Who do you like

neoretro7 said:

Alicia's music is better. Joss' voice is better. Simple and plain as that.

didn't get into Joss
until Saadiq showed up

Alicia, I liked from the gate
The Diary Of...
is simply amazing

Alicia - no question.

I'm not sure I get the comparison, but Alicia...

After "As I Am"... Joss

theodore said:

wow Theo...

I love this new effort
"Sure Looks Good To Me"
is my everything

and "Teenage Love Affair"

DirtyChris said:

I always liked them both
I love Joss ever since I heard the first CD

I liked some songs on the new Alicia album but just that. Nothing exciting to me

What is it with you and these Joss Stone vs threads?

ALICIA, BABY!!

theodore said:

Reminds you of Back To Basics, eh?

theodore said:

The Diary Of...
is a much better album
but As I Am is better
than the debut

the debut was plain boring to me
with the exception of "Girlfriend"
"How Come...", and the
"Never Felt This Way (Interlude)"

DirtyChris said:

I think it's


Songs in A Minor
The Diary Alicia Keys
then
As I Am

FarrahMoan said:

Back to Basics had a lot of filler shit on it
But I could make one great album out of the 22 tracks

This one is just

Alicia's debut was her best album.

dragondayz said:

Totally agree

theodore said:

Stripped was probably the best album by that hot woman. I never realized how attracted I was to that woman. She's something else. Her conflicts with my favorite rapper were amongst my fondest of memories.

CalhounSq said:

Same.

What's with all these "vs." thread...half of them don't even make sense.

"Rock Wit U"
from the debut
was hot too
I got picks & chooses
from that one

but with The Diary Of..
I liked em all

that's why it has that
special place in my heart
then that period of my life
just coincides with
"Nobody Not Really"
[Edited 12/19/07 14:13pm]

FarrahMoan said:

I love Stripped

But I'd much rather listen to Back To Basics, I guess because it's happier

DirtyChris said:

I lurve the whole Songs in A Minor album.
On The Diary... I felt like there was something missing.
MTV Unplugged just left me all
And As I Am left me all I guess because of the fucked up vocals

I do not like Joss Stone at all. She is an actress to me. I am no Alicia fan but between the two, I pick Alicia.

Probably Alicia, but pretty different people for the most part though drawing from a simliar past. Actually i would say it was Joss until this record, for me, pushed Alicia head with me, I wasnt into Alicia's debut, maybe it was the HYPE the label created but i still rarely listen to it, with the second i was into her, then unplugged, and with this new one shes become much stronger to me, Joss has done the same though i still feel Mind Body and Soul was a better album, i still really like the new one and the first one too but that had some covers and was just an ep. Vocally probably Joss but still different, i actually like alot of Alicia's vocals on this new record especially "Sure looks good too me" i mean at least it sounds like she is singing it and ripping it out of herself, too many singers layer stuff so "fine" and "perfect" that soul is non existent.

Without even thinking. Alicia! I dig Joss too though.

Alicia keys easily!

She may be "safe" and a bit ho-hum sometimes, but I like her and besides Joss Stone makes me wanna throw poop at my radio!

anybody like "Wreckless Love"
from As I Am?

that song is my everything right now
I played it like 5 times this morning
getting ready for work

neoretro7 said:

AMY whinehouse

neoretro7 said:

RipHer2Shreds said:

I was wondering if this was the same person who did the Leela James/Joss thread

DirtyChris said:

That was a complete Isaac Hayes sample