Back to Mariah Carey...
Yes she was pretty horrible especially when compared with Trey Lorenz who was great. She wasn't looking very good either. Shame as I dare to say that her 1992 version was one of the very few instances where a cover sounds better than the original. I am not surprised though.
Btw why was she looking so shocked? Did she got to know Michael Jackson?

she was Horrible. Maybe i would believe it was her being emotional and nervous, but she has been sounding like that for the past few years. So this isn't a good enough excuse. She drinks, parties, and stays up all night. Its her fault her voice is deteriorating.

She should really apologize for that dress.

jiorjios said:

Trey was much better then her, that is embarrassing. I never thought her version was better then Michaels. Even if she didn't get to reherse at the staples center, she has been singing that song for over 10 years, no excuse.

The point is she paid her respect which is enough for me.

I honestly can't blame her,,,,,I'm emotionally shook and I didn't even watch the memorial, I can't imagine what she & the rest of those people felt on stage

ok ,enough!no one will ever no the truth, on that issue,i think this thread shold be locked!!!!!we will NEVER no the truth!lock this thread!!!!! :lockdance:before it gets ugly!!!!!let mj rest!

I thought she was going to apologize for being built like a linebacker on top.

rialb said:

ignore
[Edited 7/9/09 12:52pm]

TotalAlisa said:

Haha I wasn't trying to find an excuse for her. She has been crap ever since 1994 (singles wise I don't own any of her albums) with the exception of the Emancipation singles and the odd single here and there. I never got all the fascination with her music. I just felt bad seeing her sing it so bad because her version of I'll Be There brings back a lot of memories from 1992 and it is one of the very few Mariah songs (if I can call it that) that I absolutely love. By the way did anyone else notice that in the original 1992 performance from Unplugged, Trey Lorenz who is singing basically half the song is seated behind with the rest of the backing vocals people? That was pretty inexcusable

Thanks to MidnightMover for
And this thread should be

leave mariah alone 2!!!she did great!

Timmy84 said:

umm no it actually shouldn't. just because a troll got on here and got off the topic and ya'll FED into it, doesn't meant that my thread should be locked for that. Let's just get back on topic and continue the discussion.

i agree with purple

Look how amazing her performance was in 1992



She suffered a lot of vocal damage as the years went on.

[snipped. - anx]

Lets just ignore the troll please. Can we get back on topic?

suga10 said:

You have a valid point there.

missfee said:

lets ban midnightmover

PurpleMedley122 said:

missfee said:

True, lol. Just in case the other conversation continues tho.

of course she didnt sound as good,she was overwelmed with grief!lets see if u people could have done a better job!!!!!

U CAN SEE HOW CLEARLY UPSET SHE WAS!!!!!her voice was shaking!!!!!

suga10 said:

Am I crazy or were her boobs a lot smaller then? I think she may have had some work done.

what the hell you all people want the thread to be locked , OK, Mariah talking about MJ, But still, its a mariah carey Thread, that should not be lokced, or you want it colsed because the same obsessed troll tried to ruin the thread, GOd....keept it postitve..


I don't think she was horrible at all, the fact that she accepted to sing at the memorial means alot to me, she stood there on the stage and sang in front of him , thats not an easy thing to do ,and thats mean alot to me
[Edited 7/9/09 13:17pm]

seeingvoices12 said:

yeah. I love mariah but she needs to give those vocals a rest tho for awhile.