I hope there are a few STP fans out there. So, what is their best disc? For me it's between Purple, Tiny Music... and No 4. Since Tiny Music... was the first disc of theirs I heard I gotta give it the edge for sentimental reasons.

And what about Talk Show vs. 12 Bar Blues? They're very different but which one do you think was better?

I liked "Core" the best. Purple was great too, but I stopped listening to them after Tiny Mushc and never heard No.4 even though friends said it was great. Core had a lot of great songs on it and the overall sound of the record was badass!

purple

Tiny Music

It just has the most variety of any STP album, and has their best songwriting (at least right up there with Core)

Purple

I like their debut. Can't fuck with Sex Type Thing, Plush, Creep, Secret Garden and Dead & Bloated.

STP is my favorite band of all-time! It's really hard for me to choose, but I think, for me it's a tie between Purple and No. 4.

GangstaFam said:

I remember when I first got the 'Core' album, I played "Plush" on my stereo with the volume turned up to 11 and did air guitar throughout the entire song. Hated them ever since.

Purple is one of the best disc of the 90's. That's a classic, 5 star album, don't sleep on it. CLASSIC.
[Edited 11/28/05 16:33pm]

sextonseven said:

Why? Embarrassed?

if you added "big empty" and "interstate love song" to Core, it would be a perfect album. Think I'll burn that for the car this weekend.

PURPLe and man O Man I LOVE them . VELVET REVOLVER is AWESOME..AWESOME.. SCOTT and Slash and Duff of it's just a GREAT BAND. Ya gotta see them live...EXCELLENT!

No. 4

GangstaFam said:

No, I just didn't think the later albums rocked as hard. Not from the singles I heard anyway. I liked them better when they were Pearl Jam clones.