funksterr said:

paisleypark4 said:

proof?

The Bodyguard soundtrack. Mariah has nothing in her catalog on that level.

Technically however that's not even a Whitney album lol she did have some nice songs on it ("Queen of the Night" was her best attempt at dance-rock for example lol).

mjscarousal said:

VERY which is why I dont get this comparision. They BOTH were technically good singers in their prime. It all balls down to preference.

Or 'boils down to' even.

Unholyalliance said:

mjscarousal said:

VERY which is why I dont get this comparision. They BOTH were technically good singers in their prime. It all balls down to preference.

Or 'boils down to' even.

Does it make any difference?

Also both of them are boring performers...except for Whitney when she gets into "the spirit".

funksterr said:

paisleypark4 said:

proof?

The Bodyguard soundtrack. Mariah has nothing in her catalog on that level.

Timmy84 said:

Unholyalliance said:

Or 'boils down to' even.

Does it make any difference?

I have never heard of the phrase what it all 'balls down to.' I don't even know what that means. There is 'down to the balls,' but I don't think the poster meant that...

Unholyalliance said:

Timmy84 said:

Does it make any difference?

I have never heard of the phrase what it all 'balls down to.' I don't even know what that means. There is 'down to the balls,' but I don't think the poster meant that...

Yeah, but you were right on the spelling. It's "boils".

LOL So Whitney be doing all that sweatin on stage for nothing?

Tittypants said:

mjscarousal said:

Ive notice that alot of people are bringing other things in the W vs. M arguement that is irrelevant. Regardless if Whitney never wrote a song in her life unlike Carey and all these other I'm sure facts they both have great VOCALS. I never buy into the Diva image bit because to be honest The ONLY Divas that reign Supreme is Aretha and Tina.

This isn't about irrelevance. I'm asking about who had the better MUSIC!

OKAY. WHITNEY aka NIPPY or whatever ya'll like to call her.

END OF DISCUSSION

mjscarousal said:

LOL So Whitney be doing all that sweatin on stage for nothing?

Tittypants said:

This isn't about irrelevance. I'm asking about who had the better MUSIC!

OKAY. WHITNEY aka NIPPY or whatever ya'll like to call her.

END OF DISCUSSION

"It's kinda hot in here, isn't it, can you turn down the heat? It's like 90 degrees in here. DAMN I'M IN HELL!"

I'll take these 2 Mariah trax over anything Whitney did.

Timmy84 said:

mjscarousal said:

LOL So Whitney be doing all that sweatin on stage for nothing?

OKAY. WHITNEY aka NIPPY or whatever ya'll like to call her.

END OF DISCUSSION

"It's kinda hot in here, isn't it, can you turn down the heat? It's like 90 degrees in here. DAMN I'M IN HELL!"

Divaaaazzz! Queen of the night!

robertlove said:

Timmy84 said:

"It's kinda hot in here, isn't it, can you turn down the heat? It's like 90 degrees in here. DAMN I'M IN HELL!"

Divaaaazzz! Queen of the night!

I gotta watch that again.

Timmy84 said:

robertlove said:

Divaaaazzz! Queen of the night!

I gotta watch that again.

yeah, it's the best one of all the episodes.

robertlove said:

Timmy84 said:

I gotta watch that again.

yeah, it's the best one of all the episodes.

Yeah it's up there... to me it's against this and the "Cribs" one.

"WHITNEY! Where's my TV at?!"

"Come on Bobby you know we smoked it!"

Timmy84 said:

robertlove said:

yeah, it's the best one of all the episodes.

Yeah it's up there... to me it's against this and the "Cribs" one.

"WHITNEY! Where's my TV at?!"

"Come on Bobby you know we smoked it!"

Great one too....i love the Chrisitmas special too.

"Merry Crystal Meth Meth!"

That stuff is really one of the funniest stuff i ever saw, and it stays funny. Poor woman.

robertlove said:

Timmy84 said:

Yeah it's up there... to me it's against this and the "Cribs" one.

"WHITNEY! Where's my TV at?!"

"Come on Bobby you know we smoked it!"

Great one too....i love the Chrisitmas special too.

"Merry Crystal Meth Meth!"

That stuff is really one of the funniest stuff i ever saw, and it stays funny. Poor woman.

"Merry Crystalmethmas"... and when they admitted they were addicted to snorting gasoline and they said:

"Unleaded."

"Diesel."

Mariah had better material............never really like Whitney as an artist and still don't.

paisleypark4 said:

funksterr said:

Nobody is in Whitney's class, not even Mariah who is an incredible artist and vocalist

proof?

