independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > News Comments > Guide2Prince.org shut down
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 6 of 7 <1234567>
  Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #150 posted 01/18/04 6:21am

foreign

Prince is another person now. He doesn't care about his past and so should we.
He is more like, leaving his past behind and living his future.
Don't be surprised if worse acts happen from now on.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #151 posted 01/18/04 8:19am

ArtFantastic

Instead of releasing 2 star rated albums over the past fifteen years he should have stopped recording until his creativity had rejuvented - but Prince is a quantity man, not a quality man!

But talking about bootlegs and shutting down sites, remember 10 years ago when he said 'Free the music' if his music was free then everybody owns it, so bootleggers own it simple. But Prince's answer to 'free the music' was a dodgy website where you paid large sums of $ to listen to music that had no content 'What I call glitter music, that 'Gold, Emancipation stuff that is in the bargain bin for a $!)

If Prince wants to combat the bootleggers - well Prince, release your vault on a 200 cd compilation worth $800. Would you buy it?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #152 posted 01/18/04 8:46am

undulatingacro
bat

Too bad because it was the best Prince site of any kind that I ever saw. But, it does support those that make and buy bootlegs if it is giving information about them - even if it doesnt sell them or tell where to get them. If all Prince fans were like me and bought all official releases regardless of what was on the black market, bootlegs would not be a threat to any artist.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #153 posted 01/18/04 9:42am

EverlastingNow

avatar

Bull said:

Everlastingnow, I guess that now your telling me that Prince is who he is because of the people that he worked with. Your more full of shit than I thought. You like wendy and lisa and because of them Prince became a star right.Remember Prince recorded many many songs before them.His first 4 albums were recorded solely by himself, vocals as ell as the music.So stop acting LIKE A FOOL AND LISTEN TO WHAT YOUR SAYING. Prince hired them to tour,not to right songs.Dumbass


Yes that's exactly what I'm telling you. nod I'm not just talking about Wendy and Lisa that's a big assumtion on your part. You don't know Prince history very well if think he did what he did all by himself, he's only as good as the people around him. Look at the weak shit he did in the 90's. And a lot of the music that were on the first 4 albums were based off of jams sessions he'd have with the band. Look at the Dirty Mind album, Fink co-wrote Dirty Mind, Uptown was Andre's and Partyup was Morris' song, so there's 3 songs out of 8 that he had help on. So maybe you should listen to what you're saying lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #154 posted 01/18/04 11:38am

minneapolisgen
ius

avatar

Handclapsfingasnapz said:



:kicksprinceinthebuttreallyhard: hrmph


lol
"I saw a woman with major Hammer pants on the subway a few weeks ago and totally thought of you." - sextonseven
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #155 posted 01/18/04 12:59pm

J0eyC0c0

2freaky4church1 said:

Why isn't anyone mad at Deane for chickening out? He had a good case.


No he doesn't. They got something on him and it's not the site itself. :p
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #156 posted 01/18/04 1:04pm

KeithyT

avatar

wyld1 said:

SquirrelMeat said:

Anyone else notice that Guide2prince only got mentioned on the on org the other day, and now they get a letter?

The NPGMC are getting their source from here.

Someone new says, "Hey, where can I find out about..." and some idiot puts the URL up.

Its our fault people...think, before you type!


Maybe it was someone from the NPGMC club who asked. Hmmm.

The hyperlink to guide2prince.org has been on the links page of this very site since the revamp in 2002 (at least). It wasn't a secret underground site. There is no over-riding NPGMC member conspiracy to tittle tattle and to suggest there is smacks of paranoia.
Just somewhere in the middle,
Not too good and not too bad.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #157 posted 01/18/04 1:32pm

Abrazo

bkw said:

The reason i say I understand why he is doing it is because although the site does not sell, trade bootlegs etc it does implicitly encourage them. As pointed out above, it also illegally publishes copyrighted photographs, images etc.


Most likely none of the photographs copyrights are owned by Prince, but by the photographers. And even if he did it wouldn't justify shutting down the entire website. Instead taking down the pics would be just fine.

As for the alleged "encouragement" of bootleg selling and trading, that entirely depends on the facts as interpreted by a judge. There is a conflict of freedom of speech and copyright protection there. A judge's personal opinion usually makes the difference then.
You are not my "friend" because you threaten my security.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #158 posted 01/18/04 1:35pm

Abrazo

DAFUNKYOU said:

TRON said:

Is anyone happy about this? I mean, other than Prince of course.


Although having the content of illegal bootlegs can be questioned by the 1st Admendment I think the real issue here is in the section 'picture disks'. This section contains pictures that are copyright protected under the DMCA. The problem is that on each HTML page for each picture album the statement "copyright 2002 guide2prince.org" as at the bottom of each page. This implies that the content including the picture is the property of the website owner and not NPG Music Group. This is what violates the DMCA.

The website only claims a copyright on "the look and feel" of it, that is the selection and arrangement of other copyrighted material. It does not claim to own the materials it has selected and arranged. And btw, the DMCA is only an act which is part of the US Copyright Statute. It does not specifically have to do with this.


--
[This message was edited Sun Jan 18 13:37:23 PST 2004 by Abrazo]
You are not my "friend" because you threaten my security.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #159 posted 01/18/04 1:42pm

bombpop

avatar

this is making me sick! Guide2Prince.org is one of the greatest websites of all time! The work they have put in on that is incredible.

I have a ton of bootlegs, but ya know, I didn't buy one from Guide2Prince.org. Not one! How can you justify going after this site, Prince? It just proves that you just don't have a clue anymore.

Here is my take on bootlegs. I hope Prince or his Nazi spys are reading. Bootlegs perpetuate Prince as an artist. He only has a core of diehard fans left, and bootlegs keep us going. THE BOOTLEGS KEEP US INTERESTED UNTIL YOU GET AROUND TO RELEASING AN ALBUM!!! If it weren't for the boots, many of us would of jumped ship after Emancipation, or way before that. The bootlegs keep you going as far as why your hardcore fans can still be your fans, the ones buying your high-priced garbage from 1-800-NEWFUNK, and the NPGMC. It's us, we're all the same people.

Dude, I'm telling you, alienate your fans more and more by elimanating their sense of community through sites like Guide2Prince.org and you see your bank account go down, down ,down. How can you not see that??? Boots keep fans coming to the shows, patiently waiting for you to release something worthwhile, and buying your stupid t-shirts from your do-nothing website, that costs 25 bucks per year, or more. Have a clue!!!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #160 posted 01/18/04 3:17pm

bananacologne

FUCK YOU prince*, FUCK YOU - AND KISS MY HEAVILY-LADEN BOOTLEGED ASS WHILE UR AT IT booty!

*ur not even worthy of my capital letterage anymore little man
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #161 posted 01/18/04 6:00pm

PhilG

Another site just bit the dust:

http://www.smallclub.org/

smallclub has recently been contacted by the law firm representing P and his music club. As a result, this site has been temporarily closed.

Sorry for the inconvenience.

-- smallclub staff

My god, who's next?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #162 posted 01/18/04 6:02pm

shausler

well this news

caps off the perfect

shit day for me


sad
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #163 posted 01/18/04 7:32pm

chinua

this is total bullshit
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #164 posted 01/18/04 8:05pm

Bull

avatar

Everlastingnow, Your a freakin bonehead, Prince wrote all of those songs,Prince and prince himself.You keep talking about all of these other people. Let me give you the benefit of the dought for a minute and say that all of the people that you are talking about are great. How have their last few albums faired? How many albums have they put out in the last couple of years?How have their tours been, if in fact they toured at all? Are you understanding my point yet. You may not like prince, you may think that he makes bad business decisions, you may hate the way that he looks, but you can not honestly sit here and tell me that any of them are on his level musically. At least up until the last couple of years.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #165 posted 01/18/04 9:59pm

GaryMF

avatar

Why oh why isn't anyone standing up and fighting this?

Are there no lawyers on the Org or anywhere else who can lend G2P or Small Club a hand??? Or PR people that can help them get the media on their side?
Is the press getting a hold of this???

