It's really a crime that Ricky, who finally sang GREAT last night after 2 horrible performances, is sent home & that fucking Carmen who sings like a goat being tortured wasn't even in the bottom 3...

And I don't know HOW Kimberly Locke keeps getting to the bottom 3, her voice is great. I swear, I don't know who's voting for Carmen but I'm gonna start voting for everyone except Carmen just to get the boot in her ass QUICK!!


Carmen

CalhounSq said:

I'm starting to think the whole thing's a fix. Carmen is a crap singer, no doubt, worse than GI Josh. BUT she's got the look Simon is looking for, I think. He's not interested in talent, merely how good he thinks someone will look.

CalhounSq said:

I think her voice is great too, but I don't really like her. I think the problem is her personality. She needs to smile more and look like she enjoys being there. That could be a reason why people aren't voting for her. Unlike Ricky, who was getting by on his personality. Until people had enough.

Kimberly Locke, That is my type to a t. Big and beautiful.

they all pretty much suck? who would buy an album from any of this years singers??? 90% of them should be singing at Sea World or some Ice Skating "Magic On Ice"..

and then you hear about that Red Headed Dude Clay something??.. they all crow about how great he is? He is a GEEK

WHY would anyone buy an album from him.. we already had the SAME exact type Red Headed Geek in 1988 or something

Rick Astley



HE BOMBED why would we want another in 2003??
[This message was edited Fri Apr 11 0:33:56 PDT 2003 by locoarts]

locoarts said:

A friend of mine said the same thing the other day, we were struggling to remember this dude's name!

my hope for top 2 is Ruben and Kim Locke!
Clay can sing even if he's a geek! and I would buy a good singer's album regardless of there geekiness. Are you saying you only like musicians and singers that fit into your "cool" category locoarts? but your are prolly right...his geek factor may prevent him from winning...?? we'll see.
Rick Astley! dang I haven't heard of that dude in a while. what about simply red? remember them? they had a read headed skinny dude who could sing like crazy.

CalhounSq said:

Let me join you with that vote. It's a crime that Carmen is still on the show. She sucks monkey balls and she needs to be gone ASAP. I knew sooner or later that Ricky was going to go but it should have been Carmen first. Let's see what happens next week.

JohnnyTheFox said:

GASP! imposiible. Who would DO such a thing?!



Are you trying to tell me that LOOKS ARE IMPORTANT in this thing? All this time, I thought it was about music and talent and stuff.

Boy, is my bubble burst.

What a (s)hit show. Years from now, we'll be looking back on this crap in the same way we do now with The Gong Show.

how the hell did carmen win over kimberly cauldwell? i mean, i wasn't crazy about cauldwell either, but for love of God, people! Is music not a sacred thing to anyone in america? Carmen is awful! and we have to hear her screaching, sheepish, minnie mouse voice again?!

I'd take Carmen over Josh any day...and at least she can actually play an instrument

I've checked out this show only a couple of times and it's a big joke...especially when they turn it over to the people to vote on. Sure would be nice to see some instrumentalists as well I might add. That would probably get a pass from Simon automatically.

alright, so this busted Carmen Raz-pukin' is about to, um...er, sing...is america finally going to give her the boot?

imnotsayinthisjust2bnasty said:

It's gotta be her this week, or Josh...

so...who gets the boot this week? I really want carmen raz-pukin' gone!

I'm sooo glad. Justice has been done. America has finally wiped the sleep from its eyes.

carmen's gone!

AMERICA HAS FINALLY GOT IT RIGHT!!!

JOSH OR TRENYCE WILL BE NEXT IF THEY DON'T STEP UP TO THE PLATE.

raven...you bring the chips, i'll bring the music...we gon' celebrate!!!

how about some cake instead?

Raven said:

mmm...what kind of cake? Oh, hell, who'm i kidding, i love all cake!

Raven said:

WHOOO-OOO-OOO-OOO-HOOO!!!

Yea! No more Carmen. Josh would have been a good choice too, he is sooo over. War is over and so is he.

jthad1129 said:

Yeah, great that Carmen Ratspukin's gone. Surprised she got through, let alone lasted so long. No talent Josh next. Time for him to get out to Iraq and look for Saddam. Maybe he can scare him out of hiding with his fuck-awful "singing".

CalhounSq said:

LOL, CS! You and me both! We've been pulling for that one for a while, haven't we? I didn't see it last night, so it's good to read it finally happened! No hatin' going on; I'm sure she'll be just fine.

That wink that Clay gave the camera last night made me go over him for a moment. Simon's wrong...he could be the next American Idol. He's got a great voice. I'm rooting for Kim Locke, though.

alexnvrmnd said:

Finally America got it right even though it took about 4 weeks. Trenyce needs to dig deep and pull out all the stops next week so she won't be next.

Its about time Carmen is finally gone! I really want Ruben to win. 1. He can sang 2. He's from my home state, Alabama. I think Josh will be next to be voted off.

just my opinion..

Trenyce will be the next to go...
then Josh ...then Kim (who i think has a great voice...but just not good enough)...
then its down to Clay or Ruben ...

personally i don't really care which one of these two win...both will have a recording contract and both deserve to win. (unlike some no-talent-wannabe's...Carmen...Kim Caldwell...Corey...)

i think it will probably be Ruben that ends up winning...and that's ok by me...