Yeah he needs to shut up..but he probably won't.

missfee said:

No-one can beat The Sundays cover of Wild Horses. Subsequent versions have always tried to copy that one.

Ellie said:

Merry me!

allsmutaside said:

He doesn't need to shut up, that's the point. This is a country where we can voice our opinion. And him being a singer and critiquing another singer is exactly what he's allowed to do. Prince used to say, "Critics aren't musicians. I don't critique what they write. I don't write books. They don't write music." and later said that only musicians should be able to critique other musicians. Here we have a perfect example of that, yet people are still getting their pads in a bunch over it.

Maybe the OP is a hard core Susan Boyle fan. Maybe, for them, Susan Boyle is the end all and be all of the music dream.

Maybe the OP is just bored.

Either way, Adam Lambert spoke his mind. Big deal.
The OP spoke their mind. Big deal.

Damn, some of you all need to .

It's obvious that author of this thread used the opening line "Does Lambert need to shut up?" to build interest in a larger conversation.

Gee, like Bjork sings, "You're trying too hard, undo!"

ernestsewell said:

Well, not a perfect example because you've stated the singers aren't musicians

tubby said:

Yet if he plays an instrument, he is a musician, although I don't know if he plays anything at all. Regardless, it's one SINGER talking about another SINGER. So my argument still stands.

ernestsewell said:

Dude....I was joking.

missfee said:

Tell me about it. Along with a whole slew of celebrities who got famous by doing reality television.

He needs to shut the FUCK up. Forever. And 100 years after that.
I don't think he's gay. I think he's just playing the card....

ScarletScandal said:

Have u seen some of his early videos (pre-Idol) on youtube? He is DEFINITELY gay.

ScarletScandal said:

to distract people from his big noggin.

He seems to be talented, decent looking--he could be a decent star. I don't care if he wears makeup or if he's gay.

But somehow it all adds up to something that is totally unappealing to me and, more importantly, the music is uninteresting.

It seems like a bunch of flash, and not nice flash at that. Have some music behind it as good as Bowie, Prince, and who cares how big his head is?

tubby said:

Just coverin' bases.

What a Diva!

Love his album...

I don't see why he NEEDS to shut up. He simply gave his opinion about someone's cd. No different than if it were any of us sharing our opinion in an interveiw about how we felt about someone's cd or song. So, he thought her rendition of Wild Horses was funny and her cd horrible. So what! Was he SUPPOSE to say he liked it?
[Edited 4/16/10 2:43am]