This is just insane.
rainbow
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #166 posted 01/18/04 10:30pm

EverlastingNow

avatar

Bull said:

Everlastingnow, Your a freakin bonehead, Prince wrote all of those songs,Prince and prince himself.You keep talking about all of these other people. Let me give you the benefit of the dought for a minute and say that all of the people that you are talking about are great. How have their last few albums faired? How many albums have they put out in the last couple of years?How have their tours been, if in fact they toured at all? Are you understanding my point yet. You may not like prince, you may think that he makes bad business decisions, you may hate the way that he looks, but you can not honestly sit here and tell me that any of them are on his level musically. At least up until the last couple of years.


That's it?? That's your response?? lol Prince and Prince himself huh? Well, that alone proves you haven't a fricking clue so let's discuss this again when you get one okay?

And by the way, who the fuck cares how their albums faired?? The Rainbow Children sold not even a fraction that Britney's latest has, does that make Britney's better?? jerkoff
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #167 posted 01/19/04 12:34am

piemel

well the only way to really show your disgust with this move is tor write a letter and mail it to the management and to the legal dept

bitching here aint gonna do much
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #168 posted 01/19/04 1:08am

klaatu

avatar

All i have to say is that boots are illegal and there is no use of talking about them except to promote their existence... I have complained a lot here about the "boot talking", so I hav to say i agree with that but well don't really dig the pain it may cause but think of the one who produce those songs, it must be a pain to know there are people illegally sell them...
"Goodness will guide us when love is inside of us... The Force will be with you, always"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #169 posted 01/19/04 1:17am

beautifulone7

Just to let you know this thread at NPGMC has had over 3,500 views and is 13 pages long as of 1:00 am Sunday, Jan. 18 and ALL views have been expressed.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #170 posted 01/19/04 3:14am

DrD

WHY WHAT APPLIES TO MARIJUANA (TALK ABOUT IT AS LONG AS YOU DO NOT SELL SOME) DOES NOT APPLY TO PRINCE'S BOOTLEGS ?

I agree with the comments that basically state that bootlegs actuallt BOOST Prince's album sales. They are what made him a legendary artist untimately, and they are what keep many fans' interest alive. However, as I said so many times, it should be once again no surprise for fans that he is, has always been and will always be a HUGE ASSHOLE. So no reason to leave the Prince train in my view, just leave many expectations aside...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #171 posted 01/19/04 9:55am

chiltonmusic

avatar

Okay this is what I do not understand. A few months ago Prince asked for all those who owned bootlegs to return them to him. Many of you (if not all) said hell no called him an asshole (much like today) etc. What I don't understand is if you all feel justified in those feeling about music that you purchased and did not create why would you think the creator of that music; who has every right to own and control the distribution of that music should feel any differently? I mean does that make sense to the many of you who keep calling him an asshole for doing this? If Prince has a bug up his ass about WBR (the company that made him) over sharing ownership and making much money on the music. What makes you think that he would not go after any site that has to do with bootlegging? I know that his boots are legendary I really do. I also feel if he released some of this shit himself he would be swimming in the money. I just don't agree with the overall feeling people have that they are somehow being cheated because Prince is fighting for what is his by rights!! As I stated in the start of my response if you feel that the boots you own are yours then you have no leg to stand on being angry with Prince for wanting sole control and ownership of his music.
Peace
THE CARDINAL HAS SPOKEN!!!
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #172 posted 01/19/04 10:51am

klaatu

avatar

chiltonmusic said:

Okay this is what I do not understand. A few months ago Prince asked for all those who owned bootlegs to return them to him. Many of you (if not all) said hell no called him an asshole (much like today) etc. What I don't understand is if you all feel justified in those feeling about music that you purchased and did not create why would you think the creator of that music; who has every right to own and control the distribution of that music should feel any differently? I mean does that make sense to the many of you who keep calling him an asshole for doing this? If Prince has a bug up his ass about WBR (the company that made him) over sharing ownership and making much money on the music. What makes you think that he would not go after any site that has to do with bootlegging? I know that his boots are legendary I really do. I also feel if he released some of this shit himself he would be swimming in the money. I just don't agree with the overall feeling people have that they are somehow being cheated because Prince is fighting for what is his by rights!! As I stated in the start of my response if you feel that the boots you own are yours then you have no leg to stand on being angry with Prince for wanting sole control and ownership of his music.
Peace


The problems for many fans here ids that becasue they are fans they "own" the music as much as prince do... Even if there is no involvment from their side!!!
"Goodness will guide us when love is inside of us... The Force will be with you, always"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #173 posted 01/19/04 11:29am

ArtFantastic

Prince got tighter as he got older because he lost his hair and now he wears a wig, true or false?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #174 posted 01/19/04 11:46am

Abrazo

chiltonmusic said:

Okay this is what I do not understand. A few months ago Prince asked for all those who owned bootlegs to return them to him. Many of you (if not all) said hell no called him an asshole (much like today) etc. What I don't understand is if you all feel justified in those feeling about music that you purchased and did not create why would you think the creator of that music; who has every right to own and control the distribution of that music should feel any differently?

I mean does that make sense to the many of you who keep calling him an asshole for doing this? If Prince has a bug up his ass about WBR (the company that made him) over sharing ownership and making much money on the music. What makes you think that he would not go after any site that has to do with bootlegging? I know that his boots are legendary I really do.

I also feel if he released some of this shit himself he would be swimming in the money. I just don't agree with the overall feeling people have that they are somehow being cheated because Prince is fighting for what is his by rights!! As I stated in the start of my response if you feel that the boots you own are yours then you have no leg to stand on being angry with Prince for wanting sole control and ownership of his music.
Peace


What you probably don't understand is that the facts seem to indicate that this site does not sell, distribute the music. It talks about it and provides information on what is out there, but not where and how to get it. This may be "encouragement" of buying bootlegs, but even if they encourage to buy bootlegs it is not copyright infrigement and therefore has got very little to do with infringing on Prince's intellectual property rights.
You are not my "friend" because you threaten my security.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #175 posted 01/19/04 12:35pm

Bull

avatar

Everlastingnow, What the hell does Brittany Spears have to do with this conversation? What a dumbass statement to make.When she puts 30 or 40 albums out then you come and talk to me, until then know what the hell your talking about.Those other artists haven't put out any music, and they haven't toured because know is interested. I'm not saying that I don't like them or their music, I'm just saying that there is not enough mainstream interest to get their careers moving again. Clintonmusic you are exactly correct in what you said.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #176 posted 01/19/04 2:02pm

bananacologne

bored
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #177 posted 01/19/04 2:08pm

MilkSode

avatar

To bad all these posts weren't something worth chatting about, like - new music.
I agree bored
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #178 posted 01/19/04 2:17pm

BinaryJustin

TonyC said:

BTW, I wish the operators of Guide2Prince.org would save their entire site in a big .rar file and share it on the Royal Hub, so at least fans still have access to the information.

There is another bootleg guide site that is even more current and I love it and use it most every day. I hope Prince's people don't find it and shut it down. I won't put the name here, but it is a great one.


I think that if ever anybody starts another Prince reference site, they should add a link to a zip file on the home page with maybe a 5-downloads-a-day limit, so that somebody somewhere always has a back-up of the site and can host it on any anomynous free web provider.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #179 posted 01/19/04 2:19pm

optimumshaboog
ie

avatar

GaryMF said:

Why oh why isn't anyone standing up and fighting this?

Are there no lawyers on the Org or anywhere else who can lend G2P or Small Club a hand??? Or PR people that can help them get the media on their side?
Is the press getting a hold of this???

This is just insane.


or could many of the extremely eloquent posters here write to the following
Qmagazine@Q4music.com
MOJO@emap.com

2 of the UK's leading music mags - Q especially interested in the internet and the music biz
"you know it takes more energy to frown than it does to smile!"... yeah well, did you know it takes more energy for you to point that out than it does to **** off and leave me alone.....
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 6 of 7 <1234567>
  Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > News Comments > Guide2Prince.org shut down