independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Michael Jackson's doctor
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 3 of 5 <12345>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #60 posted 09/04/09 12:59pm

Timmy84

kibbles said:

Timmy84 said:

Yep, the same thing that MJ collapsed from was the same drug that ended up killing him and YES he trusted the doctor. So it wasn't like he didn't know he was giving the stuff, it's just the dosage thing that Mike wasn't so clear about but he trusted him to give him that stuff though he wasn't even required to even do that.


exactly. he trusted this doctor, according to randy phillips. yes, he was looking for someone to administer propofol (sadly, tragically), and had been turned down by most he approached, due to the unusual request. i'm sure mj was aware that it *could be* dangerous if not properly administered - all drugs are.

i don't think murray would have received the job even if he was willing to do it if mj had the slightest inkling that murray wasn't capable and qualifed to administer it to him. what would be the point in that?
[Edited 9/4/09 12:57pm]


Yeah even ASPIRIN can kill you if you overtake it or someone over-prescribed you with it.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #61 posted 09/04/09 1:05pm

babybugz

avatar

Timmy84 said:

babybugz said:


neutral Yeah he really needed the money ,I always wonder why Michael didn't write songs for people(in this era)he could have made alot of money from that.


I wonder a lot of things. Why he start projects, then stop. I think he was tired of it all but then when pushed with this debt thing, I guess he felt he couldn't do anything BUT perform. While this investigation into his death is unusual, the way MJ's life played out, I'm not surprised that he died the way he did. Sad shit.

Yeah he probably just wanted to sit back and relax but I always felt he could
have wrote and produce for people and get money like that and yeah I agree his
death comes off less shocking everyday smh.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #62 posted 09/04/09 5:19pm

prodigalfan

avatar

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

this doctor is clearly a scapegoat. If he goes down I hope it's not alone. But I really hope he evades murder charges.



Negligible homocide dammit... THAT IS WHAT IT WAS if the reports are true that he gave propofol. I don't care how many times MJ got it before... it was THAT time that stopped his heart. Real Talk!
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #63 posted 09/04/09 5:21pm

prodigalfan

avatar

mimi07 said:

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

this doctor is clearly a scapegoat. If he goes down I hope it's not alone. But I really hope he evades murder charges.

when murray accepted to do this he put himself in this postirion. he knew what could happened if something goes wrong, he;s the doctor and he knows what he's qualified to do and took it apon himself to do something not in his field.

YES there are other doctors involved that should get prosecuted and i think something will happen to them but murray is the main target and rightfully so since his actions directly lead to michael's passing


clappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclappingclapping
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #64 posted 09/04/09 5:23pm

prodigalfan

avatar

kibbles said:

suga10 said:

Maybe it was a case of assisted suicide.

Who knows.

And Murray just gave in to Michael's wishes.



highly doubtful, but even so, that's illegal in the state of california. dr. kevorkian, an infamous 'assisted suicide' doctor in oregon, just got of prison for 2nd degree murder.

i think what the police are struggling with is whether this is manslaughter or 2nd degree murder.

manslaughter, with its unintentional gross negligence implications, is mitigated by the doctor's other actions. if dr. murray had injected mj, left and came back to find him in distress, then did everything in his power to assist him, and mj still died, then i can see manslaughter. the doctor was negligent by leaving him, not having the proper equipment to revive him, and using a medicine beyond its intended use.

but, for me, what elevate this to a higher charge is the fact that not only did he do the above, he then:

*did not call 911 asap
*did not inform the paramedics what he gave mj immediately
*made a series of phone calls while mj lied there dying
*lied about not knowing the address of the residence
*stalls for time by looking for security, prince
*did not tell anyone at the hospital what he gave mj
*did not want to speak to police about the circumstances of mj's death
*dropped out of sight for 2 days
*finally, after lawyering up, admitted to the propofol

moreover, if the rumors are true, mj was likely already dead when the paramedics arrived. i'm sorry but this scenario points to something more than manslaughter. even if he got *only* manslaughter, they're probably going to tack on obstruction of justice, inappropriate use of a drug, administering to (presumed) addict, and maybe other charges.


