hmmm decent list, although i feel they where trying to please the masses by putting the big hits in the top 10.

Personally Skin, Intervention & Nothing Fails are my favorite Madonna tracks

Mine changes constantly but I always enjoy seeing what people choose as their favorites.

Gunsnhalen said:

hmmm decent list, although i feel they where trying to please the masses by putting the big hits in the top 10.

Personally Skin, Intervention & Nothing Fails are my favorite Madonna tracks

Dont get why ELTON is on the post? its not his list, or is it just another shot at thim because he said something about the un-toucable Madonna? Dont get it at all, and im hoping that where not trying to show she has 100 top songs while he doesnt? i hope not because he is one of the most charted artists in history, by age 30 he had 21 albums out, charted and certified gold platunum and mutli platnum. And owns the record that WILL NEVER BE BROKEN , ONE TOP 40 HIT every year between 1970-1999 (a 30 year run) this record has never been challenged and no one has come within half of it, AND we know the way it is now, NO ONE is ever gonna have a 30 year run of actually being able to chart on the HOT 100!

Dont get me wrong i like Madonna for the most part, but the catalogs cant even be compared, one is a POP ICON and one is ROCK MUSICIAN ICON.

[Edited 2/18/12 13:11pm]

lastdecember said:

Gunsnhalen said:

hmmm decent list, although i feel they where trying to please the masses by putting the big hits in the top 10.

Personally Skin, Intervention & Nothing Fails are my favorite Madonna tracks

Dont get why ELTON is on the post? its not his list, or is it just another shot at thim because he said something about the un-toucable Madonna? Dont get it at all, and im hoping that where not trying to show she has 100 top songs while he doesnt? i hope not because he is one of the most charted artists in history, by age 30 he had 21 albums out, charted and certified gold platunum and mutli platnum. And owns the record that WILL NEVER BE BROKEN , ONE TOP 40 HIT every year between 1970-1999 (a 30 year run) this record has never been challenged and no one has come within half of it, AND we know the way it is now, NO ONE is ever gonna have a 30 year run of actually being able to chart on the HOT 100!

...............

i never said anything about Elton....................................

wtf so take your rant to someone who talked about Elton

[Edited 2/18/12 13:14pm]

[Edited 2/18/12 13:25pm]

RKJCNE said:

Mine changes constantly but I always enjoy seeing what people choose as their favorites.

I'm a huge fan of Erotica, Ray Of Light, Bedtime Stories & American Life.

The rest vary for me

lastdecember said:

Gunsnhalen said:

hmmm decent list, although i feel they where trying to please the masses by putting the big hits in the top 10.

Personally Skin, Intervention & Nothing Fails are my favorite Madonna tracks

Dont get why ELTON is on the post? its not his list, or is it just another shot at thim because he said something about the un-toucable Madonna? Dont get it at all, and im hoping that where not trying to show she has 100 top songs while he doesnt? i hope not because he is one of the most charted artists in history, by age 30 he had 21 albums out, charted and certified gold platunum and mutli platnum. And owns the record that WILL NEVER BE BROKEN , ONE TOP 40 HIT every year between 1970-1999 (a 30 year run) this record has never been challenged and no one has come within half of it, AND we know the way it is now, NO ONE is ever gonna have a 30 year run of actually being able to chart on the HOT 100!

Dont get me wrong i like Madonna for the most part, but the catalogs cant even be compared, one is a POP ICON and one is ROCK MUSICIAN ICON.

[Edited 2/18/12 13:11pm]

The website it's posted from is titled AfterElton a gay news website whose name is an homage to him.

Gunsnhalen said:

RKJCNE said:

Mine changes constantly but I always enjoy seeing what people choose as their favorites.

I'm a huge fan of Erotica, Ray Of Light, Bedtime Stories & American Life.

The rest vary for me

For me Like A Prayer, Ray Of Light, Confessions and Music are always flawless

same on the others, Erotica is the one I've never got into the way most of her fans have.

Gunsnhalen said:

lastdecember said:

Dont get why ELTON is on the post? its not his list, or is it just another shot at thim because he said something about the un-toucable Madonna? Dont get it at all, and im hoping that where not trying to show she has 100 top songs while he doesnt? i hope not because he is one of the most charted artists in history, by age 30 he had 21 albums out, charted and certified gold platunum and mutli platnum. And owns the record that WILL NEVER BE BROKEN , ONE TOP 40 HIT every year between 1970-1999 (a 30 year run) this record has never been challenged and no one has come within half of it, AND we know the way it is now, NO ONE is ever gonna have a 30 year run of actually being able to chart on the HOT 100!

