I don't consider myself a pop music fan, but there is always comparisons, so here we go:

Britney: when ever we hear about her, it's always about her dress, body, partying. nothing about her music.

Christina:all we hear about is how trashy she dresses.

Jessica: all you hear about is how "air headed" she is.

Out of the 3, who do you think is musically a pop star?? I am not asking about how many instruments can they play, do they lip sync, do they write there on songs.

I am going to say "Jessica": there is nothing offense about her music, she dresses with style and class, she doesn't portray a negative influence. She doesn't need to take her clothes off to get attention and she doesn't need to incorporate "hip hop" to make people think she has street credibility.

Sorry Christina and Britney: you both were on the Mickey Mouse Club, that' hard to live down and make people think you had a tough life.

Christina: you are starting to get it, you are an excellent singer/songwriter let those traits speak for you.

Britney: Put you clothes back on, do away with you 100 dancers and start acting more responsible and you might get there.

Whoever wins, we lose.

Ok, ok, I'll have to give it to Christina. But please, babe, melisma does not a good singer make.

xtina

bds70 said:

Well, Britney is obviously the most successfull. Hmm, I guess I'm copping out a bit but I got to say it's a tie between Britney and Christina. I'm not a fan of either but their music is much better than Jessica's. If it wasn't for Newlyweds would she have even released a third album?

Jessica has better boobs
Christina is prettyier and has a hotter ass
Brittney is skank

I like Chrissie's voice better

If you compared all three of their best albums to each other, Christina would kill them all easily.

jtgillia said:

I'd give it to Britney for albums...but for lasting potential

CHRISTINA

X-TINA has all the makings to be the one that lasts.... remember how people claimed Cyndi Lauper would be bigger than Madonna? Everyone touts Britney as the next Madonna and don't really pay Chris any mind unless she's got bad hair than everyone bags on her.

jessica beats brit..and christina beats em both..period.

.....

I'd have to go with Christina on this one. She is diverse in her performances, unlike Britney and Jessica, and she has the best voice. Plus, her songs have more of a message to them besides partying all night and having sex with your new husband. "Beautiful" still moves me. She wins hands down.

jtgillia said:

And that's the truth, Ruth!!!

Britney can't sing strong enough and hits off notes.

Jessica OVER-sings and hits off notes.

Christina wins, because she doesn't over-sing (usually) and has great pitch.

xxxtina

Christina is hotter and relatively talented

MrSquiggle said:

Have you seen Xtina lately? SHe took the "x" out of Tina and is looking a lot classier! I forogt which magazine she is on the cover of this month...I think its VOGUE. Her hair is short, and a strawberry-ish color. I'm telling you, it's a Madonna "80s morph"

X-tina = Madonna like a virgin era
Classy Chistina look now = True blue/Who's that Girl era

mrdespues said:

This is so true

I like Jessica more as an overall personality. I actually admit that I own her first two albums and have had them for years -- way before she was popular and had a reality show.

I bought them because of the songs "I think I'm in Love" and "Irrestible" -- on both of these Jessica's voice is powerful and perfect. I think she fired her vocal coach. Seriously. She has lost her vocal control. On the series last year she oversang "With you" in the studio and her bosses had her do it over . She got mad. But the released, toned-down version sounds much better.

It's a shame to have powerful vocals that you can't reign in and control. Beyonce used to be like that. But her delivery is together now. I can only hope someone close to Jessica has the guts to say tone it down. Lose the overexaggerated lip twists and facial expressions when you're singing -- oh and the horrible epileptic hand movements.

If she regains her vocal control and stage presence, Jessica could seriously vie with Christina for the best voice.

But for now, Christina is the best of the three. And I love her new blond, curly do. She looks great.

I've never liked Britney nor respected her "talent." And her celebrity exploits are hurting her cause. She's disgusting.

purplegypsy said:

Oh C'mon lol















Madonna was never that tanned

CinisterCee said:

you just wait...christina's next record is going to be some big religious statement, a la LIKE A PRAYER.

purplegypsy said:

I hope not!

purplegypsy said:

What's she gonna call it, "Pray At The Pussy Altar"?

VoicesCarry said:

Madonna could have easily used that title.

sextonseven said:

sextonseven said:

For Like A Prayer? I don't think so. Erotica, maybe.

VoicesCarry said:

Yes. I was thinking specifically of the song "Where Life Begins."

NO contest - Christina all the way...Britney can't sing and Jessica Simpson just annoys the shit outta me, LOL. I hate that remake of that slow jam 80's tune. She is jkust too bubble for me.

Christina.

Christina

sorry if Im repeating myself, but anyone who've seen her live knows that this girl can sing her ass of... her voice just gave me the chills; her singing talent is divine.

Britney on the other hand - which Im somewhat sorry to admit I've seen live as well - does put on a decent show, but that's about it. She lip-syncs all the way through which is a bit of a disappointment really.

Jessica can she even be considered an artist? And her husband Nick... ah don't get me started on him..