JasmineFire said:

Because Simon says stuff like "you're staying in this competition".

To quote Paula, Simon should "Knock it off!".

I can't believe I'm saying this, but:

Latoya and Diana were my faves tonite!

poor Fantasia may be in trouble

ps...RED HAS GOT TO GO!!!!!

Aerogram said:

oh

paula paulaa paula

do you have a real opinion in that head of yours

just bland

mimickery

SimonCowell said:

your handsome

What are we talking about?

starkitty said:

the sun moon and stars

are not the same

as they were . . .


yesterday

endorphin74 said:

Fantasia stunk this week. So did George (who's never been any good). Latoya was barely better. Jasmine and Diana were the two best this week.

TheFrog said:

Oh Simon I love your accent

alandail said:

In my opinion, they ALL sucked tonight.

Gee, could it be because they were singing songs that sucked?

Um Yup.

When I heard that the theme was Gloria Estefan, I wasn't really excited about the choice. Overall I didn't think her songs worked for the competition that is really trying to showoff the range of the contestants. It forced them to incorporate more movement which wasn't bad. John should have been gone at least four weeks ago when he messed up the first time. It makes me flashback to when Tamyra had an off night and was gone just like that. But no we get stuck with John hanging in there just because his fans vote like crazy. All I can say is if he is still there a week from tomorrow, he would have a good chance to take it all just because of the wacky voters, and ultimately America will get what they deserve.

Nobody was outstanding, but I enjoyed Diana, LaToya, and Fantasia.

SimonCowell said:

Indeed

I would sing, but I'm baking a cake. sorry.

alandail said:

JASMINE???? For real? it's always good to be rmeinded of how diverse people's tastes can be. And how subjective talent is. Jasmine about pushed me over the edge last nite.

I will say, Mr George Huff has COMPLETELY lost his way the last 3 weeks. I was never a big 'fan' of his, but his recent performances have gotten me totally over him.


...not awake yet...
[This message was edited Wed Apr 28 4:44:29 2004 by endorphin74]

So, tonight we see what totally incompetent boob you Americans think should be in the running to be your Idol.

And tomorrow we get to see what the totally incompetent boob whom you Americans didn't vote in has to say to the 9-11 commission.

Lleena said:

You could always sing MacArthur Park.

Hopefully, no one will ever know you don't dance due to bouncy man boobs.

Latoya is gonna stay but fantasia will go soon, she has the voice , but lacks charisma, and looks that everyone wants, but after this past show, diana is gonna be around for a while yet... she was better then the rest this week

SimonCowell said:

Simon can u judge my music?