Author | Message |
Is Janelle Monáe tone deaf or does she sing that way on purpose? Listening to Janelle Monáe sing becomes a test of patience for me. It becomes frustrating and a huge annoyance after a while, because it always sounds as if she's singing everywhere and never entirely in one direction. Like, she'll take a song all across the world, but never in an actual path. I think this became apparent when my friend and I watched her singing on some late night talk show and we thought that maybe it was just the equipment messing up. Though, after hearing her critically acclaimed album and hearing some more of her live we came to the conclusion that it wasn't the equipment. It's actually her. The only time I can even bear to stand her is when she's 'sing talking' like Ke$ha, in such songs as: Tightrope and Dance or Die. Curious about a musician's opinion I showed my friend, who is an opera singer, some of her work and then we started to talk about music and singing. Also, we discussed who he considered were some of the standout singers in the pop music & opera world.
When I showed her to him he pretty much agreed with me, but put it in better words: He said that while her songs are very simple she never actually hits any of the notes. She sings around the notes all the while avoiding the actual notes themselves. There are times when she will hit them, but it's just too inconsistant and makes for some squirm inducing singing. She does have a lovely voice, but she, herself, has a hard time singing with it, which is unfortunate. The worst is when the band is playing one thing and she's singing something else entirely different from them. They are not even on the same page half of the time. Hearing her perform makes me upset sometimes...it's like listening to Taylor Swift sing, only that Janelle Monáe singing makes me want to sleep as opposed to Taylor's which makes me want to tear out my eardrums.
My friend said that he could only explain this as 'abstract music,' but he was done with listening to her as it was putting his nerves on edge. So I talked about how I really like a lot of Motown singers, because they sang with the beat. Then he said that was why Michael Jackson could break the rules later , because he already knew them. So, because of that many singers try to follow that, but it just hurts them because they don't really have a strong grasp of the actual foundation themselves. (I want to liken this as being similar to the postmodern/post-impressionism eras in Western art...kinda. But even then most of those artists had very strong foundations in the basics, i.e. Picasso, before they went out and broke all the rules later.)
tl; dr? Does Janelle Monae sing that way on purpose because it's some kind of artistic decision that she feels is neccessary for her music or is it because she's tone deaf and can't really sing all that well? Like, is she in desperate need of a vocal coach?
My friend didn't really answer this, but I figure that some of you JM buffs would, possibly, know a little bit more. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
OK....I'm not a JM buff by any means, but I agree with pretty much everything you have said. I have wondered ever since she came onto the scene why so many people have been raving about her because her music is pretty mediocre and average. I believe she sings like that on purpose.....its part of her style......and she does have style. BUT her style does not make up for her music.
You would think by the way people talk about her that; a) Her voice and singing are just BLOW YOU AWAY good, or b) Her voice is so unique that it makes you notice in a good way (Like say Bjork or David Byrne) or c) Her music is so different and unique that it BLOWS YOU AWAY.
I don't think any of these 3 apply to Janelle. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I don't think she's tone deaf, I actually like her voice...however I'm not that crazy about her music, and there are many more talented vocalists out there as well. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Opera singers are out of tune all the time. Not to mention many of them are using vibrato so much that it's silly. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Unholyalliance...Thank you! Thank you! THANK YOU!
I have been saying since I first heard of Janelle Monae that her performances makes me feel like I'm about to have a seizure. Everything about them is just so all over the place with absolutely no direction!
I was really beginning to think that I was the only one that could see and hear it!
I want to give her the benefit of the doubt because I really do think she's talented and has a lovely voice but to me it's like somebody took little bits and pieces of every musical great of the last 60 or so years, crammed them all into her, for her to try and unleash all at once.
It's just too much of everything and not enough of anything!!! I knew from the start that I loved you with all my heart. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think I´m getting old. I don´t really get her. Nor do I get what is so great about most other contemporary artists. As far as I´m concerned, I´m stuck somewhere in the mid to late 90s. I don´t get Kanye West either (sure, he´s a decent producer,but he ain´t all that). I don´t get Janelle Monae, I don´t get that other chick that Prince and Obama like so much, I don´t understand all the rave about Drake, I find the BEPs obnoxious...I don´t really understand why all these artists are so full of themselves, I liked bits and pieces of some Alica Keys albums but no,I wouldn´t say I like her.
