Thread started 01/15/17 4:21pmbluegangsta
|
Rate Stevie Wonder's post-"Golden Era" albums Stevie Wonder's Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" (1979) Hotter than July (1980) The Woman in Red (1984) In Square Circle (1985) Characters (1987) Jungle Fever (1991) Conversation Peace (1995) A Time to Love (2005) Always cry 4 love, never cry 4 pain. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #1 posted 01/16/17 12:46am
Dancelot |
Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" (1979)
I would include that in the Golden Era
as for the rest I'd rank them from top to bottom like this:
Hotter than July
In Square Circle The Woman in Red
Characters A Time to Love Jungle Fever Conversation Peace
Vanglorious... this is protected by the red, the black, and the green. With a key... sissy! |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #2 posted 01/16/17 6:35am
MD431Madcat |
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is! |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #3 posted 01/16/17 8:57am
2freaky4church 1 |
In Square Circle is pathetic. All you others say Hell Yea!! |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #4 posted 01/16/17 12:56pm
214 |
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
Yes, i will include Hotter Than July, bit not Secret Life. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #5 posted 01/17/17 12:51am
bluegangsta
|
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
Music From My Mind through to Songs In The Key of Life are universally regarded as the Golden Era, not so much Hotter Than July. Always cry 4 love, never cry 4 pain. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #6 posted 01/17/17 12:37pm
214 |
bluegangsta said:
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
Music From My Mind through to Songs In The Key of Life are universally regarded as the Golden Era, not so much Hotter Than July.
You're right. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #7 posted 01/17/17 1:57pm
CoolMF |
I understand the feedback that I'm reading but, personally, I consider Hotter Than July part of the "golden" era simply because I like some of the songs (All I Do, Lately, etc...) as much as I like some of the Innervisions/Fulfillingness joints That said:
Jungle Fever
A Time To Love
Conversation Peace
That's it. The 80's stuff was too hit and miss up until Junger Fever for me. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #8 posted 01/17/17 3:17pm
TonyVanDam |
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
THIS!!!!!^
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #9 posted 01/17/17 6:44pm
728huey |
TonyVanDam said:
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
THIS!!!!!^
I always thought his best 1980's output came on his first greatest hits album (the Musiquarium one) which included "That Girl", "Do I Do", and "Ribbon In the Sky". |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #10 posted 01/18/17 7:12am
MD431Madcat |
i'd bet anything that i know much more about music than both of you!
214 said:
bluegangsta said:
Music From My Mind through to Songs In The Key of Life are universally regarded as the Golden Era, not so much Hotter Than July.
You're right.
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #11 posted 01/18/17 12:49pm
jtfolden |
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
The title of the thread asks you to rate his ***post-***"Golden Era" albums.
That means those that came after.
However, Wonder's classic era does not include Hotter Than July. Even Stevie Wonder's Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" is questionable. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #12 posted 01/18/17 1:05pm
214 |
MD431Madcat said:
i'd bet anything that i know much more about music than both of you!
214 said:
You're right.
I'd bet anything in this whole wide world that i don't care a damn, darling. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #13 posted 01/18/17 9:57pm
MD431Madcat |
214 said:
MD431Madcat said:
i'd bet anything that i know much more about music than both of you!
I'd bet anything in this whole wide world that i don't care a damn, darling.
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #14 posted 01/19/17 2:48am
MD431Madcat |
jtfolden said:
MD431Madcat said:
Your choices aren't Stevies Golden era..
Music of my mind - Hotter than July
is!
The title of the thread asks you to rate his ***post-***"Golden Era" albums.
That means those that came after.
However, Wonder's classic era does not include Hotter Than July. Even Stevie Wonder's Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" is questionable.
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #15 posted 01/19/17 11:47am
heathilly |
Music of my mind 8/10
Talking book 9/10
Innervisions 10/10
Fufillingness First Finale 9/10
Songs in the key of life 10/10
Great music great songs.
But lyrically not that amazing to me
Majority of his songs are about peace love and togetherness with some protest things sprinkled in.
And that's great and that his artistic expression
But Stevie is not a really deep or expansive thinker all the conflicts in his music can be solved with god and love and I know that's an African American trope and just the status quo in society of how to think but it so cliche and cheap it kinda rubs me in a mystical nonsense mumbo jumbo talking way leaving me intellectually hungry. Prince also does this a lot 3rd eye hotep crap, time doesn't exist that gets passed off as deep intellectual knowledge and I'm like uhh no. I wish the music had more darkness grit and realism like songs (to high, superstition, living for the city etc)
Anyway it's good overall. [Edited 1/19/17 11:48am]
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #16 posted 01/19/17 12:02pm
lowkey |
728huey said:
TonyVanDam said:
THIS!!!!!^
I always thought his best 1980's output came on his first greatest hits album (the Musiquarium one) which included "That Girl", "Do I Do", and "Ribbon In the Sky".
