Can't stand her.

too bad...

She's really good.
I love her

i am not interested in her either. tryin too hard to be rebellious

popular music is shit

She's a really talented vocalist. I love this little video of Beyonce, Alicia Keys, and Pink that showcases all of their vocal talent. Pink comes out on top in my opinion. I think her rebellious music takes away from her vocal talent.

http://www.youtube.com/wa...ZkLiFzLJQw

horatio said:

the smartest thing i've ever heard in this forum..

I don't like her either



Can'tspelltodayedit!
[Edited 9/18/07 11:35am]

jess555ja said:

what is it with you and the word "here" today?

BlaqueKnight said:

she was playing on the radio when i started this. I dunno blaqueknight, I think she's really contrived. A supposed rebel, but with bland, radio friendly music with predictable chord changes. Like Avril Lavigne.

LittleSmedley said:

Shit. I was saying her

LittleSmedley said:

I don't think she's contrived. I remember when she first started she made a comment on Mtv about how she would rather go back to working at McDonalds than to be forced to be like Britney and the others. The problem is that she didn't really understand how the entertainment business works and that if she is gonna be heard at all, she's going to have to pick an image. I think she's fallen into her image box now and is sorta stuck there. She's talented but the lesson is that you can't go to the pop crowd complaining about...the pop crowd!

LittleSmedley said:

I'm afraid you're right. No matter how much she flatters herself about being different and rebellious, the fact is her music is really formulaic. Her songwriting is bad too. It's just the sound of a four year old screaming for attention. Annoying.

I love her!

.
[Edited 9/18/07 12:56pm]

tritoncin said:

me too!!

Her music is wack, but I'd do her

I like her, but I wish she could do a RnB album next just to see how it go's.
Since the first one was good

LOVE LOVE LOVE her!

Better her than Britney, I say.

I love her rebellious attitude.

Better her than Britney, I always say.

I love her rebellious attitude.

"Her music is wack, but I'd do her "


holy shit, you are brave,

she's the worst looking tranny in music

PricelessHo said:

Exactly!!


I've always said that...

But I personally don't have anything against her tho'

Aww well that's too bad. I think you're missing out. I love Pink, I think she's great and she's not full of ish like so many of these celebrties. "Like A Pill" is also one of my fave songs ever. Pink rocks!

paper said:

Finally, someone else who likes her first album! I personally thought 'Most girls' was one of the few good songs of 2000. Admittedly she had hardly any creative control over that album but everything she has done since SUCKS in my opinion.

I get told by all my friends 'well her singles are crap, but her album tracks are good' - SORRY, but I've tried to get into them and they are bland. As has been said, predictable chord changes and just BLAND BLAND BLAND!
I was only saying the other day, both 'Family Portrait' and 'Just Like a Pill' were saturated beyond belief on UK radio and they truly belong on my longstanding fictitious compilation '20 wrist-slashing greats.'

I think her songwriting is very overrated - again as has already been said, like Avril Lavigne. I don't think her voice is anything to write home about either.

She is a cracking looking girl though, I'll give her that!

danpartyman86 said:

I never thought so, but I have to admit, she got a rise out of me in that "Stupid Girls" video on top of that car all wet & sh!t. Was that all Hollywood magic? I don't know.

I hate to ask... what DO you like? She is great and her latest cd is incredible. You are really really missing out.

CHIC0 said:

I can't really understand why she receives so much negative criticism...

I think she receives that because she speaks her mind politically...
I lover that in her too, She's brave.
[Edited 9/19/07 0:57am]

tritoncin said:

why did you edit all that?

she does get some mixed reactions. people like what they like.
but i'm with you. how can you not like P!NK???
a couple of my co-workers claim that they can't stand her. but one of them asked me to put on her "I'm Not Dead" album twice! LOL yeah that's what i thought.

i love the fact that she's opinionated and has a mind to go with it. she's a great songwriter and has an amazing voice. imo. i've yet to see her live but if she's ever in this area i'm definitely going to be there!


awaits Moonbeam's arrival on this thread

Her voice is great, but I've never bought an album by her. Her songs don't really appeal to me for some reason, but I love that she tries to do her own thing & has such a powerful voice.