Author | Message |
Why are there so few female musical greats? well.... | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
There aren't? | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
VoicesCarry said: There aren't?
well think about it. Can you think of a female equivalent of Mozart, Duke Ellington, Stevie Wonder, Miles Davis, Prince etc..? I mean you might say Carole king, Joni Mitchell, Regina Carter, but anyone else I might think of would only be a great singer, not a great overall musician. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I think there are some extremely talented female artists out there, but I agree they do seem to come in much smaller numbers, and they are fewer and more far apart.
Female artists seem more inclined to play the sex-appeal pop star role than that of the artist. That, or they play the role of folk singer. This usually means strumming chords on an acoustic guitar and singing songs about flowers and seagulls. [Edited 11/6/04 22:48pm] "Knowledge is preferable to ignorance. Better by far to embrace the hard truth than a reassuring faith. If we crave some cosmic purpose, then let us find ourselves a worthy goal" - Carl Sagan | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Women in music are stronger than ever. Before Janis Joplin and Joni Mitchell really, they had very little control over the direction of their careers. That said, there have been many, many wonderful vocalists and MUSICIANS, especially in the last 30 some years.
Joni Mitchell - as good a songwriter as they come Nina Simone - breathtaking vocals and piano playing Tori Amos - kicks ultimate ass on her instrument; as accomplished as any male you'll see if not moreso Tina Weymouth - just listen to her bass and you'll understand PJ Harvey - killer guitars, killer voice, killer songs, killer live show Mary J. Blige - she may be seen as one of the greats someday Bjork - the way she looks at music is completely revolutionary; she has no precedent | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
There have always been female musical greats.
Perhaps, the public didn't get exposed to their genius due to gender oppression and social custom. You mention Mozart ... you know of course, that he had a sister who was also a musical prodigy. When she was young, people called her a "child wonder," but then she grew up enough to clean people's houses. You never hear about her, although like him she got to play before the Queen. And because history is really HISstory and chronicles the lives of men (white men mostly), and very few women .. aside from a few references to Mozart's sister, I've never heard what happened to her.I think she ended up teaching music. The lack of information on female composers from the classical period onward is pretty sad and disconcerting. That doesn't mean they lacked skills and didn't exist ... throughout the generations they've simply created in obscurity. And those who knew of their creations, didn't deem them significant enough to preserve for posterity. It's the same in literature. Poor Dorothy Wordsworth wrote in her little private journal ... While brother William Wordsworth got the praise for penning poetry that suspiciously mirrored the imagery, metaphors and themes in her journals. What an indictment against human society. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
I hate how popular female artists have to vamp up their image to sell a record.
Male artists are NEVER judged on their looks as harshly as females. That irks me. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Ani DiFranco. Great vocalist, lyricist, guitar player, producer, record label owner. How do you account for that? [Edited 11/7/04 0:37am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
i think there are more women than men in my CD collection. yes SIR! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Lisa Gerrard
Laura Nyro k.d. lang Meredith Monk Liz Phair Courtney Love Madonna Sade Billie Holiday Donna Summer | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Patrice Rushen
Chaka Khan Kim Deal Debbie Harry Patti Smith Annie Lennox Chrissie Hynde Sinead O'Conner Kate Bush Laurie Anderson | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
its called sexism. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
SynthiaRose said: There have always been female musical greats.
Perhaps, the public didn't get exposed to their genius due to gender oppression and social custom. You mention Mozart ... you know of course, that he had a sister who was also a musical prodigy. When she was young, people called her a "child wonder," but then she grew up enough to clean people's houses. You never hear about her, although like him she got to play before the Queen. And because history is really HISstory and chronicles the lives of men (white men mostly), and very few women .. aside from a few references to Mozart's sister, I've never heard what happened to her.I think she ended up teaching music. The lack of information on female composers from the classical period onward is pretty sad and disconcerting. That doesn't mean they lacked skills and didn't exist ... throughout the generations they've simply created in obscurity. And those who knew of their creations, didn't deem them significant enough to preserve for posterity. It's the same in literature. Poor Dorothy Wordsworth wrote in her little private journal ... While brother William Wordsworth got the praise for penning poetry that suspiciously mirrored the imagery, metaphors and themes in her journals. What an indictment against human society. Ain't it the muthafunkin truth. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
In college we had to write a paper on a composer. I asked my intructor if there were any female composers that I could research. All she could come up with was Clara Schumann. She was married to Robert Schumann.
http://www.geneva.edu/~dk...umann.html Clara Wieck Schumann The Premier Female Musician of the 19th Century Accomplished Composer and Virtuoso Pianist Clara Josephine Wieck Schumann (September 13 , 1819 - May 20, 1896), wife of composer Robert Schumann, trained from an early age by her father Friedrich Wieck, had a brilliant career as a pianist from the age of thirteen up to her marriage. In the various tours on which she accompanied her husband, she extended her own reputation farther than the outskirts of Germany, and it was thanks to her efforts that his compositions became generally known in Europe. From the time of her husband's death she devoted herself principally to the interpretation of her husband's works, but when in 1856 she first visited England the critics received Schumann's music with a chorus of disapprobation. She returned to London in 1865 and continued her visits annually, with the exception of four seasons, until 1882; and from 1885 to 1888 she appeared each year. In 1878 she was appointed teacher of the piano at the Hoch Conservatorium at Frankfurt am Main, a post which she held until 1892, and in which she contributed greatly to the modern improvement in technique. As an artist she will be remembered, together with Joseph Joachim, as one of the first executants who really played like composers. Besides being remembered for her eminence as a performer of nearly all kinds of pianoforte music, at a time when such technical ability was considerably rarer than in the present day, she was herself the composer of a few songs and of some charming music, mainly for the piano, and the authoritative editor of her husband's works for Breitkopf and Härtel. [Edited 11/7/04 9:12am] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
jacktheimprovident said: well....
y'know i've been wonderingthe same thing myself. i always here about the great female SINGERS and thats nice but i never hear about any great female MUSICIANS. i always hear about the dudes prince hendrix stevie wonder all those classical piano dudes miles davis etc etc but where are their female equivalents? Yesterday is dead...tomorrow hasnt arrived yet....i have just ONE day...
...And i'm gonna be groovy in it! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Rhondab said: its called sexism.
Thank you. Just like other industries are controlled by males, so is the music industry. And the leeway and freedom for men does NOT exist for females as a whole. I said, as a whole, knee jerk reactionaries stay away. The females throughout history in the music business have to work three times as hard to get where they want as the males do. And just as there are Black rock bands out there (you didn't know a ton of them exist?) who never get signed, or get signed and not given the same promotional backing as their White counterparts, there are female musicians and recording artists who never get signed, or are never given the equal opportunity once they get signed. Consequently, their careers are sometimes shorter. You're expected to stay in your traditional role as a female musician (not many drummers, brass players, bass players, electric guitarists, producers, and certainly not many female BANDS). Sing and look pretty. No creative control. If your ambition is outside of that status quo, good luck with that. It can happen, but 100 of your male counterparts will get signed before you will. Aside from being a GREAT recording artist, Ani DiFranco is exalted for a very good reason. She has everything she wants due to her work outside the status quo. She calls the shots, in the studio and on the road. She owns her work. She assembles her bands. She has creative control. Nobody but the taxman tells her what to do. This post not for the wimp contingent. All whiny wusses avert your eyes. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Rhondab said: its called sexism.
I couldn't be more succinct than that . | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
What about Janis Joplin
Fuck all of you | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
jayaredee said: What about Janis Joplin
Fuck all of you Err....we're all agreeing with you. Fuck you too! | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Wow, I just found an amazing website
The following is a list of famous female composers. http://encyclopedia.thefr...0composers | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
And how about Hildegard von Bingen? Anybody remember this?
Vision is kinda New Agey, but Canticles of Ecstacy is more traditional. You can listen to that here: http://music.msn.com/albu...m=29455635 Here is a nice bio: http://www.fordham.edu/ha...garde.html | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Supernova said: Rhondab said: its called sexism.
Thank you. Just like other industries are controlled by males, so is the music industry. And the leeway and freedom for men does NOT exist for females as a whole. I said, as a whole, knee jerk reactionaries stay away. The females throughout history in the music business have to work three times as hard to get where they want as the males do. And just as there are Black rock bands out there (you didn't know a ton of them exist?) who never get signed, or get signed and not given the same promotional backing as their White counterparts, there are female musicians and recording artists who never get signed, or are never given the equal opportunity once they get signed. Consequently, their careers are sometimes shorter. You're expected to stay in your traditional role as a female musician (not many drummers, brass players, bass players, electric guitarists, producers, and certainly not many female BANDS). Sing and look pretty. No creative control. If your ambition is outside of that status quo, good luck with that. It can happen, but 100 of your male counterparts will get signed before you will. Aside from being a GREAT recording artist, Ani DiFranco is exalted for a very good reason. She has everything she wants due to her work outside the status quo. She calls the shots, in the studio and on the road. She owns her work. She assembles her bands. She has creative control. Nobody but the taxman tells her what to do. Well said. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