me too. i dont see how this album and hotter than july are not part of his 'golden era'. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #17 posted 01/19/17 12:43pm
214 |
heathilly said:
Music of my mind 8/10 Talking book 9/10 Innervisions 10/10 Fufillingness First Finale 9/10 Songs in the key of life 10/10 Great music great songs. But lyrically not that amazing to me Majority of his songs are about peace love and togetherness with some protest things sprinkled in. And that's great and that his artistic expression But Stevie is not a really deep or expansive thinker all the conflicts in his music can be solved with god and love and I know that's an African American trope and just the status quo in society of how to think but it so cliche and cheap it kinda rubs me in a mystical nonsense mumbo jumbo talking way leaving me intellectually hungry. Prince also does this a lot 3rd eye hotep crap, time doesn't exist that gets passed off as deep intellectual knowledge and I'm like uhh no. I wish the music had more darkness grit and realism like songs (to high, superstition, living for the city etc) Anyway it's good overall. [Edited 1/19/17 11:48am]
You're right, Stevie Wonder is a little or it comes across as naive lyrically wise. The same could be said about Prince and Michael Jackson, but isn't all go down to respect each other, if we did, things woul be much different, so... that's the point in the message of these artists. So, in this case Bob Dylan's writing seems to me much more complex than that of Stevie,Michael and Prince and many more of course. Although in that matter, Leonard Cohen is up there with Dylan. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #18 posted 01/19/17 12:54pm
heathilly |
214 said:
heathilly said: Music of my mind 8/10 Talking book 9/10 Innervisions 10/10 Fufillingness First Finale 9/10 Songs in the key of life 10/10 Great music great songs. But lyrically not that amazing to me Majority of his songs are about peace love and togetherness with some protest things sprinkled in. And that's great and that his artistic expression But Stevie is not a really deep or expansive thinker all the conflicts in his music can be solved with god and love and I know that's an African American trope and just the status quo in society of how to think but it so cliche and cheap it kinda rubs me in a mystical nonsense mumbo jumbo talking way leaving me intellectually hungry. Prince also does this a lot 3rd eye hotep crap, time doesn't exist that gets passed off as deep intellectual knowledge and I'm like uhh no. I wish the music had more darkness grit and realism like songs (to high, superstition, living for the city etc) Anyway it's good overall. [Edited 1/19/17 11:48am]
You're right, Stevie Wonder is a little or it comes across as naive lyrically wise. The same could be said about Prince and Michael Jackson, but isn't all go down to respect each other, if we did, things woul be much different, so... that's the point in the message of these artists. So, in this case Bob Dylan's writing seems to me much more complex than that of Stevie,Michael and Prince and many more of course. Although in that matter, Leonard Cohen is up there with Dylan. The Marvin Gaye acclaimed what's going on is chalked full of that. But yes I respect the different perspectives. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #19 posted 01/19/17 1:19pm
214 |
heathilly said:
214 said:
You're right, Stevie Wonder is a little or it comes across as naive lyrically wise. The same could be said about Prince and Michael Jackson, but isn't all go down to respect each other, if we did, things woul be much different, so... that's the point in the message of these artists. So, in this case Bob Dylan's writing seems to me much more complex than that of Stevie,Michael and Prince and many more of course. Although in that matter, Leonard Cohen is up there with Dylan.
The Marvin Gaye acclaimed what's going on is chalked full of that. But yes I respect the different perspectives.
You don't like that song, is great, but the message is true, even if it's full of cliches. Life is that; is full of common places. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #20 posted 01/19/17 1:30pm
heathilly |
214 said:
heathilly said:
214 said:
You're right, Stevie Wonder is a little or it comes across as naive lyrically wise. The same could be said about Prince and Michael Jackson, but isn't all go down to respect each other, if we did, things woul be much different, so... that's the point in the message of these artists. So, in this case Bob Dylan's writing seems to me much more complex than that of Stevie,Michael and Prince and many more of course. Although in that matter, Leonard Cohen is up there with Dylan.
The Marvin Gaye acclaimed what's going on is chalked full of that. But yes I respect the different perspectives.
You don't like that song, is great, but the message is true, even if it's full of cliches. Life is that; is full of common places.
No I love that song I was talking about the album. He talks about all these issues racism proverty enviromental disasters drugs etc. Goes to the same trope of we need god and love because it will solve everything. It seems a little like really Marvin that's going to solve everything. It's just seem unrealistic. But as I said this like a traditional trope. But with that said I think Marvin excuted the same message better than Stevie it sounded more mature and rationale less naive cliches and all. [Edited 1/19/17 13:34pm] |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #21 posted 01/19/17 2:29pm
HardcoreJollie s |
To me A Time to Love was his best work since Hotter Than July. And I am a lifelong fan. The others post Hotter often have moments but have too many pedestrian songs/performances to make cohesive and powerful statements as albums. If you've got funk, you've got style. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #22 posted 01/19/17 2:50pm
Marrk
|
bluegangsta said:
Stevie Wonder's Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" (1979) Hotter than July (1980) The Woman in Red (1984) In Square Circle (1985) Characters (1987) Jungle Fever (1991) Conversation Peace (1995) A Time to Love (2005)
'Plants'. Not keen on it at all 4/10
'Hotter than July'. I love nearly every song 9/10
'The Woman in red' meh. 5/10
'In Square Circle'. Has 'Overjoyed' and 'Part Time Lover' on it, so not all bad. 4/10
'Characters' I saw as a return to form. Little i dislike. 8/10
'Conversation Peace' Not heard it, don't own it.