Send me to an old people´s home already, I feel like Arthur Spooner and his clique.
" I´d rather be a stank ass hoe because I´m not stupid. Oh my goodness! I got more drugs! I´m always funny dude...I´m hilarious! Are we gonna smoke?" | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I don't hear it - to me she can sing, and actually pretty well and seems pretty on-the-beat to me. At least on record. Live she's bit spotty (like during the BET tribute to Prince).
Check out the songs "Violet Stars Happy Hunting" and "Tightrope". To me on those she actually sounds like Michael Jackson when he was little, and he obviously could sing his ass off.
My issue is with most of the actual songs themselves, because barring the two I just named off, I just can't get into her work and it annoys me because it's like - everything else works for me, I just don't like most of the songs she sings. "I don't think you'd do well in captivity." - random person's comment to me the other day | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I enjoy her "various" styles of singing she gives to the tracks of her song from her talk/sing approach to the sometimes operatic (?sp) sounds in her music. Her style of music takes time for some to grow on. She does have a different sound not similar to the manufactured artists on the scene today, who are just direct carbon copies of earlier artists, who don't know how to adopt a style and make it their own. It's not unusual for artists to copy or emulate another's style, it's another thing though, to be creative with it, and mold it into your own recipe. Janelle, in my opinion, isn't an artist you can "put in a box" and is not as predictable as artists like Beyonce, Jay-Z, Rihanna, Gaga, etc. Just my 2 cents.
[Edited 3/30/11 12:01pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I saw her in Boston last June opening for Erykah Badu and couldn't STAND her voice, her music or even her entire act. It was noisy, although energized and apparent that she did not perform a sound check prior to her performance. I don't think she's any big deal really. BUT, I WILL SAY that she's a step up from the droves of other women today who are dominating the R&B charts; just not THAT much of step up in my opinion. I've seen/heard WAY better. Hungry? Just look in the mirror and get fed up. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
She's awesome. "Whitney was purely and simply one of a kind." ~ Clive Davis | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I enjoy Janelle and her performances and her CD. My only issue with her is the whole costume getup which I hope she changes soon because it has grown tired. She has a wonderful voice, gurl can sang! She has character and is a breath of fresh air from the crap that is constantly played on the radio. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I agree I'M NOT SAYING YOU'RE UGLY. YOU JUST HAVE BAD LUCK WHEN IT COMES TO MIRRORS AND SUNLIGHT!
RIP Dick Clark, Whitney Houston, Don Cornelius, Heavy D, and Donna Summer. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
so she's no longer an associated artist? I'M NOT SAYING YOU'RE UGLY. YOU JUST HAVE BAD LUCK WHEN IT COMES TO MIRRORS AND SUNLIGHT!
RIP Dick Clark, Whitney Houston, Don Cornelius, Heavy D, and Donna Summer. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I don't know what her not being able to be 'put in a box' has to do with the fact that she is unable to sing her own songs properly and hit the notes in a consistent manner. Last time I checked...I don't even think that they two have anything to do with each other.
They are still off, but her live performances tend to be far worse.
When I listen to this:
This doesn't sound off to me. She sounds as if her voice is flowing with the instruments, as if they are one. Ella is not fighting against it, but flowing with it. They sound as one. Together. In harmony.
Or even here:
The vocals and instrumentals sound as if they are making sweet love together as they are totally in sync with one another. Also, this was as pop music as you can get back at that time as well. So it should not matter if it's mainstream or not. The only thing that should matter is how the music sounds and only that. I don't care if the performer is completely naked, wearing a potato sack, looks like Jabba the Hut, or whatever. All that should matter is the music and how it sounds. If something is off...is doesn't sound as pleasant. Which is what I believe to be the point of this kind of music:
Tightrope sounds more like older MJ kinda like in 'Jam'. Well, to me anyways.
So...what does this have to do with Janelle Monáe? Are you trying to imply that opera singers are so out of tune, as a collective, that they are unable to judge when someone else is in or out of tune?
