THE first posthumous release by Michael Jackson will thrill fans, but it's hard to get past what it is - songs the perfectionist hadn't finished and were completed after his death.
The album, Michael, hits stores on Friday. It has 10 previously unreleased Jackson songs brought "to completion" since his death by various producers.
The first single release, Breaking News, was a tactical error. Not only is the song weak, but Jackson's heavily-treated vocals started the destructive rumours that soundalike singers were used on the album.
Certainly the rest of Michael sounds like Jackson's unmistakable voice; the star had spent the years after 2001's Invincible - his last studio album - working on new songs with all manner of producers and songwriters, from A-listers to virtual unknowns.
The single Hold My Hand is more polished than the leaked version from a few years back.
Keep Your Head Up is the inspirational moment, complete with gospel choir. It's a strong find, with
Jackson coming back to real life lyrically.
(I Like) The Way You Love Me first appeared on a Jackson compilation in 2004 in demo form. The smooth R&B jam now starts with the singer sketching out the plan for the song on an answering machine. It's a showcase for his voice.
Monster recalls the mechanical R&B of Scream, with Jackson sounding angry, as he slips back into Thriller mode.
Best of Joy is a simple moment that harks back to his Motown era.
(I Can't Make It) Another Day was written and produced by Lenny Kravitz a decade ago and it shows. Jackson's voice is particularly strong on the chorus and, bizarrely, Dave Grohl drums on the track.
Behind the Mask sees Jackson add vocals - and vocoder - to the Yellow Magic Orchestra instrumental, singing "take off the mask so I can see your face".
The best is kept till last.
Much Too Soon was written around the time of Thriller. It's a nicely understated ballad in the vein of Ben, with harmonica and Spanish guitar.
It'll be interesting to see what comes out of the Jackson vaults next. He had been working with Lady Gaga's producer, RedOne, and Black Eyed Pea's will.i.am.
Michael is far from the barrel-scraper cynics suggested.