'A Time To Love'. A pretty strong album 7/10.
Can't believe it's 12 years ago! Come on Stevie, put something new out.
|
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #23 posted 01/19/17 2:58pm
HardcoreJollie s |
Marrk said:
bluegangsta said:
Stevie Wonder's Journey Through "The Secret Life of Plants" (1979) Hotter than July (1980) The Woman in Red (1984) In Square Circle (1985) Characters (1987) Jungle Fever (1991) Conversation Peace (1995) A Time to Love (2005)
'Plants'. Not keen on it at all 4/10
'Hotter than July'. I love nearly every song 9/10
'The Woman in red' meh. 5/10
'In Square Circle'. Has 'Overjoyed' and 'Part Time Lover' on it, so not all bad. 4/10
'Characters' I saw as a return to form. Little i dislike. 8/10
'Conversation Peace' Not heard it, don't own it.
'A Time To Love'. A pretty strong album 7/10.
Can't believe it's 12 years ago! Come on Stevie, put something new out.
Yeah, one new album the past 22 years! What a waste. And to think it was highly publicized and a running joke about how long it took for him to deliver SITKOL after Fulfillingness. Now instead of a couple of years it's a couple of decades! If you've got funk, you've got style. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #24 posted 01/19/17 3:13pm
Marrk
|
HardcoreJollies said:
Marrk said:
'Plants'. Not keen on it at all 4/10
'Hotter than July'. I love nearly every song 9/10
'The Woman in red' meh. 5/10
'In Square Circle'. Has 'Overjoyed' and 'Part Time Lover' on it, so not all bad. 4/10
'Characters' I saw as a return to form. Little i dislike. 8/10
'Conversation Peace' Not heard it, don't own it.
'A Time To Love'. A pretty strong album 7/10.
Can't believe it's 12 years ago! Come on Stevie, put something new out.
Yeah, one new album the past 22 years! What a waste. And to think it was highly publicized and a running joke about how long it took for him to deliver SITKOL after Fulfillingness. Now instead of a couple of years it's a couple of decades!
You'd think with the passing of so many great artists (and his friends too!) it might inspire him, seems that isn't the case. Maybe he's content and done with it all. It is a waste. Stevie could have done so much more, he still has good songs in him. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #25 posted 01/19/17 6:52pm
mjscarousal |
I love all his albums from this era, he is a genius. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #26 posted 01/19/17 11:05pm
heathilly |
I wonder why Stevie's decline was such a sudden drop? It's interesting to look at great songwriters and see their best work usually comes in the 20s than it just vanishes.
Same with
Bob Dylan McCartney/Lennon Prince Neil young Etc. strange phenomena |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #27 posted 01/20/17 8:17am
MotownSubdivis ion |
Marrk said:
HardcoreJollies said:
Marrk said:
'Plants'. Not keen on it at all 4/10
'Hotter than July'. I love nearly every song 9/10
'The Woman in red' meh. 5/10
'In Square Circle'. Has 'Overjoyed' and 'Part Time Lover' on it, so not all bad. 4/10
'Characters' I saw as a return to form. Little i dislike. 8/10
'Conversation Peace' Not heard it, don't own it.
'A Time To Love'. A pretty strong album 7/10.
Can't believe it's 12 years ago! Come on Stevie, put something new out.
Yeah, one new album the past 22 years! What a waste. And to think it was highly publicized and a running joke about how long it took for him to deliver SITKOL after Fulfillingness. Now instead of a couple of years it's a couple of decades!
You'd think with the passing of so many great artists (and his friends too!) it might inspire him, seems that isn't the case. Maybe he's content and done with it all. It is a waste. Stevie could have done so much more, he still has good songs in him. Look at all he has done. That's plenty if you ask me. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #28 posted 01/20/17 12:40pm
214 |
heathilly said:
I wonder why Stevie's decline was such a sudden drop? It's interesting to look at great songwriters and see their best work usually comes in the 20s than it just vanishes. Same with Bob Dylan McCartney/Lennon Prince Neil young Etc. strange phenomena
Bob Dylan and MCcartney have done great songs, later in their lives, especially Dylan, But in general is true the 20's is when they do their greatest and more iconic work. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Reply #29 posted 01/20/17 1:21pm
heathilly |
214 said:
heathilly said: I wonder why Stevie's decline was such a sudden drop? It's interesting to look at great songwriters and see their best work usually comes in the 20s than it just vanishes. Same with Bob Dylan McCartney/Lennon Prince Neil young Etc. strange phenomena
Bob Dylan and MCcartney have done great songs, later in their lives, especially Dylan, But in general is true the 20's is when they do their greatest and more iconic work. It's a weird thing maybe they were more driven when they were younger less responsibility, more freshness of youth? I don't know just a weird thing I noticed. |
| - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
copyright © 1998-2024 prince.org. all rights reserved.