I love it

P.S. No smart mouf, Ms.Andrea

Have to say I'm impressed. Of course people still are trying to hold on to 1985-1992 Whitney but I don't mind this at all. Least she's surviving. Good pop ballad. Glad she's back.

Thanks, Harle.

Timmy84 said:

I love the fact that she didn't exceed her vocal limits, she's working within her "recent" vocal range and she gave emotional depth to the song, which made it a winner in my book.

I don't even care that it sounds like it was written by wack ass Diane Warren,,,,but make no mistake, I'd settle with Nippy singing for Diane instead of QueeNY-Yo

Timmy84 said:

Me digs this

nice song but she sounds really really tired that my own throat hurts just listening to her

but didn't she already try that theme/formula with that On My Own song and it didn't work?

Harlepolis said:

PricelessHo said:

Whitney have been singing the same "proud" theme since Greatest Love Of All.

I'm not bothered by it all. And I love the "edge" in her voice, its a quality that clearly wasn't in her music previous to "My Love Is Your Love", only now its more pronounced.

I love raspy/husky voices

Harlepolis said:

Yeah Whitney knows due to her past that there's ranges she can't reach anymore. I love the raspier Whitney too.

well not jumping up and down over this song but I hope her comeback is successful

I kinda like it. i was a bit worried about what it'd be like. But i like it and am lookin forward to the album.
August 1st.

She lost her voice.

moussemaker said:

You're 10 years late

i like it but it sounds like a Fantasia outtake.

i like the raspyness of her voice too aisha. i just find the song to be too big for her current vocal shape, which clearly shows as it starts building up for the climax.

they could've at least given her an AC ballad that enhances the beauty of what she's got left of her range, rather than pointing out what she's lost from it

Harlepolis said:

Exactly!

I like the song, don't love it. Can't wait for her album to come out.

Harlepolis said:

That's the voice and song of a survivor! She sent herself to hell but she brought herself back to be able to sing about it when others were planning her memorial! I ain't mad at her at all, as long as she stays clean and focused!

HatrinaHaterwitz said:

Least this song has more value than "Try It On My Own" did, that's when she didn't know HOW to do it on her own but now it's a new day. Go Whitney!

Timmy84 said:

Try It On My Own,,,,with Bobby Brown emerging from the shadows in an imitation of a REAL LIFE pimp riiiiight.

Harlepolis said:

Lord that video was creepy wasn't it?

Not bad. But all that crack really f--ked up her voice!

not bad
[Edited 7/2/09 16:35pm]

Harlepolis said:

Or Swizz Beatz

She has an audience if she stays in her lane

I kinda dig the way her voice has, uhh, "aged." That she doesn't sound like she used to doesn't bother me. The song, on the other hand, is just Typical Whitney, survivor stuff. She better have a good "Kiss my asssss!" song on there somewhere.

RipHer2Shreds said:

Like "Whatchulookinat"?

Timmy84 said:

RipHer2Shreds said:

RipHer2Shreds said:

Well Tim, you ruined the fantasy, thanx alot

And no, the ONLY good "kiss my ass" song she did was "In My Business" with Missy,,,,,but other than that, mm mm ESP not "My Name Is Not Susan"

Harlepolis said:

Yeah I like "In My Business". Funny I remember I used to sing "My Name is Not Susan" just to get on my sister's nerves. She was always singing it using another girl's name!