These women are both dancers but who do you think has better versatility.

synapscape.

I've seen both perform live. Mya is a better dancer, but beyonce overall is the better performer

Mya is a better dancer.

Beyonce can't dance really. She's a great mover, but Beyonce doesn't move her feet like Mya and Janet. I'm noticing that Ciara barely moves her feet, so I wouldn't consider them real/trained dancers.

Like someone else said. Beyonce is a great performer.

mya

mya is a better nothing

PricelessHo said:

Mya is a better everything compared to Beyonce.

It's really no comparison.

Beyoncé's style of dancing is more rhythmic and organic. It's not like what you see ppl like Britney, Mya, etc...the more choreographed intricate stylized moves. Beyoncé has never done their type of choreography and she's not that kind of performer. Just like Tina Turner dancing could not be compared to a Janet Jackson or Paula Abdul routine.

Mya is way better mainly because she is a trained dancer, and now teaches at her own dance school that she built. And lets not forget she trained with Savion Glover.

Scorpion said:

whewwwww lawd...that's funny


that chyle is just shakin' her ass.

I recall DC-era quotes about Beyonce not being able to dance at all and needing lots of time to learn moves. As a solo singer she came to be more rhythmic of course. Maybe someone has the info to paste in.

Mya is a graceful little ballerina of a dancer. No contest.

Rhondab said:

For real!

"Rhythmic and organic"...puh-leeze!!!

Mya could literally dance circles around that girl!

Please...this is no contest - Mya.

Rhondab said:

Exactly. That :::shake, shake, pop booty, shake shake, pop booty::: shit that Beyonce does is not dancing.

Mya. She also has better thighs/bootay and gives better lap dances.

Mya!!!

Ifsixwuz9 said:

I love you.

Beyonce doesn't really do alot of specific dance moves. she more or less shakes and skates across stage which is fine, but not like real getting down dancing

Rhondab said:

Well that's what it is. It's natural movement.

Not that intricate or robotic 8-count dancing that requires hours of time and rehearsal.
[Edited 10/24/07 13:03pm]

Scorpion said:

her second cd isn't all that shaking stuff. but I would see her over mya and I like her stuff too. I just think that b is more of a fun entertainer.

Real dancing?
Mya

Scorpion said:

Crazy in love....Ring the Alarm.....that chyle does do choreographed messes....

Rhondab said:

Now why you wanna go and ruin Scorpion's fantasy with the truth!

Hell if I know, but Mya was in the Cellblock Tango number of Chicago - she's probably more of a graceful/trained dancer Beyount can do some shit w/ heels though, but doesn't she just run around & shake? I dunno, don't watch either of them enough to say so I should just

Mya.....

technically it goes to MYA

but freestyle it's Beyoncé hands down.

I cannot remember how well Mya dances. I haven't seen anything new from her lately. I can however remember the ass. It's always about the ass. So my vote goes to Mya.

I know these are just opinions, but...are y'all serious? MYA! She's a trained dancer. Not that that automatically qualifies one as a better dancer but her training shows in her dancing and Beyonce's lack of training really shows. She can move, no doubt, but she's not on par with Mya at all. I'd like to see Beyonce even attempt to do what Mya did in Chicago.

Rhondab said:

I don't know what amused me more - your response or the statement that prompted it.

CalhounSq said:

Actually MYA has done alot of dancing in high heels, check for her MadTv performance where she did a wild dance of "wahtever bitch" i have no idea how she didnt snap her ankles, and also her performance on the "disco ball" a few years back to was in very high heels. Yeah Beyonce doesnt really have constructed dance routines that she does there is alot of running and sliding and falling going on.