whodknee said: Supernova said: Thank you. Just like other industries are controlled by males, so is the music industry. And the leeway and freedom for men does NOT exist for females as a whole. I said, as a whole, knee jerk reactionaries stay away. The females throughout history in the music business have to work three times as hard to get where they want as the males do. And just as there are Black rock bands out there (you didn't know a ton of them exist?) who never get signed, or get signed and not given the same promotional backing as their White counterparts, there are female musicians and recording artists who never get signed, or are never given the equal opportunity once they get signed. Consequently, their careers are sometimes shorter. You're expected to stay in your traditional role as a female musician (not many drummers, brass players, bass players, electric guitarists, producers, and certainly not many female BANDS). Sing and look pretty. No creative control. If your ambition is outside of that status quo, good luck with that. It can happen, but 100 of your male counterparts will get signed before you will. Aside from being a GREAT recording artist, Ani DiFranco is exalted for a very good reason. She has everything she wants due to her work outside the status quo. She calls the shots, in the studio and on the road. She owns her work. She assembles her bands. She has creative control. Nobody but the taxman tells her what to do. Well said. Indeed. Although I think there's more to it than that. I think women, throughout history, in addition to being repressed/oppressed, have been trained to be complicit with their oppression. I think women are taught to be docile, submissive, stupid and superficial and I think that's still very true despite the progress that's been made. Women aren't encouraged to be assertive or to develop their talents as much as men, they're more encouraged to be pretty and to get a good man, and even if you don't buy that you can't argue that women are judged more on their looks than their talent or merits. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Yes, that's part of what I had in mind when I talked about one's ambition being outside of the status quo. This post not for the wimp contingent. All whiny wusses avert your eyes. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Indeed. Although I think there's more to it than that. I think women, throughout history, in addition to being repressed/oppressed, have been trained to be complicit with their oppression. I think women are taught to be docile, submissive, stupid and superficial and I think that's still very true despite the progress that's been made. Women aren't encouraged to be assertive or to develop their talents as much as men, they're more encouraged to be pretty and to get a good man, and even if you don't buy that you can't argue that women are judged more on their looks than their talent or merits.[/quote]
That's why it's important to support people like Ani who prove that there's much more to a woman than looks and nurturing the male ego. By the same token you have to admit that many women have been more than willing to get by on their looks, so you can't put ALL of the blame on men-- just most of it. I honestly listen to Ani because she articulates things in ways that most men, even Prince, won't or can't. The female perspective is sorely under-represented in our society and it's necessary to our well-being. [Edited 11/7/04 12:53pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Becoz you don't hear about 'em(or you choose not to) lemme drop some names for you and you be the judge:
-Bessie Smith -Billie Holiday AKA Lady Day -Ellla Fitzgerald -Sarah Vaughan AKA Sassy -The Queen Of Gospel Miss Mahalia Jackson -Marian Anderson, the 1st black female opera vocalist. -Mary Lou Williams, the 1st black female bandleader/arranger and the mentor for the bebop musicians(Dizzy, Bird, Miles, Bud, Monk & them). -Hazel Scott, the 1st musician to infuse boogie woogie/stride piano with classical and the 1st black woman to have her own TV SHOW. -Pearl Bailey, the 1st black female comediene and broadway star. -Dinah "Queenie" Washington AKA The Queen Of Jukebox -Aunt 'Retha, The Queen Of Soul -Chaka Khan, The queen of fusion. What else do you wanna know? [Edited 11/7/04 13:19pm] | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
Harlepolis said: Becoz you don't hear about 'em(or you choose not to) lemme drop some names for you and you be the judge:
-Bessie Smith -Billie Holiday AKA Lady Day -Ellla Fitzgerald -Sarah Vaughan AKA Sassy -The Queen Of Gospel Miss Mahalia Jackson -Marian Anderson, the 1st black female opera vocalist. -Mary Lou Williams, the 1st black female bandleader/arranger and the mentor for the bebop musicians(Dizzy, Bird, Miles, Bud, Monk & them). -Hazel Scott, the 1st musician to infuse boogie woogie/stride piano with classical and the 1st black woman to have her own TV SHOW. -Pearl Bailey, the 1st black female comediene and broadway star. -Dinah "Queenie" Washington AKA The Queen Of Jukebox -Aunt 'Retha, The Queen Of Soul -Chaka Khan, The queen of fusion. What else do you wanna know? [Edited 11/7/04 13:19pm] All due respect to these ladies, most of them are just singers (emphasis on MOST) | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
And so are Tony Bennett, Frank Sinatra, Bing Crosby, Luciano Pavarotti, Elvis Presley (plays guitar a bit better than Madonna), Robert Plant, Joe Williams, Smokey Robinson, etc. But nobody questions the merits of their legendary status.
And in general, most singers of that era have at least some rudimentary knowledge/experience of playing piano chords or guitar chords, male and female. This post not for the wimp contingent. All whiny wusses avert your eyes. | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |
jacktheimprovident said: Harlepolis said: Becoz you don't hear about 'em(or you choose not to) lemme drop some names for you and you be the judge:
-Bessie Smith -Billie Holiday AKA Lady Day -Ellla Fitzgerald -Sarah Vaughan AKA Sassy -The Queen Of Gospel Miss Mahalia Jackson -Marian Anderson, the 1st black female opera vocalist. -Mary Lou Williams, the 1st black female bandleader/arranger and the mentor for the bebop musicians(Dizzy, Bird, Miles, Bud, Monk & them). -Hazel Scott, the 1st musician to infuse boogie woogie/stride piano with classical and the 1st black woman to have her own TV SHOW. -Pearl Bailey, the 1st black female comediene and broadway star. -Dinah "Queenie" Washington AKA The Queen Of Jukebox -Aunt 'Retha, The Queen Of Soul -Chaka Khan, The queen of fusion. What else do you wanna know? [Edited 11/7/04 13:19pm] All due respect to these ladies, most of them are just singers (emphasis on MOST) But what great singers they are....all of them icons... (...tho I hope CK doesn't still hit those Newports... ) "...all you need ...is justa touch...of mojo hand....." | |
- E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator |