independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > General Discussion > Man decapitates passenger aboard Greyhound bus in Manitoba:
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 5 of 8 <12345678>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #120 posted 08/02/08 4:32pm

paintedlady

avatar

WillyWonka said:

JustErin said:

The passengers did everything right.



I agree.

With all due respect... I disagree, but you can never tell/expect another person to put their lives in danger for a stranger, so in that sense they get over on allowing someone to be slain in front of them.

Me personally, I would have done something, anything.... goes to show that if you are in a battle for your life... you are on your own. confused
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #121 posted 08/02/08 4:38pm

paintedlady

avatar

emm said:

the victim's family didn't know until 10 1/2 hours after this thread was started. how messed up is that? sad

That breaks my heart cry this story is just so awful.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #122 posted 08/02/08 4:53pm

violator

JustErin said:

WillyWonka said:




I understand your emotion and passion about this situation and applaud your bravado, but I think you're being rather harsh and unfair in calling the other passengers "cowards" because of their reaction/s. You must realize that being an armchair speculator after the fact vs. actually being there while such carnage is happening and seeing the spurting gore and unimaginable violence firsthand, are two wildly incomparable scenarios. It's not really possible to predict how you would have reacted were you there; you are writing your indignant opinion from the safety and comfort of your home or office, able to utilize logic and better judgement than were the passengers who suddenly, out of the clear blue, were awakened to or became aware of the horrible murder that happened so suddenly on that bus.

Many people were asleep, were listening to a movie or to music on headphones, or were otherwise occupied when, with no forewarning whatsoever, they heard a terrible scream and turned around to see that young man being violently butchered. Seeing such an unexpected atrocity - especially if just jarred awake from sleep - would understandably throw the human mind into a disconnect, with the first instinct being to flee.

Perhaps some of the passengers will wonder if there was something they might've done to help or to have saved that young victim's life, and will feel guilt -- but the reality is that this incident occured so quickly and in such close quarters and was of such a bizarre, extreme nature that there really was little that could have been done to help that young man at the point where people realized with any clarity what was going on.


The passengers did everything right.


Yeah, I agree. I can't blame anyone for not getting physically involved beyond the point they did (apparently they kept the guy on the bus until the police arrived), although I'd like to think that in a similar situation there's something I could have done to help that guy. But that's an individual's call, not anyone's duty.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #123 posted 08/02/08 6:38pm

WillyWonka

paintedlady said:

WillyWonka said:




I agree.

With all due respect... I disagree, but you can never tell/expect another person to put their lives in danger for a stranger, so in that sense they get over on allowing someone to be slain in front of them.

Me personally, I would have done something, anything.... goes to show that if you are in a battle for your life... you are on your own. confused



I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #124 posted 08/02/08 7:11pm

paintedlady

avatar

WillyWonka said:

paintedlady said:


With all due respect... I disagree, but you can never tell/expect another person to put their lives in danger for a stranger, so in that sense they get over on allowing someone to be slain in front of them.

Me personally, I would have done something, anything.... goes to show that if you are in a battle for your life... you are on your own. confused



I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?


knock him down... get the knife away. I am one of those people that isn't too trusting so I always have some shit on me... I grew up in a tough neighborhood and watched (as a kid, I was about 13) as a young guy (Willie) was cut open and gutted on a street. He died but I watched other women take his the killer's ass down, they fought back, and the machete was taken from him. I had a gun to my head also before...I had no help, I had to help myself, I am still here, but I could not live with myself if anyone died with NO help.

Some just don't want to be involved, I think it is a responsibility to look out for your fellow man. You either watch or you help. This was an extreme case, but I've seen men fight off other men with guns in protection of strangers (Charlie's Hick's dad rose) He saved a teen's life he didn't know... that is called heroism and some people will either help or not.

I think you have to be desensitized from violence I guess, to not be afraid to help.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #125 posted 08/02/08 9:23pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

pplrain said:


I think in the USA people are chicken shit when it comes to protecting / helping each other. They don't want to interfere.


Maybe so...but, uhm....this story takes place in Canada.
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #126 posted 08/02/08 9:28pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

...and as if this story weren't grisly enough as it were;

Police tape: Canada bus killer ate victim's flesh
By CHARMAINE NORONHA, Associated Press Writer
Sat Aug 2, 7:43 PM ET

TORONTO - A police officer at the scene of a grisly beheading on a Canadian bus reported seeing the attacker hacking off pieces of the victim's body and eating them, according to a police tape leaked on the Internet Saturday.

In the tape of radio transmissions, a Royal Canadian Mounted Police officer refers to the attacker as "Badger" and says he is armed with a knife and scissors and is "defiling the body at the front of the bus as we speak."

On the tape, which lasts about 80 seconds, officers continue to detail the attacker's movements until one reports, "Badger's at the back of the bus, hacking off pieces and eating it."
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #127 posted 08/02/08 9:29pm

Muse2NOPharaoh

PurpleJedi said:

pplrain said:


I think in the USA people are chicken shit when it comes to protecting / helping each other. They don't want to interfere.


Maybe so...but, uhm....this story takes place in Canada.

lol and the Canadian individuals kept the living dead freak trapped in the disabled bus until the cops arrived.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #128 posted 08/02/08 9:32pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

Muse2NOPharaoh said:

PurpleJedi said:



Maybe so...but, uhm....this story takes place in Canada.

lol and the Canadian individuals kept the living dead freak trapped in the disabled bus until the cops arrived.


lol
There is NOTHING funny about this horrific story...but LOL @ that! That wacko probably saw one-too-many "zombie" movies.
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #129 posted 08/02/08 9:43pm

Muse2NOPharaoh

TheMistress said:

Bishop31 said:



Really?? And u believe in God. I see.


Yes. When He goes bowling and makes it thunder I hide under my bed.

Thats not bowling... Its moving furniture around.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #130 posted 08/02/08 9:52pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

Muse2NOPharaoh said:

TheMistress said:



Yes. When He goes bowling and makes it thunder I hide under my bed.

Thats not bowling... Its moving furniture around.


falloff
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #131 posted 08/02/08 9:57pm

Muse2NOPharaoh

missfee said:

this is one sick story. i was highly disturbed when I read it. it's crazy to think somebody would do that to another stranger for no reason at all. what i'm most upset about is, why are they just charging the psycho with second degree murder??? isn't this vicious crime considered first degree???!!! What is going on here?

I have this horrible habit of leaving the news channels on as i drift off to sleep. I remember hearing this story in the really early hours and shake regretting my habit.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #132 posted 08/02/08 10:06pm

Muse2NOPharaoh

PurpleJedi said:

Muse2NOPharaoh said:


lol and the Canadian individuals kept the living dead freak trapped in the disabled bus until the cops arrived.


lol
There is NOTHING funny about this horrific story...but LOL @ that! That wacko probably saw one-too-many "zombie" movies.

I found it funny that the above individual claimed American inferiority ... whilst in fact it occurred in Canada and the bus driver disabled the vehicle and the Canadians made certain the living dead freak ( code for human without a soul) remained trapped until authorities arrived. KUDOS to their bravery!

I reject every attempt of any individuals to claim greater humanity for their respective countries. Its crap, people are people wherever you go!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #133 posted 08/02/08 10:09pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

Muse2NOPharaoh said:


I reject every attempt of any individuals to claim greater humanity for their respective countries. Its crap, people are people wherever you go!


nod
Every society has its saints and its sinners and its pathological deviants.
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #134 posted 08/02/08 10:15pm

Muse2NOPharaoh

PurpleJedi said:

Muse2NOPharaoh said:


I reject every attempt of any individuals to claim greater humanity for their respective countries. Its crap, people are people wherever you go!


nod
Every society has its saints and its sinners and its pathological deviants.

nod the DNA variance runs through them all!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #135 posted 08/03/08 12:01am

pplrain

avatar

PurpleJedi said:

pplrain said:


I think in the USA people are chicken shit when it comes to protecting / helping each other. They don't want to interfere.


Maybe so...but, uhm....this story takes place in Canada.



Yeah I know same difference. The guy had a knife not a gun. How can a bus full of people not throw a bag at him and corner him or stop him. confused
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #136 posted 08/03/08 1:10am

wildgoldenhone
y

WillyWonka said:

paintedlady said:


With all due respect... I disagree, but you can never tell/expect another person to put their lives in danger for a stranger, so in that sense they get over on allowing someone to be slain in front of them.

Me personally, I would have done something, anything.... goes to show that if you are in a battle for your life... you are on your own. confused



I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?

To tell the truth, I know what I said I would do earlier,
but when actually in that situation, and caught off guard, I just might have reacted the same way that the passengers reacted.

But I'm sure if just one person started to defend that guy, others who may have been shocked initially, would have jumped in too.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #137 posted 08/03/08 5:50am

WillyWonka

paintedlady said:

WillyWonka said:




I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?


knock him down... get the knife away. I am one of those people that isn't too trusting so I always have some shit on me... I grew up in a tough neighborhood and watched (as a kid, I was about 13) as a young guy (Willie) was cut open and gutted on a street. He died but I watched other women take his the killer's ass down, they fought back, and the machete was taken from him. I had a gun to my head also before...I had no help, I had to help myself, I am still here, but I could not live with myself if anyone died with NO help.

Some just don't want to be involved, I think it is a responsibility to look out for your fellow man. You either watch or you help. This was an extreme case, but I've seen men fight off other men with guns in protection of strangers (Charlie's Hick's dad rose) He saved a teen's life he didn't know... that is called heroism and some people will either help or not.