Dr. Death is from Michigan. And you are right he just got out of prison for assisted suicide even though the people made video tapes and signed documents (if physically able to sign) that it was their own wish to be assisted in suicide. if MJ's doctor get off LAPD and LA DA are full of it... they need to bring Murray to Michigan!
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #65 posted 09/04/09 5:28pm

BoOTyLiCioUs

prodigalfan said:

kibbles said:




highly doubtful, but even so, that's illegal in the state of california. dr. kevorkian, an infamous 'assisted suicide' doctor in oregon, just got of prison for 2nd degree murder.

i think what the police are struggling with is whether this is manslaughter or 2nd degree murder.

manslaughter, with its unintentional gross negligence implications, is mitigated by the doctor's other actions. if dr. murray had injected mj, left and came back to find him in distress, then did everything in his power to assist him, and mj still died, then i can see manslaughter. the doctor was negligent by leaving him, not having the proper equipment to revive him, and using a medicine beyond its intended use.

but, for me, what elevate this to a higher charge is the fact that not only did he do the above, he then:

*did not call 911 asap
*did not inform the paramedics what he gave mj immediately
*made a series of phone calls while mj lied there dying
*lied about not knowing the address of the residence
*stalls for time by looking for security, prince
*did not tell anyone at the hospital what he gave mj
*did not want to speak to police about the circumstances of mj's death
*dropped out of sight for 2 days
*finally, after lawyering up, admitted to the propofol

moreover, if the rumors are true, mj was likely already dead when the paramedics arrived. i'm sorry but this scenario points to something more than manslaughter. even if he got *only* manslaughter, they're probably going to tack on obstruction of justice, inappropriate use of a drug, administering to (presumed) addict, and maybe other charges.


Dr. Death is from Michigan. And you are right he just got out of prison for assisted suicide even though the people made video tapes and signed documents (if physically able to sign) that it was their own wish to be assisted in suicide. if MJ's doctor get off LAPD and LA DA are full of it... they need to bring Murray to Michigan!


lol I went to school in michigan. Probably from detroit or flint...those dudes there are CRAZY.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #66 posted 09/04/09 5:29pm

BoOTyLiCioUs

suga10 said:

Maybe it was a case of assisted suicide.

Who knows.

And Murray just gave in to Michael's wishes.

That's why LAPD is not being so harsh on Murray.


Or their tests were inclusive, and they used the Propofol excuse to end all the speculation.
[Edited 9/4/09 11:32am]


no no no and more nos. It could be anything but not suicide. Michael loved his kids too much to do something like that. i'm sure he was depressed but suicidal....NO NO NO NO.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #67 posted 09/04/09 5:30pm

prodigalfan

avatar

kibbles said:

suga10 said:

Maybe it was a case of assisted suicide.

Who knows.

And Murray just gave in to Michael's wishes.



highly doubtful, but even so, that's illegal in the state of california. dr. kevorkian, an infamous 'assisted suicide' doctor in oregon, just got of prison for 2nd degree murder.

i think what the police are struggling with is whether this is manslaughter or 2nd degree murder.

manslaughter, with its unintentional gross negligence implications, is mitigated by the doctor's other actions. if dr. murray had injected mj, left and came back to find him in distress, then did everything in his power to assist him, and mj still died, then i can see manslaughter. the doctor was negligent by leaving him, not having the proper equipment to revive him, and using a medicine beyond its intended use.

but, for me, what elevate this to a higher charge is the fact that not only did he do the above, he then:

*did not call 911 asap
*did not inform the paramedics what he gave mj immediately
*made a series of phone calls while mj lied there dying
*lied about not knowing the address of the residence
*stalls for time by looking for security, prince
*did not tell anyone at the hospital what he gave mj
*did not want to speak to police about the circumstances of mj's death
*dropped out of sight for 2 days
*finally, after lawyering up, admitted to the propofol

moreover, if the rumors are true, mj was likely already dead when the paramedics arrived. i'm sorry but this scenario points to something more than manslaughter. even if he got *only* manslaughter, they're probably going to tack on obstruction of justice, inappropriate use of a drug, administering to (presumed) addict, and maybe other charges.



