always appealed to me about P's output. I think it COULD b turned into the basis of a complex and satisfying network of beliefs. This is NOT the same as any pop-star or musician. The Lennon comparison is actually interesting because he also tried to create stories that linked together a philosophy and world-view, but I think P has always done it in a more interesting way. He has invented symbols, and terminology which is specific to his "religion", and only "followers" understand it, although even then it is always open to interpretation and reinterpretation by others using other examples of its usage (I'm thinking of terms like "Uptown", "New Power", "Lovesexy", "power fantastic", "the dawn", "love4oneanother" etc).
U could take this a lot further - because he intentionally mimics religious system's iconoclature. He has a symbol which represents himself (I can only think of one other historical figure like that!!!). He has a holy city (MPLS) which exists more as an idea than a reality. He even has his own system of writing (which I use 2, but mainly coz I'm inherently lazy!). His use of mystery and ambiguity, creating meaning in the gaps between texts, or by merging other texts (like in his symbol) provides a depth which echoes the profundity of religious textuality.
The cultic nature of NPGMC needs no reiteration.

None of the above has anything to do with the hero-worship BS that urthighs and others were talking about. I just wanted to point out how the structure of "Prince" as a text, not as a person, has a lot in common with religious textuality. This is without even delving into the contents of the philosophies, the whole lovesexy/lovedivine thing etc.
"We've never been able to pull off a funk number"

"That's becuase we're soulless auttomatons"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #55 posted 08/17/04 1:47am

sloopydrew4u

avatar

Ugh. I'll reserve comment, because anything I say regarding this topic would come off as far too mean.

Prince a religion in his own right? Please listen to what you're typing.

Luv & Peace,
Alex
Clubbin' in Mpls/A Night w. Prince
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #56 posted 08/17/04 2:35am

BlaqueKnight

avatar

Some of these post seem to carry the subtle justification of idolworship. If your first experiences with certain types of knowledge are through Prince that's fine, but I personally have not heard Prince say anything that hasn't been said before. Love Is God, God is Love - go to church and you'll hear the same thing. Prince is no prophet. He is an entertainer who plays instruments well and had a helluva public relations campaign funded by WB. Faith in man is faith in failure. If you all want to subscribe to a Prince-based belief system, go right ahead. think about this: If Prince believed all of his own bullshit, he would seek a following. Instead, he has chosen the JWs. If your "leader" is a follower, then what are you?

He/She who believes in nothing will fall for anything.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #57 posted 08/17/04 6:43am

Hotlegs

urthighs said:

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music,
so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????


Prince is not a religion. But, he is part of movement by artist to get their fans to see past the smokescreen of bullshit that the media has created.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #58 posted 08/17/04 8:33am

mdd

avatar

TheDreamingPeasant said:

IS PRINCE A RELIGION IN HIS OWN RIGHT?

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music, so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????


I'm not religious either, but when it comes to PRINCE, he is almost like my "GOD" -- I know, I know, he sings, now, "He's your messiah ..." but I can't help but to see Prince in that way. I listen to him everyday. I can't help it. I still sing (at the concerts): "I'm your Messiah..."

It took some time for me to not feel "sad" whenever I thought about me never ever knowing PRINCE at all. I'm still not quite over it. When I realized that I might not ever know PRINCE, it was like realizing everyone has to die.

One time, I was shopping, and I was looking for something for the PRINCE concert at Club Black in NEW YORK and the sales person asked, "What are you looking for?" and I said, "Something to wear to the PRINCE concert" and she said, "If ain't GOD, I ain't going to see anyone in concert." Then she started to talk about how too many people worship stars and need to believe in GOD and go to church.

And then I'm waiting in line for the concert at Club Black and I am freezing and this girl says, "You'd think PRINCE is God the way I'm freezing out here ..."

This was around the time, I think, Passions of the Christ was at the theaters and everyone ('cept me) was on that trip.

I'm not religious, but most people tell me I live as though I am in a nunnery because the way I eat (my strict diet) and resisting temptation (like drugs, alcohol). I guess since I don't go to church, I "worship" everything else -- like PRINCE and John Mayer.

Well, is Prince a religion in his own right? To me he is.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #59 posted 08/17/04 8:39am

mdd

avatar

TheDreamingPeasant said:

IS PRINCE A RELIGION IN HIS OWN RIGHT?

im not religious in the slightest but i do follow prince in whatever he says and whatever he does regarding his music, so if i dont listen 2 him or watch him i feel empty,
so i feel as though i need 2 feel his vibe everyday.
just like people feel god, so is prince a kind of god u tell me, do u feel the same????


I'm not religious either, but when it comes to PRINCE, he is almost like my "GOD" -- I know, I know, he sings, now, "He's your messiah ..." but I can't help but to see Prince in that way. I listen to him everyday. I can't help it. I still sing (at the concerts): "I'm your Messiah..."

It took some time for me to not feel "sad" whenever I thought about me never ever knowing PRINCE at all. I'm still not quite over it. When I realized that I might not ever know PRINCE, it was like realizing everyone has to die.

One time, I was shopping, and I was looking for something for the PRINCE concert at Club Black in NEW YORK and the sales person asked, "What are you looking for?" and I said, "Something to wear to the PRINCE concert" and she said, "If ain't GOD, I ain't going to see anyone in concert." Then she started to talk about how too many people worship stars and need to believe in GOD and go to church.

And then I'm waiting in line for the concert at Club Black and I am freezing and this girl says, "You'd think PRINCE is God the way I'm freezing out here ..."

This was around the time, I think, Passions of the Christ was at the theaters and everyone ('cept me) was on that trip.

I'm not religious, but most people tell me I live as though I am in a nunnery because the way I eat (my strict diet) and resisting temptation (like drugs, alcohol). I guess since I don't go to church, I "worship" everything else -- like PRINCE and John Mayer.

Well, is Prince a religion in his own right? To me he is.

[b]Nothing against you,but i think you need some professional help to see others reasons to fell good and happy besides worshiping Prince.He is briliant i agree but a God? be carfull.....
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 2 of 3 <123>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > IS PRINCE A RELIGION IN HIS OWN RIGHT?