What are yours? Mine are:

1. Everybody
2. Angel
3. Open Your Heart
4. Who's That Girl?
5. The Look of Love
6. Like A Prayer
7. Cherish
8. Something To Remember
9. Justify My Love
10. Deeper and Deeper
11. Waiting
12. Secret Garden
13. I'll Remember
14. Sanctuary
15. I Want You
16. Substitute For Love (my #1)
17. Power Of Goodbye
18. Time Stood Still
19. I Deserve It
20. Gone

1. Burning Up
2. Oh Father
3. Skin
4. Gambler
5. Dear Jessie
6. I'll Remember
7. Lucky Star
8. Paradise
9. Bad Girl
10. Ray of Light
11. Beautiful Stranger
12. Bedtime Story
13. Impressive Instant
14. Substitute for Love
15. Hanky Panky
16. Causin' a Commotion
17. Cherish
18. Into the Groove
19. Secret
20. Crazy for Love

my picks would be, in no particiular order:

impressive instant
vogue
ray of light
this used to be my playground
like a prayer
deeper and deeper
bedtime story
burning up
dress you up
oh father
causing a commotion
skin
borderline
music
into the groove
secret
waiting
la isla bonita (the version from the drowned world tour)
nothing really matters
holiday

Moonbeam said:

hmm. I've never heard that one. Is it good?

Interesting that most of yours are singles too. She is really strong in that department.

And strange that no True Blue songs made it in the Top 20.
[This message was edited Sun Apr 13 16:24:16 PDT 2003 by TRON]

Moonbeam said:

TRON said:

I shouldn't post while I'm on the phone, I guess!

Moonbeam said:

Is my list pretty much what you thought it'd be?

TRON said:

I'm shocked that "Lucky Star" isn't there, but other than that it makes sense.

In chronological order:

1.Borderline
2.Material Girl
3.Love Don't Live Here Anymore
4.Shoo be Doo
5.Crazy for You
6.Into the Groove
7.Open Your Heart
8.Like a Prayer
9.Cherish
10.Dear Jessie
11.Something to Remember
12.Bad Girl
13.Rain
14.Inside of Me
15.Love Tried to Welcome Me
16.Take a Bow
17.Frozen
18.Little Star
19.Drowned World/Substitute for Love
20.Impressive Instant

Drowned World
Not exactly in that order.

Secret Garden
Paradise
Waiting
Secret
Physical attraction
Sooner or later
Love Song
Music
Don't tell me
Oh Father
Holiday
Everybody
Burning Up
Angel
Bedtime Story
Erotica
Mer Girl
Candy Perfume Girl
Live to tell

Moonbeam said:

It just missed the cut actually. Stuff like Don't Tell Me, Papa Don't Preach, Skin, Inside Of Me and Survival were all pretty close too.

Tomorrow (April 14) three new Madonna songs will premiere on-line...


"Love Profusion" will premiere on AOL.
"X-Static Process" will premiere on Yahoo.
"Mother And Father" will premiere on MSN.

Won't be long now

TRON said:

I thought "Lucky Star" would be top ten. I didn't know you liked "The Look of Love," "Who's That Girl?," "Waiting," "I'll Remember" or "I Want You" more.

I know Madonna's more known for her dance music, but I realized looking over my list that my favorite songs are her ballads.

I guess that's why I've been disappointed over the past couple of years, because from going deeper into electronic music, she's kinda held back on releasing top notch ballads like Take a Bow or Frozen...

DavidEye said:

Oooh, i hope can resist the temptation...

jtgillia said:

I Deserve It
Gone
Paradise (Not For Me)
Nobody's Perfect
Time Stood Still
Mer Girl
Has To Be
Power Of Goodbye
Substitute For Love
Little Star
To Have And Not To Hold

are all top notch ballads

Moonbeam said:

Lucky Star is a recent grower. I love it lots. But all those other songs are longtime favorites.

I Want You is probably top 5. Speaking of which, if I limited it to Top 5 it would probably be, in this order:

Substitute For Love
Like A Prayer
Justify My Love
Deeper and Deeper
I Want You

TRON said:

YES! A top five list with order! I AM having an effect.

>I Deserve It
Gone
Paradise (Not For Me)
Nobody's Perfect
Time Stood Still
Mer Girl
Has To Be
Power Of Goodbye
Substitute For Love
Little Star
To Have And Not To Hold

are all top notch ballads<

Yeah, I don't deny the Ray of Light stuff. But Mirwais' production for me kills the ballads. Just my opinion. I did like Gone, however, it just can't compare to the classics (ie. Crazy for You, Something to Remember, Bad Girl, etc.)

I wanted to include "I Want You", but as it is a cover, I opted not to.

DavidEye said:

That's nice and everything, but what's your top 20 Madonna songs?

Moonbeam said:

I know. You've ruined me for life. Asshole.

TRON said:

Moonbeam said:

Update your songlist you lazy wanker!

TRON said:

Thanks. I can't believe it's only been a week since you went back to Utah. Time is weird right now.

TRON said:

No Physical Attraction or Dress You Up?

rdhull said:

Both of those are great, but my bro and I are huge fans who know all the material, so top 20 is pretty exclusive.

rdhull said:

No Oh Father either.

But damn..The Look of Love is there from Whos That Girl too..I always thought of that as a throwaway imo. Dress You Up at least should take that place...I mean when she goes "..in my love" and "from your head down to your toe-oes" is the jam


.
[This message was edited Sun Apr 13 20:38:21 PDT 2003 by rdhull]

rdhull said:

The Look of Love for me is Live To Tell only better. I know it's nuts, but I've always loved that one.

Dress You Up is great, but isn't a standout cut.

What would be your top 20?
[This message was edited Sun Apr 13 20:56:19 PDT 2003 by TRON]