Oh and bravo on the point that he hid what the "bleep" he gave MJ to first responders. If MJ had a chance... by not telling exactly what, how much and when med was given... that omission could make a difference in life or death.
Some meds can be given that can counteract the affects of opiates (etc) almost instantly!
But if anyone who has worked with propofol knows.. this med begins to clear the system in less than 3 - 5 minutes after being shut off. So chances are MJ dies while this med was still being pumped into his body. By the time he was discovered... he was long dead. Sorry so blunt but it is the truth.

God bless MJ and his family. It really is such a tragedy.
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #68 posted 09/04/09 5:30pm

BoOTyLiCioUs

NpgSoldier said:

suga10 said:

Maybe it was a case of assisted suicide.

Sad, but these are my thoughts too.


no no no no and more nos. It is not suicide and it has not been ruled a suicide from day 1.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #69 posted 09/04/09 5:46pm

prodigalfan

avatar

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

I don't think MJ deserved death. MJ bought the weapon, loaded the gun and threw incentives for someone to pull the trigger. This is the bottom line. I do hope the doctor does not go down alone, if at all.

And why don't we ask EXACTLY WHY Michael hired Dr. Murray. Could it be he knew he'd get his way because of this dumbasses mess of a life? If you dangle meat in front of a starving dog, you should not be surprised if it bites your hand.
[Edited 9/4/09 12:09pm]




but in your scenario, if the starving dog stole the meat guess what.... IT IS STILL STEALING!

Even if MJ gave him the gone and paid him BIG money to pull the trigger... Murray pulled the trigger. That is the crime. You can't spin this any other way. And Murray doesn't get a pass.... it is not like he was a homey from the hood who didn't know what the f8ck he had... HE KNEW! and he KNEW the risks.
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #70 posted 09/04/09 5:58pm

shorttrini

avatar

prodigalfan said:

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:

I don't think MJ deserved death. MJ bought the weapon, loaded the gun and threw incentives for someone to pull the trigger. This is the bottom line. I do hope the doctor does not go down alone, if at all.

And why don't we ask EXACTLY WHY Michael hired Dr. Murray. Could it be he knew he'd get his way because of this dumbasses mess of a life? If you dangle meat in front of a starving dog, you should not be surprised if it bites your hand.
[Edited 9/4/09 12:09pm]




but in your scenario, if the starving dog stole the meat guess what.... IT IS STILL STEALING!

Even if MJ gave him the gone and paid him BIG money to pull the trigger... Murray pulled the trigger. That is the crime. You can't spin this any other way. And Murray doesn't get a pass.... it is not like he was a homey from the hood who didn't know what the f8ck he had... HE KNEW! and he KNEW the risks.


Here is what I think. If it was Dr. Murray, it was going to be someone else. Michael had been taking drugs for years, so for the authorities to only focus on him is a little weird. I never thought that MJ would live to a ripe old age. One of the reasons why celebs do what they do, is because people are afraid to tell them NO! When you work for a celeb, it seems like your integrity goes right out of the window.
[Edited 9/4/09 18:19pm]
"Love is like peeing in your pants, everyone sees it but only you feel its warmth"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #71 posted 09/04/09 6:00pm

Timmy84

shorttrini said:

prodigalfan said:





but in your scenario, if the starving dog stole the meat guess what.... IT IS STILL STEALING!

Even if MJ gave him the gone and paid him BIG money to pull the trigger... Murray pulled the trigger. That is the crime. You can't spin this any other way. And Murray doesn't get a pass.... it is not like he was a homey from the hood who didn't know what the f8ck he had... HE KNEW! and he KNEW the risks.


Here is what I think. If it was Dr. Murray, it was going to be someone else. Michael had been taking drugs for years, so for the authorities to only focus on his is a little weird. I never thought that MJ would live to a ripe old age. One of the reasons why celebs do what they do, is because people are afraid to tell them NO! When you work for a celeb, it seems like your integrity goes right out of the window.


Exactly. This is what leads me to believe the LAPD are going to indict OTHER doctors on charges. If it was that simple, Murray would've been arrested LAST MONTH.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #72 posted 09/04/09 6:14pm

dearmother

avatar

kibbles said:

even if the stand at o2 had been successful, mj would have only been hated more as a 'freak' for a number of unconfortable reasons that i won't elaborate on here.


you really think so?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #73 posted 09/04/09 6:23pm

shorttrini

avatar

Timmy84 said:

shorttrini said:



Here is what I think. If it was Dr. Murray, it was going to be someone else. Michael had been taking drugs for years, so for the authorities to only focus on him is a little weird. I never thought that MJ would live to a ripe old age. One of the reasons why celebs do what they do, is because people are afraid to tell them NO! When you work for a celeb, it seems like your integrity goes right out of the window.


Exactly. This is what leads me to believe the LAPD are going to indict OTHER doctors on charges. If it was that simple, Murray would've been arrested LAST MONTH.


I was looking at his press conference for his O2 concerts, that he held back in March. Michael was HIGH at that conference!!, so, I am willing to bet, that others were in on it....Not Just Murray.
"Love is like peeing in your pants, everyone sees it but only you feel its warmth"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #74 posted 09/04/09 6:26pm

Timmy84

shorttrini said:

Timmy84 said:



Exactly. This is what leads me to believe the LAPD are going to indict OTHER doctors on charges. If it was that simple, Murray would've been arrested LAST MONTH.


I was looking at his press conference for his O2 concerts, that he held back in March. Michael was HIGH at that conference!!, so, I am willing to bet, that others were in on it....Not Just Murray.


Yeah and MJ hired Murray in May.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #75 posted 09/04/09 6:42pm

shorttrini

avatar

Timmy84 said:

shorttrini said:



I was looking at his press conference for his O2 concerts, that he held back in March. Michael was HIGH at that conference!!, so, I am willing to bet, that others were in on it....Not Just Murray.


Yeah and MJ hired Murray in May.


Really? I did not know this.
"Love is like peeing in your pants, everyone sees it but only you feel its warmth"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #76 posted 09/04/09 6:49pm

prodigalfan

avatar

mimi07 said:

SupaFunkyOrgangrinderSexy said:



I'm sure the rewards clouded his judgement. He should have run very fast from Michael Jackson but Michael had the resources to hire a team of the most brilliant medical minds that the world had to offer. But he didn't. Why? Because he knew he wouldn't get his way.

that's no excuse for any doctor, if michael was an addict like they claim an dthey saw he had a problem the should have done something. these are things michael could get on his own, people were giving it to him.

and the thing that bothers me is WHO introduced propfol to michael in the first place, mike ain't no medical professional to come up with the idea of using it to sleep on his own... some doctor suggested it. they said michael had a "mini clinic" on the history tour, an anesthiologist was with him also...at least he knew what he was doing.



Bingo! There is your answer. This is most likely where MJ first got Propofol for sleep.
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #77 posted 09/04/09 7:07pm

Timmy84

shorttrini said:

Timmy84 said:



Yeah and MJ hired Murray in May.


Really? I did not know this.


Yep, he had just hired him. Who knows what he was doing between March and May unless it was just seeking dancers and musicians out.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #78 posted 09/04/09 7:10pm

kibbles

shorttrini said:

prodigalfan said:





but in your scenario, if the starving dog stole the meat guess what.... IT IS STILL STEALING!

Even if MJ gave him the gone and paid him BIG money to pull the trigger... Murray pulled the trigger. That is the crime. You can't spin this any other way. And Murray doesn't get a pass.... it is not like he was a homey from the hood who didn't know what the f8ck he had... HE KNEW! and he KNEW the risks.


Here is what I think. If it was Dr. Murray, it was going to be someone else. Michael had been taking drugs for years, so for the authorities to only focus on him is a little weird. I never thought that MJ would live to a ripe old age. One of the reasons why celebs do what they do, is because people are afraid to tell them NO! When you work for a celeb, it seems like your integrity goes right out of the window.
[Edited 9/4/09 18:19pm]


i never understand the so-called logic behind this statement, and i see people making it all the time. well, duh. yeah, if it wasn't murray, it would have been someone else. and your point? if it was someone else, we'd be talking about how that person is looking at manslaughter charges.

as i and many other people have pointed out, it doesn't matter what other drugs were in mj's system, assuming there were. did you not see the coroner's report? it stated mj died from propofol overdose with the sedatives that murray gave him as underlying factors in his death. DRUGS MURRAY GAVE HIM. whether mj had aspirin or oxycontin or heroin in his system, that's not the point. he died from what murray gave him.

honestly, people, come on!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #79 posted 09/04/09 7:14pm

Timmy84

Then arrest him. If we post by Christmas and Murray ain't arrested, I'm convinced the LAPD is just slow as fuck.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #80 posted 09/04/09 7:20pm

kibbles

prodigalfan said:

kibbles said:




highly doubtful, but even so, that's illegal in the state of california. dr. kevorkian, an infamous 'assisted suicide' doctor in oregon, just got of prison for 2nd degree murder.

i think what the police are struggling with is whether this is manslaughter or 2nd degree murder.

manslaughter, with its unintentional gross negligence implications, is mitigated by the doctor's other actions. if dr. murray had injected mj, left and came back to find him in distress, then did everything in his power to assist him, and mj still died, then i can see manslaughter. the doctor was negligent by leaving him, not having the proper equipment to revive him, and using a medicine beyond its intended use.

but, for me, what elevate this to a higher charge is the fact that not only did he do the above, he then:

*did not call 911 asap
*did not inform the paramedics what he gave mj immediately
*made a series of phone calls while mj lied there dying
*lied about not knowing the address of the residence
*stalls for time by looking for security, prince
*did not tell anyone at the hospital what he gave mj
*did not want to speak to police about the circumstances of mj's death
*dropped out of sight for 2 days
*finally, after lawyering up, admitted to the propofol

moreover, if the rumors are true, mj was likely already dead when the paramedics arrived. i'm sorry but this scenario points to something more than manslaughter. even if he got *only* manslaughter, they're probably going to tack on obstruction of justice, inappropriate use of a drug, administering to (presumed) addict, and maybe other charges.



Oh and bravo on the point that he hid what the "bleep" he gave MJ to first responders. If MJ had a chance... by not telling exactly what, how much and when med was given... that omission could make a difference in life or death.
Some meds can be given that can counteract the affects of opiates (etc) almost instantly!

But if anyone who has worked with propofol knows.. this med begins to clear the system in less than 3 - 5 minutes after being shut off. So chances are MJ dies while this med was still being pumped into his body. By the time he was discovered... he was long dead. Sorry so blunt but it is the truth.

God bless MJ and his family. It really is such a tragedy.


exactly. assuming mj had a chance (and that's a really big assumption at this point), the paramedics likely had the anecdote for propofol, and if murray had nothing to hide he would have told them *immediately*.

i have read that other doctors are skeptical of murray's claim that mj asked for propofol after those sedatives. one, they say even if he wasn't completely asleep, mj would have been very groggy. what doctor would take seriously the rantings of a heavily sedated man? and two, it was 10:40am according to the doctor when he administered this last bit of propofol. mj was due at rehearsal in a few hours. why go back to sleep at that time? i just don't have any reason to believe this happened the way murray claims.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #81 posted 09/04/09 7:29pm

kibbles

dearmother said:

kibbles said:

even if the stand at o2 had been successful, mj would have only been hated more as a 'freak' for a number of unconfortable reasons that i won't elaborate on here.


you really think so?


