Battle of the Janet clones.

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Aaliyah

Vocals

1.Aaliyah

2. Mya

Ciara and Britney About the same

Dancing

Ciara

Aaliyah

Britney

Mya

vocals

aaliyah

mya

ciara

britney

dancing

mya

ciara

aaliyah

britney

Prime

(Vocals)

1. Britney

2. Aaliyah

3. Mya

4. Ciara

(Dancing)

1. Britney

2. Ciara

3. Mya

4. Aaliyah

When did mya dance that good? Or are you thinking about her dancing on dancing with the stars?

babybugz said:

When did mya dance that good? Or are you thinking about her dancing on dancing with the stars?

Mya is a dancing beast.. She can tap dance, salsa, and hip hop dance. easily the most versatile. and her dancing tribute to janet jackson>>>anything aaliyah, ciara, or britney ever did.

Pressure said:

Battle of the Janet clones.

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Aaliyah

Singing style:

1. Aaliyah
2. Mya
3. Britney
4. Ciara

Dancing style:

1. Ciara
2. Aaliyah
3. Britney
4. Mya

musicjunky318 said:

Prime

(Vocals)

1. Britney

2. Aaliyah

3. Mya

4. Ciara

(Dancing)

1. Britney

2. Ciara

3. Mya

4. Aaliyah

I love Britney but you know you wrong

babybugz said:

musicjunky318 said:

Prime

(Vocals)

1. Britney

2. Aaliyah

3. Mya

4. Ciara

(Dancing)

1. Britney

2. Ciara

3. Mya

4. Aaliyah

I love Britney but you know you wrong

Go back to ...Baby One More Time when she was at her peak vocally.

Or even before that on the Mickey Mouse Club.

Love Britney too, but she is not a better singer than Aaliyah was nor is she a better dancer than Ciara.

at Britney being a better singer than Aaliyah. In your dreams! She's not even better than Ciara or Mya vocally.

Vocally:

1. Aaliyah

2. Mya

3. Ciara

4. Britney

Dancing:

1. Ciara

2. Mya

3. Aaliyah

4. Britney

Vocals:

Aaliyah

Mya

Ciara

Britney

Dancing:

Mya

Ciara

Britney (pre-breakdown)

Aaliyah

neonlights said:

at Britney being a better singer than Aaliyah. In your dreams! She's not even better than Ciara or Mya vocally.

Vocally:

1. Aaliyah

2. Mya

3. Ciara

4. Britney

Dancing:

1. Ciara

2. Mya

3. Aaliyah

4. Britney

VOCALS

1. Aaliyah - average

2. Mya - below the average

3. Britney - mediocre

4. Ciara - weak

DANCING

1. Ciara

2. Britney

3. Mya

4. Aaliyah

all the girls are dancing better than singing and were good dancers in their prime-time.

[Edited 10/22/11 5:55am]

For vocals, I'm going with Aaliyah and Mya. As far as dancing goes, I think Mya was the most versatile. Ciara is good with the robotic, pop-and-lock moves...but I dont think it goes beyond that for her. Britney is a marketing powerhouse - however, the dancing is very lacking. She usually stands in one spot and moves her arms around.

I always thought Mya could've been the next Janet as far as dancing was concerned.

See @ 2:10

musicjunky318 said:

neonlights said:

at Britney being a better singer than Aaliyah. In your dreams! She's not even better than Ciara or Mya vocally.

Vocally:

1. Aaliyah

2. Mya

3. Ciara

4. Britney

Dancing:

1. Ciara

2. Mya

3. Aaliyah

4. Britney

For what? You're just a deluded stan.

Mya-great versatality, her dancing lacks personality though. Easily the best dancer on this list.

Ciara-great street dancer and natural ability, but repetetive and gimmicky.

Aaliyah-Smooth, technical, and precise. Lacked interesting choreography though.

Britney-good choreography, but horrible execution. usually got outdanced by her backup dancers.

[Edited 10/22/11 9:59am]

neonlights said:

at Britney being a better singer than Aaliyah. In your dreams! She's not even better than Ciara or Mya vocally.