Also, to the Janelle Monáe defense brigade that's making their way in here, whether or not you like her is is all good and not the point. This doesn't make her any better of a vocalist or singer. Her being 'different' from the mainstream doesn't mean that makes her any better of a vocalist or singer either. It's one thing if she's doing it for a greater purpose, but many times...it just doesn't seem to be the case.
[Edited 3/30/11 14:31pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think she is adorable, but her music is overrated imo. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Is there anyone that this board like? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I would like to thank the OP for this thread. I went and looked up Janelle Monae on Youtube and found the song Cold War- which I'm diggin!
I think the girl can sing, she just can't improvise notes. Not everyone can do it. My two biggest regrets:
1. That I wasn't born early enough to see Prince perform the oldies in person. 2. That I wasn't born early enough to see Michael Jackson perform in person. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Curtwill1975 said: Is there anyone that this board like? A couple of months ago, "Cold War" was voted our favorite song of 2010. "Whitney was purely and simply one of a kind." ~ Clive Davis | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I LOVE her. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Your welcome. =D | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
SAME!!!!!!!!
I Saw her at the Stevie Wonder show i did she was fantastic Pistols sounded like "Fuck off," wheras The Clash sounded like "Fuck Off, but here's why.."- Thedigitialgardener
All music is shit music and no music is real- gunsnhalen Datdonkeydick- Asherfierce Gary Hunts Album Isn't That Good- Soulalive | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
^^^ Guess some people are tone-deaf to the fabulous sounds that we hear!!! "Music gives a soul to the universe, wings to the mind, flight to the imagination and life to everything." --Plato
https://youtu.be/CVwv9LZMah0 | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Well, you brought up opera singers yourself in the first place. Your friend being an opera singer and telling us about his views was supposed to give validity to your own views on Janelle Monae being out of tune all the time. So why did you even mention it if you feel now that it is irrelevant?
I'm not a Janelle Monae fan and neither have I even listened to her new album from start to finish. I might do that one of these days, but it's not on the list of my priorities. However, calling her material "abstract music" is definitely an overstatement by your friend. You really shouldn't have quoted that, because it just exposes he doesn't have much of an idea how abstract music can be. Janelle Monae's music is not abstract music.
To answer your question: The implication was not that "opera singers are so out of tune as, a collective, that they are unable to to judge when someone else is in or out of tune". The implication was that using an opera singer's view really doesn't back up your views as much as you seem to have thought it would. I found it ironic that an opera singer would criticize an R&B / pop singer doing something similar when a very large percentage of opera singers warble around the correct notes all the time.
I'd like to comment on something else as well. You wrote:
He said that while her songs are very simple she never actually hits any of the notes. Which was soon followed by: There are times when she will hit them, but it's just too inconsistant [sic] and makes for some squirm inducing singing. Try to abstain from backing up your views with such overstatements from other people and then toning them down yourself later on. It's an annoying tactic when you're trying to express a negative opinion on someone.
In case you are wondering why I am giving you such a long response: I personally dislike long diatribes about someone's artistic or intellectual output when the argumentation is illogical and contains obvious overstatements. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think she is fantatic! Great singer! Great songs! Great live peformer!! And I'm not the only one...
and as long as I got Stevie Wonder and Prince on my team! I'm winning!! [Edited 3/31/11 0:45am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
she actually sounds like frankie lymon... she has a cute voice... it does sound like that typical black kid church voice...
she has the tools... not the technique.....
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
All I know is that I really like listening to her music
I love her work, but I admit I haven't enjoyed the two covers I've seen her do (Let's Go Crazy at the BET awards and Smile, somewhere on yt). Maybe what you've said here has something to do with it (ie. her unique style doesn't translate well to singing other people's songs) or maybe I just enjoy other versions more
Lake Minnetonka Music: https://lakeminnetonka.bandcamp.com/
Lake Minnetonka Press Kit: http://onepagelink.com/lakeminnetonka/ | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
utter nonsense | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I'll take a listen with this perspective in mind.
| |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I definitely think she's talented and interesting but there's two things stopping me from getting into her yet.
1) Her vocal skills are mediocre. 2) Her songs are generally kinda incoherent and all over the place.
If she can improve number two and write some classic tunes I may become a fan! Music, sweet music, I wish I could caress and...kiss, kiss... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |