Interested in this, too. There's demos with him on instruments. MJ stans really harp on that beat boxing which makes me think "no." Even Britney stans got go-to clips of her playing piano for "Everytime" set for every they wanna stan her artistic clout.

^^

RJOrion said:

Am3121 said:

WhisperingDandelions said:

lol......

Am3121 said:

WhisperingDandelions said:

Interested in this, too. There's demos with him on instruments. MJ stans really harp on that beat boxing which makes me think "no." Even Britney stans got go-to clips of her playing piano for "Everytime" set for every they wanna stan her artistic clout.

Britney spears isn't very talented imo I think all her talent is her T&A

Eh regardless, her stans can easily make with real life footage of her physically composing a song and playing it in front of a camera while MJ stans, the most rabid and intense fanbase in the history of music, drone on endlessly about his artistic compositional proficiency "beat-boxing" his work while whining Quincy took all the credit.

Like just going "BOOM ba'chkBADADADABADADBABDADADA" is more integral to the construction of an LP than actually assembling the musicians and writing/arranging different parts for them to play on the record.

Quincy undermining MJs artistry again! He knows damn well MJ came up with the "BOOM chk BOOM chk chk BOOM BOOM chk" first day in the studio, in the first take. Them other 20 tracks of guitar, drums, keyboard, bass, horns, synths, etc. would be NOTHING without MJ's initial composition of "BOOM chk BOOM chk chk BOOM". Quincy wouldn't know how to tie his own shoes if MJ didn't "BOOM chk BOOM chk chk BOOM".

[Edited 7/4/23 17:17pm]

WhisperingDandelions said:

I want to find one other artist in the history of art who composes his records like MJ stans allege he "composes" his.

Like it's been over 40 years since Thriller, there's gotta be someone out there, "oh yeah I write all my records beat boxing like MJ and then turn it over to some talentless hack producer/arranger to dress it up a tad, you know, dot the i's cross the t's."

Flashback to like, Beethoven era. Beethoven turns to his producer:
"The way I envision this next piece.... DA DA DAAAAAAA DUNN DUNN DUNN DUNNNNNN." "Brilliant sir, brillaint, like this?" "No, no. Watch me again. DA DA DAAAAAAAAA."

"W NNNNNnNNNnN B.C." "W nnNnn B C?" "No, W. NNNNnNNnnn B.C.!" "W NNnNNN B C?" "Nope, nope.."

[Edited 7/4/23 17:25pm]

Am3121 said:

I think this video explains it all https://youtu.be/vTzHM2XUfSE

hahaha is this the video @ShellyMcG (lol i put "ShelbyJ" until I scrolled down) was referring to?

I had to slow it down at the :20 second "Scream" slow mo because this vid is like crack-cocaine or that jumbo chocolate cake from Matilda.

bahahaha and the Prince clip just goes on the rest of the Vs.

This series should be ongoing for generations like Days of Our Lives.

MJ wasn't that bad on the piano, actually. He just might be on a Britney level. You could be right. You could be right.

Am3121 said:

James Brown couldn't play many instruments, but vocalized what each of his bandmembers should play, then arranged it on the spot.

Then it was recorded in one take.

The best take made the record.

I think his main instruments were the organ and pay docking.

Who is this beat-boxing MJ you all speak of?

RJOrion said:

.

Still too long. Just one less character and it will be perfect.

nayroo2002 said:

Who is this beat-boxing MJ you all speak of?

https://www.youtube.com/w...C5he8XQCBw

WhisperingDandelions said:

nayroo2002 said:

Who is this beat-boxing MJ you all speak of?

https://www.youtube.com/w...C5he8XQCBw

https://www.youtube.com/w...-7tf8qwMQk