I missed it because I wasn't home. I'm wondering who got voted off. If somebody could let me know, that'd be great, since they have no information (yet) on the American Idol website. Thanks!

i dont normally watch it ... but it was on ... and i thought i could be the ultimate "never watched it- but -still -can -predict -it" ... jerk ...

at the end ... the 2 blonds were left - so one of them were off ...


the one who finally got the boot wasnt the one i thought ...they booted the one who looks like a model ... with all her great belly shirts/etc ... i think she is a pamela lee anderson lookalike!!?? (sorry , dont know her name )

They got rid of Kimberley Caldwell .. I really liked her.

I thought she was better than Carmen ...

But, I really want Clay to win...he has an amazing voice!!

That Kimberly Caldwell chick got voted off, I read. Again, I just don't know how that Carmen stays on. It's a conspiracy, I tell ya.

alexnvrmnd said:

It really IS a conspiracy There is NO way in hell people can like that girl's voice - she sounds like a fucking goat! Kim's voice was nice, she just didn't always pick the best songs to showcase it. She deserves to be on for at least another week. Carmen sucks incredible amounts of ass & should have been gone weeks ago... America is fucking retarded!

CalhounSq said:

Agreed. But I refuse to participate by phoning in to this crap. I'm not like these little teenagers who hit re-dial for an hour or so trying to jack the box!

alexnvrmnd said:

I hear you I'd never voted until Kimberly kept getting into the bottom 3, that had me worried. So I voted for the first time last week. I think I will again next week & I'll vote for everyone except Carmen I feel like a dork but I'm participating by watching, might as well have an impact on the voting

I just don't get how Carmen still survives. If anything she should have been gone right after Julia. She better not end up in the top 4.

CalhounSq said:

Better you than me, but since you're voting, get a few in for Kimberly and Clay for me!

Carmen sucked on the Wild Card show. I'm baffled she made it this far

Interesting how Carmen survives each week...she was not good at all this week.I was shocked at the vote! I smell conspiracy!
[This message was edited Thu Apr 17 13:42:11 PDT 2003 by Frederick96]

I was pissed when I saw that Carmen made it last night. I threw my tissue box at the TV, that's how mad I was. She can't sing for shit. She sounds like she belongs in a talent show not American Idol. Kimberly C should have stayed another week but like someone here had said, she was a victim of bad song choices that didn't fit well with her voice. I wouldn't be surprised if we see her somewhere in the near future. She has lot of stage presence, which is a major plus in my book and she can sing.

I srta like Carmen though...she's the only one that play an instrument