I mean it just sounds too perfect...and i heard a rumour it was studio recorded and then the audience noises were just added in the mastering...her vocals are PERFECT...the instrumentation is PERFECT...the sound of the 'venue' has almost no reverb...does anyone know for sure either way?

badujunkie said:

i wouldn't say it was too perfect, I've heard her sound better. nerver heard the studio/audience recording rumor before

I have heard her live on that same tour, it's positively live!

The show was recorded on video as well. It is 100% live.

AntonioFargas said:

word? is that video circulating?

AntonioFargas said:

no way!! fo' real! do you have it??

i hate how the erykah fans are so unconnected, it's so hard to get anything of hers like dat...

Well Tyrone was a video too, right? She'd have to be one of the best lip sync-ers in the world to have gotten that w/ the little ad libs & shit. Me thinks it's live

Good album and good good artist. Um... I think it's live, Cuz I seen the Tyrone video and her voice was right on point.

the tyrone video could have been lipsynched with concert footage used...who knows, i dont think that's proof...i swear, go back and listen to how fake and on point all the clapping and audience interaction in it...and it seems recorded...everyone just try one mo' time

Audiences
have been
known to
applaud -
not trying
to be fun-
ny, simply
saying it
could still
be the real
deal, man.

badujunkie said:

CalhounSq said:

There's a video??? I. Love. That. Song.

Puhchoolee said:

YEAH BUT DIG THIS

AFTER RECORD SHOW

GO BACK IN STUDIO AND REDO BAD PART

EVERY PART ON DIFFERENT TRACK ON STAGE

IT EASY TO REDO BAD PART

EVER SINCE KISS ALIVE EVERYONE DO IT

onenitealone said:

I saw the video before I ever heard it on radio VH1 Soul still plays it



.
[Edited 8/17/05 1:30am]

Well, the Marilyn Manson and Nine Inch Nails ones certainly weren't.

CalhounSq said:

Cheers, Calhoun.