I think you have to be desensitized from violence I guess, to not be afraid to help.



Thank you for helping me to understand more clearly your point of view and rationale regarding the situation on the bus. I do agree with a couple points you make, and you've given me food for thought, as well.

I'm sorry you've endured such terrible experiences in your own life. hug
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #138 posted 08/03/08 6:20am

WillyWonka

wildgoldenhoney said:

WillyWonka said:




I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?

To tell the truth, I know what I said I would do earlier,
but when actually in that situation, and caught off guard, I just might have reacted the same way that the passengers reacted.

But I'm sure if just one person started to defend that guy, others who may have been shocked initially, would have jumped in too.


Perhaps. I just feel it's impossible to be 'sure' of how anything might have played out in such an extreme, random and sudden act of deranged violence such as this. At this moment we are, in retrospect and from afar, thinking logically about a situation which defied logic or reason, and which erupted so quickly that it didn't really provide the other passengers themselves any time to gather their own wits about them.

I suppose a pertinent question - one about which I'm unclear - is whether or not that young man was still alive when the other passengers realized what was happening. Was he?

Were I faced with a horrific scenario like the incident on the bus, perhaps I'd have done something to help - but perhaps I'd not have. There are just too many variables and factors involved (many likely still unknown to the general public) which preclude me from being able to 'know' for sure how exactly I'd react, or how other people would collectively react - which is why I contend it's unfair to say the other passengers on that bus were cowardly, or to condemn them for what they did (or didn't) do.
[Edited 8/3/08 6:24am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #139 posted 08/03/08 8:50am

sonic

avatar

This has got to be the sickest thing ive read.....this freak should have been shot dead at the scene (imo)

now he will sit in an asylum until he dies...which i hope will be soon.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #140 posted 08/03/08 9:29am

paintedlady

avatar

WillyWonka said:

paintedlady said:



knock him down... get the knife away. I am one of those people that isn't too trusting so I always have some shit on me... I grew up in a tough neighborhood and watched (as a kid, I was about 13) as a young guy (Willie) was cut open and gutted on a street. He died but I watched other women take his the killer's ass down, they fought back, and the machete was taken from him. I had a gun to my head also before...I had no help, I had to help myself, I am still here, but I could not live with myself if anyone died with NO help.

Some just don't want to be involved, I think it is a responsibility to look out for your fellow man. You either watch or you help. This was an extreme case, but I've seen men fight off other men with guns in protection of strangers (Charlie's Hick's dad rose) He saved a teen's life he didn't know... that is called heroism and some people will either help or not.

I think you have to be desensitized from violence I guess, to not be afraid to help.



Thank you for helping me to understand more clearly your point of view and rationale regarding the situation on the bus. I do agree with a couple points you make, and you've given me food for thought, as well.

I'm sorry you've endured such terrible experiences in your own life. hug


I'm actually not sorry, its made me stronger as a person, and I was very lucky to not be physically hurt so time healed any trauma. hug But I am not angry at those passengers, just really disappointed that the killer got to "have fun" with his victim. And I come back to this thread to read that he was eaten too?!
I think this man killed before. Wonder just how many.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #141 posted 08/03/08 9:30am

paintedlady

avatar

wildgoldenhoney said:

WillyWonka said:




I'm curious, and I ask the following sincerely, not snarkily: what do you think you could have done, had you been on that bus and in the exact circumstances as those other passengers? If you'd been startled awake, or been watching the film or listening to music and then heard the screams and turned around in your seat to that young man in the process of being savagely stabbed by a deranged man weilding a large knife...what do you imagine you could have/would have done to help at that point?

To tell the truth, I know what I said I would do earlier,
but when actually in that situation, and caught off guard, I just might have reacted the same way that the passengers reacted.

But I'm sure if just one person started to defend that guy, others who may have been shocked initially, would have jumped in too.


I agree. nod
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #142 posted 08/03/08 9:56am

missfee

avatar

WillyWonka said:

missfee said:

this is one sick story. i was highly disturbed when I read it. it's crazy to think somebody would do that to another stranger for no reason at all. what i'm most upset about is, why are they just charging the psycho with second degree murder??? isn't this vicious crime considered first degree???!!! What is going on here?



From my understanding, the 2nd-degree murder charge is being thought to have been used because proving in a court of law the intent and premeditation of this random crime could prove a difficult task for the prosecution, as these two men were absolute strangers to one another with no history whatsoever; theoretically, there may be random factors which could have come into play that could have suddenly have set off something in Li's brain, causing him to go into the deranged state he clearly was in when he committed this horrific murder.

It's also my understanding that a second-degree murder charge under Canadian law has a range of parole stipulations and so that, ultimately, the final sentence for Li may not be much different than were he charged with 1st degree murder.


