There both considered comeback albums, and commercial failers. Which one do you think is best, and do they still hold up today?

I'd have to vote for Invincible, because a lot of the tracks on Rave are pure filler,not good material. Many of the cuts on Invincible can hold up as singles in today's market.

"Invincible". Not that they are worth comparing. Prince allegedly wrote most of "Rave" in a week or so. It showed

"Rave" is a horrible album. Not surprising the title track is actually quite good as its old as hell. But why make a then dated song from the late 80's your title track? I do love "wherever you go" though, a gem to me if there ever was one.