...............

i never said anything about Elton....................................

wtf so take your rant to someone who talked abotu Elton

[Edited 2/18/12 13:14pm]

no not you it was a general question about where was the post coming from, i see now this is a website about him, but not authorized by him. The post title looks as if it was a shot at Elton for his posts and "heres Madonna's track record" not that you were saying anything

lastdecember said:

Gunsnhalen said:

...............

i never said anything about Elton....................................

wtf so take your rant to someone who talked abotu Elton

[Edited 2/18/12 13:14pm]

no not you it was a general question about where was the post coming from, i see now this is a website about him, but not authorized by him. The post title looks as if it was a shot at Elton for his posts and "heres Madonna's track record" not that you were saying anything

Oh, gotcha

Yeah it's just the name of the magazine... ironically

RKJCNE said:

Gunsnhalen said:

I'm a huge fan of Erotica, Ray Of Light, Bedtime Stories & American Life.

The rest vary for me

For me Like A Prayer, Ray Of Light, Confessions and Music are always flawless

same on the others, Erotica is the one I've never got into the way most of her fans have.

LAP is my first Madonna i really loved

LOve Song with Prince is good but kidn of boring at times, Till Death Do Us Part & Promise To Try are 2 other faves

Gunsnhalen said:

RKJCNE said:

For me Like A Prayer, Ray Of Light, Confessions and Music are always flawless

same on the others, Erotica is the one I've never got into the way most of her fans have.

LAP is my first Madonna i really loved

LOve Song with Prince is good but kidn of boring at times, Till Death Do Us Part & Promise To Try are 2 other faves

I adore Till Death Do Us Part, it's part early Madonna jittery pop and part 90s jaded and snide Madonna. Always wish it had a video. I like Love Song, I think it just ads on to how unorthadox of a pop album it was. Spanish Eyes is also a huge favorite of mine, love it when Madonna brings on the Drama.

too random

my personal Top10 (not necessarily my favorites)

10.Holiday

9.Live to Tell

8.Oh Father

7.Papa Don't Preach

6.Rain

5.Express Yourself

4.Lucky Star

3.Ray of Light

2.Vogue

1.Like a Prayer

'Vogue' will always be my favourite song.

Like A Prayer was ranked too low. I would have it #1 on my list of best Madonna songs ever.

Does she even have 100 songs?

lastdecember said:

no not you it was a general question about where was the post coming from, i see now this is a website about him, but not authorized by him. The post title looks as if it was a shot at Elton for his posts and "heres Madonna's track record" not that you were saying anything

Relax, no one is attacking Elton. The After Elton website is a site for the LGBT community, not about Elton. The name comes because Elton was one of the first musicians to come out as gay/bisexual and it covers people who have come out more recently and things of general interest to the LGBT community, hence the name After Elton. The website's slogan is "the pop culture site that plays for your team". Perhaps before getting hysterical and thinking Elton is being insulted when nothing of the kind was done, you should click on the link so you know what you are talking about instead of mindlessly ranting.

TonyVanDam said:

Like A Prayer was ranked too low. I would have it #1 on my list of best Madonna songs ever.

it would definitely be in my Top 5

NDRU said:

Does she even have 100 songs?

She has over 70 singles.

RKJCNE said:

NDRU said:

Does she even have 100 songs?

She has over 70 singles.

That doesn't answer the question, does it?

Obviously I am kidding, but she has what 10-12 albums? It's not like she has 500 songs. I would think the top 100 has to include some of her bad ones.

"I Know It" and "I'd Rather Be You Lover" are her worst tracks to me.

NDRU said:

I wonder what Elton John would think of this list?

I'd wager, if he's reading this - that he's throwing Diamonds at his cat right now

This is a very entertaining thread. Well, the first page was anyway.

NDRU said:

RKJCNE said:

She has over 70 singles.

That doesn't answer the question, does it?

Obviously I am kidding, but she has what 10-12 albums? It's not like she has 500 songs. I would think the top 100 has to include some of her bad ones.

Madonna has 100 good songs

JoeTyler said:

NDRU said:

That doesn't answer the question, does it?

Obviously I am kidding, but she has what 10-12 albums? It's not like she has 500 songs. I would think the top 100 has to include some of her bad ones.

Madonna has 100 good songs

then why did they include 4 minutes?

NDRU said:

JoeTyler said:

Madonna has 100 good songs

then why did they include 4 minutes?

I would rank that one between the 95-100 spots...

Hudson said:

"I Know It" and "I'd Rather Be You Lover" are her worst tracks to me.

Can't see how "I Know It" made it onto her debut album when she had several other top-notch songs that she could have used ("Don't You Know","Ain't No Big Deal").