Proof nothin'. That is not a class I am interested in signing up for. [Insert Patti inspired Robot Whitney GIF here!]

Timmy84 said:

robertlove said:

Divaaaazzz! Queen of the night!

I gotta watch that again.

Please provide details of whatever episodic shenanigans you are referring to. She went there. So if she is going to invite us to come along... The outtakes! Please God send us the outtakes.

allsmutaside said:

paisleypark4 said:

proof?

Proof nothin'. That is not a class I am interested in signing up for. [Insert Patti inspired Robot Whitney GIF here!]

You rang?

[img:$uid]http://www.gifsoup.com/view/33184/patti-robot-o.gif[/img:$uid]

allsmutaside said:

Timmy84 said:

I gotta watch that again.

Please provide details of whatever episodic shenanigans you are referring to. She went there. So if she is going to invite us to come along... The outtakes! Please God send us the outtakes.

HUH?! We were referring to this.

Duh.

Mariah.

daPrettyman said:

I'll take these 2 Mariah trax over anything Whitney did.

Breakdown !!!

Whitney totally owns Mariah

"All The Man I Need" kicks any and everything Mariah ever recorded into the dumpster with the rest of the trash. In Whitney's prime and in Mariah's prime, vocally Whitney smashed her. Today, sure, Mariah could probably (yes, I said probably...Mariah would clown herself trying to sing anything she recorded pre-1993) outsing her...but one thing Whitney STILL has over Mariah in spades to this day is stage presence. Even in the shittiest vocal state, Whitney can rouse a crowd and own the stage. When Mariah performs, it's like watching an ameutur try on Star Search. She almost always looks silly.

[img:$uid]http://stan-wars.com/GIFS/nothere.gif[/img:$uid]

@ all these Whitney votes.

Timmy84 said:

allsmutaside said:

Please provide details of whatever episodic shenanigans you are referring to. She went there. So if she is going to invite us to come along... The outtakes! Please God send us the outtakes.

HUH?! We were referring to this.

Oops! Sorry for being a dumbass, but I thougt you were talking about Bobby and Whitney's reality show.

NaQu said:

"All The Man I Need" kicks any and everything Mariah ever recorded into the dumpster with the rest of the trash. In Whitney's prime and in Mariah's prime, vocally Whitney smashed her. Today, sure, Mariah could probably (yes, I said probably...Mariah would clown herself trying to sing anything she recorded pre-1993) outsing her...but one thing Whitney STILL has over Mariah in spades to this day is stage presence. Even in the shittiest vocal state, Whitney can rouse a crowd and own the stage. When Mariah performs, it's like watching an ameutur try on Star Search. She almost always looks silly.

I could not have put it any better, myself. While both had a gift, I think Mariah used the fact she could sing at a higher range, as a gimmick. In almost all of her early records, she used those notes, constantly, to the point where it was like, enough all ready. Although Whitney, could be found guilty of over singing, She seemed a more disciplined singing, in the beginning.

I like Mariah but honestly,I only own one song by her: "Fly Like A Bird",which I bought from iTunes.She's an amazing singer but I don't like much of her material.She rides the hip-hop bandwagon a little too often for my tastes.

I love Whitney's first two albums and her contributions to the 'Bodyguard' soundtrack.Vainandy's gonna take away my "cool card",lol.

I like Mariah's music better, but for me, it's not even a contest. Whitney imo blows Mariah away vocally.

Sure Mariah is a wonderful singer and can hit those dog whistle notes, but Whitney is a much more powerful singer if you ask me. Mariah tends to sound whiney when she hits her upper register whereas with Whitney, her voice never falters. When she was at her peak, she could not be topped.

Whitney's voice had such strength and clarity. She hit those high notes SO EFFORTLESSLY, which is more than I can say for the likes of Mariah and Christina Aguilera who sound like they're really forcing to hit those high notes.

Whitney is my all time favorite female vocalist. At her peak, she was just incredible. Amazing tone, range, power and perfect diction.

I still get goosebumps whenever I listen to some of her old records. What a gifted singer.

Timmy84 said:

allsmutaside said:

Proof nothin'. That is not a class I am interested in signing up for. [Insert Patti inspired Robot Whitney GIF here!]

You rang?

[img:$uid]http://www.gifsoup.com/view/33184/patti-robot-o.gif[/img:$uid]

[img:$uid]http://i159.photobucket.com/albums/t145/theodore_3121/Gifs/patti.gif[/img:$uid]