For me, it's pumpkin, although apple pie is pretty damn good too.

Cherry!!! But apple is a very close second

My dad likes cherry pie.

what pie ISN'T good? i kinda recoiled at rhubarb pie when i was younger, but i'd like to try it again as an adult and see if my opinion has changed. there is no pie i would turn down. they are all equally good. i mean - it's PIE, people.

I prefer Apple, but Pecan is my fave.
[Edited 11/24/06 15:39pm]

True, pie is good, no matter what kind it is. I remember when I was little, my aunt made a meat pie that was delicious (think it was called a shepard pie). Never tried rhubarb pie, I'm curious as to how it would taste.

Stax said:

Pecan!

Chocolate! But between the two- apple, I don't like pumpkin. As a kid, I hated pumpkin pie- as an adult, it's okay. I don't think of it as dessert but more as a side dish. And I fucking hateHateHATE- peacan pie and anykind of fill in the blank-cream pie with coconut!


Drew made three apple pies for Thanksgiving from scratch- crust and all. He makes great pie crust and biscuits!

Apple without question tho pumpin is good too.

CynthiasSocks said:

Drew! Think I may have had chocolate silk pie as a kid, but have not had it in YEARS. Pies made from scratch are always the best, you can't beat 'em!

NAnomaly said:

psychodelicide said:

i think of shepard's pies and pot pies as a different branch of the pie tree from fruit pies, though i have made vegetarian shepards pies in the past and they were really super duper yummy, especially on a nasty cold winter night.


oh my god, can you imagine if there were such things as pie trees?

Pie trees.

Apple with a tasty sharp chedder cheese.

xplnyrslf said:

Never had apple pie with cheddar cheese. That's an interesting combination.

psychodelicide said:

Ooooh yeah, that IS good together.

I have a recipe I want to try for an apple tart that has a layer of caramel on top. The picture looked really good.

psychodelicide said:

I would line the damn streets with pie trees. I'd carry around a big sack and fling pie tree seeds everywhere. I'd be Anxy Pieseed. And I'd be the size of a Winnebago and proud of it.

shellyevon said:

Apple tart with caramel sounds yummy!

Anx said:

[Edited 11/24/06 16:22pm]

A pie is a vagina in Scotland. So I would say auburn.

Humble Pie

LleeLlee said:

That's always in my top two favorites. one can never get enough of Humble Pie.

Pumpkin.

I love apple, but pumpkin. Especially right now.

Pumpkin of course.

apple

Apple pie

Apple, though I like apricot best. Only had pumpkin pie ONCE! when an american lady from mothers group came to my house

Anx said:

omg.

I'll have to say apple because I make a home made pie that is the best apple pie this side of the Mississippi.