rank in the following categories:

1. video performances
2. concert performances
3. songwriting ability
4. movie performances
5. mass appeal
6. award show performances
[Edited 1/2/08 5:16am]

1. video performances

90's janet

2. concert performances

'80's madonna

3. songwriting ability

90's janet

4. movie performances

90's janet

5. mass appeal

'80's madonna

6. award show performances

'80's madonna

Beyoncé is spoiled brat when compared to with the Donna and Jahnit!
[Edited 1/2/08 5:43am]

1. video performances
Janet
2. concert performances
Janet
3. songwriting ability
All of them use professional songwriters...
4. movie performances

5. mass appeal
Madonna (there were Madonna wannabes everywhere in the 80's)
6. award show performances
Beyonce

JoeTyler said:

Please...Beyoncé even ripped the Kyborg suit from Kylie in one of the latest show performances.

MikeMatronik said:

Yeah, but I've chosen her because of that amazing Brits performance with Prince...

JoeTyler said:

Coof...Grammies...coof....



But hey, B is a hardworking woman

MikeMatronik said:

oh, that's true , my bad
[Edited 1/2/08 5:57am]

Beyonce is the only one who has a legitimate career...

Madonna and Janet are pure products of MTV and music videos

I think Beyonce, Madonna and Janet should not been put in the same category...

Beyonce should be replaced by Britney Spears


That thread should be 80's madonna VS 90's janet VS 00's Britney
[Edited 1/2/08 6:19am]

krayzie said:

You're contradictory as hell, dude

JoeTyler said:

he's krayzie!























Sorry...it was a cheap joke, but I couldn't resist

1. video performances

They all suck, but "IF" was magic and yummy
I'm about to cue that up right now.

2. concert performances

backing tracks and yodeling, they all suck

3. songwriting ability

Stop playing

4. movie performances

Janet wins strictly because she actually said,"Do you wanna..."
She gets freak points.

5. mass appeal

They're all plastic and vanilla so

6. award show performances

Let's see, air traffic control poplocking or rolling around on the floor and popping various oiled up body parts, they all suck

why are we talking about beyonce?

90ss Madonna is best...

next would be 80s Janet...

then 90s Janet...

then 80s Madonna...

then 00s Janet...




...00s Madonna

Beyonce dont figga

krayzie said:

Are you paid to walk her dog and wax her bikini line, too?

krayzie said:

I have to admit, while I'm not a Bigonce fan, I've actually listened to some of her crap and there are these hints of something decent, but of course they get washed away or smothered by donkey balls like Swizz Beats and her pimp, I mean father.

Fury said:[quote]rank in the following categories:

1. video performances-80's madonna
2. concert performances-90's janet and 00's beyonce
3. songwriting ability-80's madonna and 90's janet
4. movie performances-90's janet and 00's beyonce
5. mass appeal-80's madonna
6. award show performances-90's janet and 00's beyonce
[Edited 1/2/08 17:06pm]

Dance said:

never been a fan of hers either.

those 3 and mariah carey are my favourite female artists

And Beyonce is a product of shit hop and there is nothing lower on the face of this earth than shit hop.

Fury said:

1. Madonna
2. Madonna
3. Madonna
4. LMAO!!!!
5. Madonna
6. Madonna



Of all of them Beyonce is the only talented singer. But the questions were skewed towards Madonna.

Yeah, but look at what she sings. Judy Garland is a talented singer also but I wouldn't be caught dead listening to her music.

vainandy said:

She's a victim of hip hop and her loser parents.

They didn't allow the child to enjoy music in a normal way or actually learn to read, write, and speak english.

That sick pedo dad of hers had her jogging in stripper shoes and paid some wack chick to teach the girl to yodel on command.

vainandy said:

For Vainandy, everything he dislikes is shit hop

Beyonce is shit hop, Whitney Houston is shit hop, even Barbara Streisand is shit hop

Anyway Beyonce would have had a career in music with or without hip hop, with or without MTV, with or without music videos...

Because everybody knows that when it comes to performing, singing live on stage, she's the real deal...

She's one of the few people from the mess called "music industry" that can still put a 2 hour show and sing perfectly LIVE which used the norm until the 70's...The 80's is the beginning of the end for real artsists...

I don't think we can say the same for Madonna and Janet


I don't think Janet and Madonna would have a career in the music industry without the emergence of MTV and music videos that pretty much help lipsyncers and other talentless hoes to sell records and be famous...


Madonna and Janet are the worst things that ever happened to Music ...

This is the reason why Beyonce should be not compared with Janet and Madonna...

vainandy said:

I think Beyonce has talent.Unfortunately,she wastes it on lackluster shit hop material.Like Mariah Carey,she's only interested in singing predictable,shit hop garbage.

krayzie said:

I totally agree. Janet & Madonna are different kinda artists than Beyonce. Neither Janet or Madonna could come near the talent of Beyonce when it comes to singing. At the end of the day thats what talent is about. Bones get old & it isn't cool to see some 50 year old woman trying to look young & be some kinda Pop star. For that Reason I believe Beyonce will have a much better Career than both of them...She will always be able to sing..

But to answer ur question...


1. video performances

90's janet

2. concert performances

Beyonce

3. songwriting ability

Beyonce....neither Janet or Madonna really write..

4. movie performances

90's janet

5. mass appeal

'80's madonna

6. award show performances

'80's madonna
[Edited 1/3/08 10:10am]

Bishop31 said:

Madge writes most of her lyrics.

B doesn't write much at all just gets her name put in the credits. talk to Ne-yo

1. video performances
Madonna

2. concert performances

Janet

3. songwriting ability
Come on! Lets be serious now, none of them are good songwriters.

4. movie performances
Janet

5. mass appeal
Madonna

6. award show performances
Beyonce
[Edited 1/3/08 10:43am]

ehuffnsd said:

No, Bigonce writes a lot of her bullshit. Even NeYo's wack ass wouldn't sit down and write that "dangerously crazy in love got my body like oh thugs yeah baby girl right now boy oh ass ass titties titties ass" bs. Hell, even Mariah can do better.

krayzie said:

If that's the case, why does she use backing tracks during shows?

Tina(who they used as the mold for her even though Bigonce doesn't measure up)would jump around, scream, and yell forever on stage.

I agree she can hold a note, but unless she is somehow able to break out of what she's doing, she'll always be just as wack as J and Vadge, I mean Madge.

Dance said:[quote]

ehuffnsd said:

OMG, LMOA!!!!

I almost choked on my pizza.