Hmm, well thanks for the insight. The guy should really fry for this. I've never heard of a murder this grim before. There is obviously something off in his brain to commit such a gruesome murder with calmness.
I will forever love and miss you...my sweet Prince.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #143 posted 08/03/08 12:17pm

horatio

missfee said:

WillyWonka said:




From my understanding, the 2nd-degree murder charge is being thought to have been used because proving in a court of law the intent and premeditation of this random crime could prove a difficult task for the prosecution, as these two men were absolute strangers to one another with no history whatsoever; theoretically, there may be random factors which could have come into play that could have suddenly have set off something in Li's brain, causing him to go into the deranged state he clearly was in when he committed this horrific murder.

It's also my understanding that a second-degree murder charge under Canadian law has a range of parole stipulations and so that, ultimately, the final sentence for Li may not be much different than were he charged with 1st degree murder.




Hmm, well thanks for the insight. The guy should really fry for this. I've never heard of a murder this grim before. There is obviously something off in his brain to commit such a gruesome murder with calmness.


oh
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #144 posted 08/03/08 8:21pm

PurpleJedi

avatar

pplrain said:

PurpleJedi said:



Maybe so...but, uhm....this story takes place in Canada.



Yeah I know same difference.


omfg say WHAT?!?!?!?! stfu

The guy had a knife not a gun. How can a bus full of people not throw a bag at him and corner him or stop him. confused


I totally agree with you. I mean, I've never been in a fight,. and honestly I don't know exactly how I would react in a similar situation...but I would like to believe that I'd have at least thrown SOMETHING at him!
By St. Boogar and all the saints at the backside door of Purgatory!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #145 posted 08/03/08 10:40pm

sonic

avatar

Thats right..most people DONT KNOW how they would react.

Im sure when the passenger saw this ....it took a while before what he saw actually "sunk into his brain" & by then im sure the victim was dead or close to it.

Most of these "passengers" will be traumatized for life & should seek councelling(sp)..they will be living with feelings of guilt & regrets.
The only one to blame is the sick fu$# that did this . Period!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #146 posted 08/04/08 12:17am

meow85

avatar

Bishop31 said:

The things I'm reading on this thread with people making fun of people who believe in God is more than offensive. God forbid if a Christian here would speak against Gays for there lifestyle. But, true colors show themselves & from the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks. So, peace to you all. Your free to your beliefs. But these comments against those who believe in blessings seems to be a bit much...

You must be reading a different thread than me. Because I haven't seen a single post that is decrying or insulting to the Christian faith, or people who follow that path. I have seen, however, people point out the absolute, stunning arrogance of someone who'd presume God took care of them and not someone else.

As for the so-called "gay lifestyle"? Being gay is a matter of birth. Being Christian is a lifestyle choice, not the other way around.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #147 posted 08/04/08 12:20am

meow85

avatar

AlienX2050 said:

This is something out of a horror movie man. That fucker is crazy.

I don't think I would have been on a bus without me little friend. Especially knowing that strange people travel on buses, man.

Me would love you long time so let me introduce you to the Glock .45.



User Ratings
Quality:*****
Accuracy:*****
Design:*****


.


I'm afraid of people like you.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #148 posted 08/04/08 12:26am

meow85

avatar

missfee said:

WillyWonka said:




From my understanding, the 2nd-degree murder charge is being thought to have been used because proving in a court of law the intent and premeditation of this random crime could prove a difficult task for the prosecution, as these two men were absolute strangers to one another with no history whatsoever; theoretically, there may be random factors which could have come into play that could have suddenly have set off something in Li's brain, causing him to go into the deranged state he clearly was in when he committed this horrific murder.

It's also my understanding that a second-degree murder charge under Canadian law has a range of parole stipulations and so that, ultimately, the final sentence for Li may not be much different than were he charged with 1st degree murder.


Hmm, well thanks for the insight. The guy should really fry for this. I've never heard of a murder this grim before. There is obviously something off in his brain to commit such a gruesome murder with calmness.


No death penalty up here, thank God.

The stupidest, most illogical, and completely ineffective way of punishing a killer is another killing.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #149 posted 08/04/08 4:16am

AnckSuNamun

avatar

TheMistress said:

meow85 said:


Mightn't it be the implication that God was looking out for her on her Greyhoudn trip, but obviously not this poor guy?


Yeah, that shit makes me a bit uncomfortable sometimes. I think TheResistor hit it on the head when he used the word arrogant.

I agree with the questions being asked, but I just don't think the girl meant to offend. Questions regarding religion are always gonna be a hot button, so I usually take a less aggressive approach when questioning someone's beliefs. I see so many religion threads in P&R fail because questions come off as attacks.
rose looking for you in the woods tonight rose Switch FC SW-2874-2863-4789 (Rum&Coke)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 5 of 8 <12345678>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > General Discussion > Man decapitates passenger aboard Greyhound bus in Manitoba: