minneapolisgenius said:

Lady Stardust.

Wait until you see my next selection.

sextonseven said:

minneapolisgenius said:

Actually, I just realized if "Star" gets voted off first then "Lady Stardust" will be my next selection. You may have to wait awhile to see what comes after that.

sextonseven said:

I'm still watching you. You could seriously screw things up here.

damosuzuki said:

Get the fuck out of here!

Not literally. But why?

minneapolisgenius said:

I'm just one vote. How much harm could I do?

sextonseven said:

I'm glad you're playing. The more the merrier.

Do you think you'll jump into the later stuff as we get to it? It'd be a perfect way to break in those albums.

GangstaFam said:

I don't think I'm ready yet. I may not even wnat to open those threads 'cos they might influence the way I hear the albums when I finally get around to buying them.

sextonseven said:

Get 'em now.

At least the soul period stuff from '74-'76 so you can extend your participation.

GangstaFam said:

Aren't there any more deluxe editions? I was spoiled by the Ziggy and Aladdin double discs.

sextonseven said:

Yeah, the one right after those 2 called "Diamond Dogs" has a double disc deluxe edition too.

And the one after that "Young Americans" should be out soon.

lady stardust.

too many songs with the word star somewhere in there.

Star ~ part of my reasoning is that it is a very short song so I am voting off less of the album. I just love the whole cd so much!

MoonSongs said:

Any reason is a legitimate one.

GangstaFam said:

I know it's lame but I'm really reaching here.

GangstaFam said:

To be perfectly honest, I was planning on voting for star until I saw there were a few votes registered in that direction, so I decided to try going against the current.

I had no idea that would be a controversial selection, though. I’ve always had that song pegged as a middling, second-tier track; dull melody, plodding tempo, and cloying vocal – I just don’t think it has much going for it.

I don't mean to be difficult, y'know...I just am.
[Edited 1/29/07 18:10pm]

GangstaFam said:

I may participate in the 'Diamond Dogs' survivor then.

damosuzuki said:

I realize there are better songs, but it might just be my favorite on the whole album.

GangstaFam said:

No need to box yourself - if the past is any indicator, my dislike for it probably means everyone else loves it to death.

star

minneapolisgenius said:

Phil Collins Fan!!

People who voted for "Soul Love" or "Lady Stardust" are crazy!!!

noepie said:

Cheek said:

and?

Cheek said:

I'm getting the impression that after "It Ain't Easy" people who vote for anything are crazy.

sextonseven said:

good point. The later rounds are going to be BRUTAL!!

sextonseven said:

That's true. The rest are all great songs.

Lady Stardust...it tends to be a bit boring.

dawntreader said:

And other times, she can charm your pants off!