yes. as rupert everett said, mj was a freak. he was a freak b/c he didn't ever comform to the limited expectations that exist in this country for certain people. even if he'd given a good concert, it would have been downplayed and ignored in the press, just like his other success tours had been, his fans called lunatics, blinded by his celebrity, blah, blah, blah.

he was painfully insecure and he allowed the hate to seep in from all corners of his 'rhinosceros skin'. it was just all consuming. all my life i've heard hateful, hateful comments about mj - have been hearing them since the 70s - and in retrospect, i'm surprised mj accomplished as much as he did with the forces against him.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #82 posted 09/04/09 7:33pm

Timmy84

kibbles said:

dearmother said:



you really think so?


yes. as rupert everett said, mj was a freak. he was a freak b/c he didn't ever comform to the limited expectations that exist in this country for certain people. even if he'd given a good concert, it would have been downplayed and ignored in the press, just like his other success tours had been, his fans called lunatics, blinded by his celebrity, blah, blah, blah.

he was painfully insecure and he allowed the hate to seep in from all corners of his 'rhinosceros skin'. it was just all consuming. all my life i've heard hateful, hateful comments about mj - have been hearing them since the 70s - and in retrospect, i'm surprised mj accomplished as much as he did with the forces against him.


I think it was all too much for Mike at the end.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #83 posted 09/04/09 8:18pm

shorttrini

avatar

kibbles said:

shorttrini said:



Here is what I think. If it was Dr. Murray, it was going to be someone else. Michael had been taking drugs for years, so for the authorities to only focus on him is a little weird. I never thought that MJ would live to a ripe old age. One of the reasons why celebs do what they do, is because people are afraid to tell them NO! When you work for a celeb, it seems like your integrity goes right out of the window.
[Edited 9/4/09 18:19pm]


i never understand the so-called logic behind this statement, and i see people making it all the time. well, duh. yeah, if it wasn't murray, it would have been someone else. and your point? if it was someone else, we'd be talking about how that person is looking at manslaughter charges.

as i and many other people have pointed out, it doesn't matter what other drugs were in mj's system, assuming there were. did you not see the coroner's report? it stated mj died from propofol overdose with the sedatives that murray gave him as underlying factors in his death. DRUGS MURRAY GAVE HIM. whether mj had aspirin or oxycontin or heroin in his system, that's not the point. he died from what murray gave him.

honestly, people, come on!


If you asked me, Michael died as a result of YEARS of drug abuse. Remember, he had been taking drugs for all types of ailments, for many years. For people to just single out Murray, is in a way, more of a miscarriage of justice than anything else. I don't believe for a second that MJ just started taking Proporfol, when he met Dr. Murray. I think he started taking it way before he ever met him. Michael was very familiar with the drug and it's affects, due to the amount of surgeries he has undergone. My point is that every doctor that attended to Michael, should be held accountable for the man's death.
"Love is like peeing in your pants, everyone sees it but only you feel its warmth"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #84 posted 09/04/09 9:29pm

mimi07

avatar

shorttrini said:

kibbles said:



i never understand the so-called logic behind this statement, and i see people making it all the time. well, duh. yeah, if it wasn't murray, it would have been someone else. and your point? if it was someone else, we'd be talking about how that person is looking at manslaughter charges.

as i and many other people have pointed out, it doesn't matter what other drugs were in mj's system, assuming there were. did you not see the coroner's report? it stated mj died from propofol overdose with the sedatives that murray gave him as underlying factors in his death. DRUGS MURRAY GAVE HIM. whether mj had aspirin or oxycontin or heroin in his system, that's not the point. he died from what murray gave him.

honestly, people, come on!


If you asked me, Michael died as a result of YEARS of drug abuse. Remember, he had been taking drugs for all types of ailments, for many years. For people to just single out Murray, is in a way, more of a miscarriage of justice than anything else. I don't believe for a second that MJ just started taking Proporfol, when he met Dr. Murray. I think he started taking it way before he ever met him. Michael was very familiar with the drug and it's affects, due to the amount of surgeries he has undergone. My point is that every doctor that attended to Michael, should be held accountable for the man's death.


yes but the man that actually killed him should get most of the blame, don't u think. no one is excusing the other doctors but michael passed because of direct actions from murray
"we make our heroes in America only to destroy them"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #85 posted 09/04/09 9:39pm

kibbles

shorttrini said:

kibbles said:



i never understand the so-called logic behind this statement, and i see people making it all the time. well, duh. yeah, if it wasn't murray, it would have been someone else. and your point? if it was someone else, we'd be talking about how that person is looking at manslaughter charges.

as i and many other people have pointed out, it doesn't matter what other drugs were in mj's system, assuming there were. did you not see the coroner's report? it stated mj died from propofol overdose with the sedatives that murray gave him as underlying factors in his death. DRUGS MURRAY GAVE HIM. whether mj had aspirin or oxycontin or heroin in his system, that's not the point. he died from what murray gave him.

honestly, people, come on!


If you asked me, Michael died as a result of YEARS of drug abuse. Remember, he had been taking drugs for all types of ailments, for many years. For people to just single out Murray, is in a way, more of a miscarriage of justice than anything else. I don't believe for a second that MJ just started taking Proporfol, when he met Dr. Murray. I think he started taking it way before he ever met him. Michael was very familiar with the drug and it's affects, due to the amount of surgeries he has undergone. My point is that every doctor that attended to Michael, should be held accountable for the man's death.


but we don't need to ask you or speculate. the coroner performed the autopsy and released the findings on what killed mj. the preliminary report does not state he died of long term drug abuse or propofol abuse. it says he died of an overdose of propofol and sedatives administered by injection.

we're singling out murray b/c he's the one who injected him with the drugs that killed him. no, not every doctor should be held accountable for mj's death. they should be held accountable for dispensing drugs improperly or under an assumed name. no one has said that mj was unfamiliar with the dangers. but so, too, was murray, and ostensibly told mj he knew what he was doing and then injected too many drugs into mj's system causing his death.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #86 posted 09/04/09 10:25pm

prodigalfan

avatar

kibbles said:



exactly. assuming mj had a chance (and that's a really big assumption at this point), the paramedics likely had the anecdote for propofol, and if murray had nothing to hide he would have told them *immediately*.

i have read that other doctors are skeptical of murray's claim that mj asked for propofol after those sedatives. one, they say even if he wasn't completely asleep, mj would have been very groggy. what doctor would take seriously the rantings of a heavily sedated man? and two, it was 10:40am according to the doctor when he administered this last bit of propofol. mj was due at rehearsal in a few hours. why go back to sleep at that time? i just don't have any reason to believe this happened the way murray claims.[



AND THERE IT IS! I don't believe it either. MJ got propofol drip the night before and Murray fell asleep sometime during the night. When he woke up, the patient was dead. The end. All this other stuff makes it sound like it was just a few minutes lapse. I will bet MJ took his last breath hours before he was found at 830 or so. I say 830 or so because it appears Dr. Murray spent more than an hour of trying to fix things before he alerted people that MJ was gone.
[Edited 9/4/09 22:29pm]
[Edited 9/4/09 22:30pm]
"Remember, one man's filler is another man's killer" -- Haystack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #87 posted 09/04/09 11:41pm

medion

You didn’t read my post correctly. Michael’s doctors didn’t care about their ethics and the law. They were more interested in keeping Michael happy by prescribing most of the drugs that he never needed in the first place (a pill for loneliness?). He was their employer and the decision maker and they agreed with his poor decisions without questioning him as long they were getting paid.

Example: a man gets lung cancer or liver cancer from too much smoking or drinking and he has himself to blame and no-one else for his choices. Same thing applies to Michael for taking prescribed pills.

Besides all that, a serious investigation has to be carried out, check out the previous doctors he had and also question AEG as they may have something behind this. I will post the questions next time on this thread when my mind is clear as I am tired and going to bed.

