Both videos from 1995

Debut:

May 31 1995- Michael Jackson and Janet- Scream

May 19-1995 Madonna Human Nature

Both were ahead of time, whose was better?

[Edited 6/1/12 20:31pm]

[Edited 6/1/12 20:34pm]

MJ and janet Scream

Don't like any of these videos much, but Scream

LOL

Scream...

Like them both, neither were ahead of their time (both 'sounds' were already around some time when they were released)...but more....what do they have to do with eachother?

why in the hell its always a vs situtaion in this case its just like so lame cuz scream was like a epic ssong human nature just a filler on a album nobody barely remembers.madonna has soo many better songs why bring up this weak one. one thing i can say that michael, janet and madonna are all kings and queens of music 3 of the best

cbarnes3121 said:

robertlove said:

Like them both, neither were ahead of their time (both 'sounds' were already around some time when they were released)...but more....what do they have to do with eachother?

I brought the comparison because of their videos- my point was video did you think was better. They were both really high budget when they came out. Both black and white- and a little out there if you know what I mean

better song: human nature

better video: scream

suga10 said:

I brought the comparison because of their videos- my point was video did you think was better. They were both really high budget when they came out. Both black and white- and a little out there if you know what I mean

Why didn't you pick "Bedtime story" for example than?

"Human nature" is very minimalistic, I doubt there was a huge budget like the Scream video.

robertlove said:

suga10 said:

I brought the comparison because of their videos- my point was video did you think was better. They were both really high budget when they came out. Both black and white- and a little out there if you know what I mean

Why didn't you pick "Bedtime story" for example than?

"Human nature" is very minimalistic, I doubt there was a huge budget like the Scream video.

Bedtime Story is a totally different genre compared to Scream- its hard to compare those two.

Human Nature and Scream were both edgy types of videos- with the whole IN YOUR FACE kind of theme.

Scream was such a disappointment. Tryna be a live anime vid. Best part was when they were doing the bump with each other in sequence for a split second.

Human Nature was ultimately more interesting with its simple small budget and image.

Love both songs, love both videos

Honestly Human Nature video is not that different from Erotica. Typical Madonna, nothing surprising. The video's pretty much the same scene over and over that you watch first 30 or 40 seconds, you've literally watched it all.

But I find it refreshing to see MJ finally showing some anger and frustration on Scream Video. I love how both Janet and MJ didn't really hold anything back on this one and just let it all happen (especially Janet) And in between all that negative emotions it has some humorous moments. I find it very entertaining.

You people are blind... BOW DOWN TO THE SCREAM VIDEO...

SCREAM WINS THIS EASILY...

Ps. I do like the Madonna video though... its one of her best but Scream was of course better..

[Edited 6/2/12 19:31pm]

Human Nature...I feel her and where she's coming from on the subject.

No contest.

Scream.

Didn't we already have about this? Scream by far, the anger in that song is just powerful. Video is better too

purplethunder3121 said:

robertlove said:

Like them both, neither were ahead of their time (both 'sounds' were already around some time when they were released)...but more....what do they have to do with eachother?

All 3 of them recieved hate and wrote an angry "fuck the haters" song and then made interesting videos to support the songs

I 'Scream' when I see MJ walk at 2:28--I it.

RosesRred said:

Just horrible

errant said:

Human Nature sounds like a Dr Dre production circa 1992/1993.

Close!!

Damn I love those drums