Vocally:

1. Aaliyah

2. Mya

3. Ciara

4. Britney

Dancing:

1. Ciara

2. Mya

3. Aaliyah

4. Britney

THIS would be my ranking as well.

Vocals:

Aaliyah

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Dancing:
Mya

Ciara

Aaliyah
Britney

Britney shouldn't even be on here. She stinks at everything she does.

Pressure said:

Battle of the Janet clones.

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Aaliyah

Vocals

1. Aaliyah

2. Britney (1999)

3. Mya

4. Britney (2011)

5. Ciara

Dancing

1. Mya

2. Britney (2002)

3. Ciara

4. Aaliyah

5. Britney (2011)

chamber said:

Vocals:

Aaliyah

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Dancing:
Mya

Ciara

Aaliyah
Britney

Britney shouldn't even be on here. She stinks at everything she does.

Singer, songwriter, choreographer, producer, dancer, actress, fragrance-designer, spokeswoman, philantropist, author, video game diva, only icon of the four...I'd be mad too.

RKJCNE said:

Pressure said:

Battle of the Janet clones.

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Aaliyah

Vocals

1. Aaliyah

2. Britney (1999)

3. Mya

4. Britney (2011)

5. Ciara

Dancing

1. Mya

2. Britney (2002)

3. Ciara

4. Aaliyah

5. Britney (2011)

Vocals

Aaliyah (better than we thought)

Mya (so much better than we think)

Britney

Ciara

Dancing

Mya (does it all, can clean the floor with everyone)

Britney

Ciara

Aaliyah

Vocals:

Aaliyah

Britney (At her peak)

Ciara

Mya

Dancing:

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Aaliyah

musicjunky318 said:

chamber said:

Vocals:

Aaliyah

Ciara

Mya

Britney

Dancing:
Mya

Ciara

Aaliyah
Britney

Britney shouldn't even be on here. She stinks at everything she does.

Singer, songwriter, choreographer, producer, dancer, actress, fragrance-designer, spokeswoman, philantropist, author, video game diva, only icon of the four...I'd be mad too.

I'm not mad; what I am is not impressed. Britney is trash and has the talent of Disco Duck. Again, she stinks. Nothing she does is any good.

chamber said:

musicjunky318 said:

Singer, songwriter, choreographer, producer, dancer, actress, fragrance-designer, spokeswoman, philantropist, author, video game diva, only icon of the four...I'd be mad too.

I'm not mad; what I am is not impressed. Britney is trash and has the talent of Disco Duck. Again, she stinks. Nothing she does is any good.

She sucks now because of one reason. She was a teen pop star. And the kind who can't keep going after they become an adult. But she keeps trying. They may not be good examples but she has greatly influenced: Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato...Any girl star on Disney. She may not be the best, but she is an icon. No use denying that.

aardvark15 said:

chamber said:

I'm not mad; what I am is not impressed. Britney is trash and has the talent of Disco Duck. Again, she stinks. Nothing she does is any good.

She sucks now because of one reason. She was a teen pop star. And the kind who can't keep going after they become an adult. But she keeps trying. They may not be good examples but she has greatly influenced: Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato...Any girl star on Disney. She may not be the best, but she is an icon. No use denying that.

What do you mean she couldn't keep going?

These all had hits after her teen years were long gone.

musicjunky318 said:

aardvark15 said:

She sucks now because of one reason. She was a teen pop star. And the kind who can't keep going after they become an adult. But she keeps trying. They may not be good examples but she has greatly influenced: Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato...Any girl star on Disney. She may not be the best, but she is an icon. No use denying that.

What do you mean she couldn't keep going?

These all had hits after her teen years were long gone.

Vocal wise, she couldn't keep going. Those albums have processed vocals all the way. she can't sing now. Yes her music is still good, but she she can't sing any more. In fact 4 of her 5 U.S number ones have been in the last 4 years. She is still great at everything else though

Never heard of any of these women except for Britney

vocals

mya

aaliyah

britney

ciara

dancing

mya

ciara

britney

aaliyah

purplemajesty23 said:

Never heard of any of these women except for Britney

And there it is.