Superstition said:

medion said:

The Jackson family and his fans are looking for an excuse to make Michael look innocent and you are aware that Michael has been taking prescription pills for 25+ years. Over the years, his doctors were happy being on the MJ payroll. The final verdict to this case: Michael Jackson killed Michael Jackson.


Wrong. Jackson was fully responsible for his actions, but so were any doctors who got the glimmer of green in their eye and turned their back on their ethics and abiding by the law.

Yeah, Jackson was probably shopping around for drugs. Why should that excuse the person who caves in and gives them to him?

I mean, this isn't a simple case of someone giving him a prescription, we're talking about a guy injecting him with all kinds of shit and basically doing an illegal job.
[Edited 9/4/09 11:59am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #88 posted 09/05/09 12:04am

TheDJONNI1993

I cannot understand, why the press tries to show MJ the addict? The person who at all did not use tobacco, the person meaningly refusing from anaesthetising (not to get to dependence) and proud of they be recollect sufferings Michael when it was bitten by a spider … the Person which in the books accurately showed the negative relation to drugs and sponsoring some actions against spread of drug addiction – the ADDICT? It as: a bee against honey?

Michael Jacson always seemed me extravagant, but the clever person.

The adult, mature, taken place, carried away by the creativity, the person possessing the reputation to enter into a drug dependence it is possible only either force, or a deceit. Besides, propofol and demerol – preparations not for a dream, and for a narcosis. The narcosis does not replace a dream! The narcosis does not give rest!

Now about become well-known the doctor Murrey. It in general live somebody saw? Or it is the phantom? With the thought up biography, clinic, relatives …. About which, besides, that they are it is not known more. At me sensation that something here not so …
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #89 posted 09/05/09 2:41am

jiorjios

avatar

Just my thoughts:
Although I haven't followed it at all, I think this case is bigger than being just about the doctor. If the doctor would be convicted alone, that would mean he is an escapegoat. Since there are pharmacies and possibly other doctors involved a case should be made about corruption and malpractise in the medical/paramedical field involved in general.
Was Michael Jackson guilty too? That's an interesting question. Michael Jackson was not a doctor or anything so he would follow his doctor's advices. Having said that, as someone who was obviously suffering from a chronic condition or disease he should have definitely researched for information concering his condition and the meds given to him. Any such search would easily show that propofol is dangerous and not to be given at home. Also it seems obvious that MJ was addicted to painkillers. Addiction to certain painkillers (especially agents which have antidepressant properties as well) is a real disease by itself. A lot of people are taking strong painkillers to overcome types of strong pains and then end up with even stronger pains and generally non-functional just because of the addiction to the analgesic agent. It certainly seems that that was MJ's case too. Does he have a responsibility at that scenario? He certainly does although that does not minimize at all the trained doctor's failure to properly treat his patient.
The pharmaceutical industry is corrupt even when it is working within the limits of the law, nevermind when it is working outside those limits as in MJ's case. It is the industry which develops new meds, does the clinical research on them, educates the doctors about them and then keeps doctors on its payrol with a minimum and extremely slow oversight from the FDA (which itself is depended on the pharmaceutical industry for some of its budget). As a result sometimes not even well-intentioned doctors have the whole picture of a med's side-effects profile. There are more people dying in the USA every year from medicines' side effects than from any other disease and condition except the heart attacks.
Despite that the pharmaceutical industry has managed to create a culture which says that whole classes of medicines are generally safe and should be taken to fight symptoms which in many cases have either not been properly investigated or they don't require treatment at all. The painkillers and their relatives (psychotropics, antidepressants, NSAIDs, corticosteroids etc) are the most important class of meds to fall in this category, newer classes of antibiotics is yet another one (follow link on my signature).
So this case instead of being used just to convict someone for a celebrity's passing should examine the responsibility of everybody involved including MJ himself because that would say a lot about the western culture and attitude towards medicine and the practices of certain members of the medical and paramedical field.
[Edited 9/5/09 2:44am]
[Edited 9/5/09 2:46am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 3 of 5 <12345>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Music: Non-Prince > Michael Jackson's doctor