I amo not going by music i am going my image and appeal which of these women has the better appeal in your opinion.

Rihanna's bad girl rated R image with short hair evil looking tortorus don't give a damn vixen




Beyonce's Sasha Fierce the agressive sensual seductive vixen

Rihanna may not be as "talented" vocally but she is hotter and not nearly as over-exposed. Rihanna anyday. But in truth, I'd probably pick the hobo singer/songwriter off the street over Beyonce. Here is Beyonce's best picture.



[Edited 11/26/09 13:10pm]

Beyonce, I'm not feeling the new Rihanna image

Neither. Both images are demonic.


[Edited 11/26/09 15:29pm]

Their elder sister:

Timmy84 said:

Thank You! I remember Janet being a very bad girl during The Velvet Rope era.

but a bad girl with class

Timmy84 said:

Has that picture been altered in some way? That doesn't look like Janet's face.

Oh, and I pick Beyonce. Overall, B's just better. She needs to cover up her legs though, 'cause that look is getting old quick.

I just turned to Beyonce's concert special on ABC. She's been wearing tights onstage, instead of showing completely bare-legs. She read my mind.

WaterInYourBath said:

No this is how Janet was looking during the 20 YO era lol

Timmy84 said:

Ahh, ok. I thought someone did something to change her smile. I've never seen it like that before.

Image wise, Rihanna murders Beyonce AND "Sasha Fierce". Bey will never be on Rih's level image and style wise

WaterInYourBath said:

That's interesting because Janet mentioned in an interview the other day that she used to think that her smile was too big. It IS pretty wide on this picture---but lovely just the same.

Timmy84 said:

Janet is NOT even capable of being mentioned in the same sentence. Damita Jo shits on EVERY female. END

ViintageJunkiie said:

Thats true, but I don't think Rihanna will ever be on Beyonces level performance wise. Musically I think they're equal though

Rihanna, she can be exciting with her image, Beyonce's always too safe even when she's being "bad".

Unfortunatley Beyonce had the more intresting album but Rhianna had better image

Since when did anyone but Grace Jones get call themselves firece

neither. they both looks pretty poserific.

Janis Joplin/Pat Benetar/Stevie Nicks FTW

Both are quite unconvincing.

neoretro7 said:

Beyonce or Rihanna...hmmmm...NEITHER!

I gotta go with Rihanna. Although let's face it Beyoce is more talented but she is also kinda boring. Rihanna seems more inetresting and less predeictable.

Both are so manufactured Janet did it better

Timmy84 said:

LMFAOO!!! I'm so glad she gained weight back

midiscover said:

she was manufactured better? yes.

errant said:

She's not manufactured Her image didn't come as forced or unconvincing.

ehuffnsd said:

midiscover said:

no, it didn't. which is why i say she was manufactured better. she came out of the most famous family in music, got hooked up with really hot producers and choreographers, and got massive exposure in the video age. she is the very definition of manufactured. but she did it all very well.

errant said:

How does coming from the most famous family of music have to do with her image? It has nothing to do with it. Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis weren't hott producer before they met Janet. That also has nothing to do with her image. They became hott after Control went big. She's not manufactured. Her image evolved just like her music. In a way it was like her listeners grew up with her because her image fitted what she was going through in her life. Rihanna and Britney Spears is what you call manufactured. How do you go from Caribbean girl singing reggae music with no sense of style to a fashion queen with edgier music? It's all BS>