JoeTyler said:

NorthC said:

JoeTyler said:

yeah

the guy had been treated before, depression AND suicidal tendencies, so WHAT THE FUCK was he doing working for an airline???

News reports I read (in Dutch) said he was under treatment years ago (they don't say how many years) for being suicidal. But the last few years (once again, they don't say how many), doctors saw no suicidal or agressive behaviour. This is all hearsay of course, but it does raise an interesting question: how would sueing the airline help anybody? Suppose someone suffered from depressions and agressive behaviour, say, 5 years ago, does that mean he'd never be allowed to work again? Let's not judge too soon.

yeah, let's not judge too soon, it's not that he hasn't already killed himself AND 150 innocent lives or anything like that...

NorthC said:

JoeTyler said:

yeah

the guy had been treated before, depression AND suicidal tendencies, so WHAT THE FUCK was he doing working for an airline???

News reports I read (in Dutch) said he was under treatment years ago (they don't say how many years) for being suicidal. But the last few years (once again, they don't say how many), doctors saw no suicidal or agressive behaviour. This is all hearsay of course, but it does raise an interesting question: how would sueing the airline help anybody? Suppose someone suffered from depressions and agressive behaviour, say, 5 years ago, does that mean he'd never be allowed to work again? Let's not judge too soon.

Oh please there are plenty of jobs where past behaviors will cause one to never be hired, EVER, add public safety issues on top of it, those families could give a bleep less about judging lest thou be judged kind of thoughts, they'd rather have their loved ones home safe.

JoeTyler said:

NorthC said:

JoeTyler said: News reports I read (in Dutch) said he was under treatment years ago (they don't say how many years) for being suicidal. But the last few years (once again, they don't say how many), doctors saw no suicidal or agressive behaviour. This is all hearsay of course, but it does raise an interesting question: how would sueing the airline help anybody? Suppose someone suffered from depressions and agressive behaviour, say, 5 years ago, does that mean he'd never be allowed to work again? Let's not judge too soon.

yeah, let's not judge too soon, it's not that he hasn't already killed himself AND 150 innocent lives or anything like that...

looks like your "piece of shit" comment was not called for............yeah, i thought the same thing too but it is looking more and more like mental issues and suicidal thoughts...........i don't think he intentionally set out to take people with him.......the one thing that is obvious is that he wanted to die and apparently there is a national obsession with personal privacy in Germany that may have helped him keep his job when he probably should have had his license suspended.........by the way - - Happy Bi-Polar Day (March 30)

[Edited 3/30/15 17:33pm]

[Edited 3/30/15 17:34pm]

^sorry, but mass murderers are pieces of shit in my book, and since I started this thread...

a person who finally succumbs to his/her inner demons and suicidal thoughts and kills her/himself has all my sympathy and pity

a piece of shit who kills 150 individuals can go fuck him/herself wherever he/she is now

guy wanted to be somebody...the easy way, by killing innocent children, men and women

FUCK HIM

[Edited 3/30/15 19:15pm]

What's even more interesting is the fact that the Co-pilot kept his family out of harms way and intentionally Murdered other peoples families. He has hurt and devastated his Family in the most Evil way possible...My heart always go out to suicide victims that feel their problems are too much to bear. The Co-pilot's act is Selfish and we will forever see him as a Murderer and Terrorist.

Chancellor said:

ntentionally Murdered other peoples families.

He has hurt and devastated his Family in the most Evil way possible...M

The Co-pilot's act is Selfish and we will forever see him as a Murderer and Terrorist.

my point exactly

Chancellor said:

What's even more interesting is the fact that the Co-pilot kept his family out of harms way and intentionally Murdered other peoples families. He has hurt and devastated his Family in the most Evil way possible...My heart always go out to suicide victims that feel their problems are too much to bear. The Co-pilot's act is Selfish and we will forever see him as a Murderer and Terrorist.

Can u imagine the narrative if this guy was Muslim or from some so called rogue Nation?

CynicKill said:

PurpleJedi said:

Seems like it was Depression.



I'm sorry but if you're going to commit suicide, there's more dramatic ways of doing so that DON'T involve hundreds of innocent lives.

>

I disagree.

There's no more dramatic a way of doing this.

I'm not suicidal, but I surely can come up with WAYYY more dramatic means of ending one's life WITHOUT murdering innocents.

I'm sure that no one has yet jumped off the Burg-Khalifa, for starters...

JoeTyler said:

^sorry, but mass murderers are pieces of shit in my book, and since I started this thread...

a person who finally succumbs to his/her inner demons and suicidal thoughts and kills her/himself has all my sympathy and pity

a piece of shit who kills 150 individuals can go fuck him/herself wherever he/she is now

guy wanted to be somebody...the easy way, by killing innocent children, men and women

FUCK HIM

[Edited 3/30/15 19:15pm]

looks like Lufthansa knew Lubitz had a serious bout of depression before they readmitted him to pilot training - so I guess they will get sued - and Lufthansa looks like the guilty one here - meanwhile a depressed co-pilot with suicidal tendencies killed himself and others just happened to be on the plane when he did it........."FUCK YOU" won't solve anything and doesn't lead the discussion anywhere

3rdeyedude said:

JoeTyler said:

^sorry, but mass murderers are pieces of shit in my book, and since I started this thread...

a person who finally succumbs to his/her inner demons and suicidal thoughts and kills her/himself has all my sympathy and pity

a piece of shit who kills 150 individuals can go fuck him/herself wherever he/she is now

guy wanted to be somebody...the easy way, by killing innocent children, men and women

FUCK HIM

[Edited 3/30/15 19:15pm]

looks like Lufthansa knew Lubitz had a serious bout of depression before they readmitted him to pilot training - so I guess they will get sued - and Lufthansa looks like the guilty one here - meanwhile a depressed co-pilot with suicidal tendencies killed himself and others just happened to be on the plane when he did it........."FUCK YOU" won't solve anything and doesn't lead the discussion anywhere

Thank you for bringing it back around to the issue. I can understand Joe's anger, but ultimately, nothing's achieved by not looking at causes and influences.

3rdeyedude said:

JoeTyler said:

^sorry, but mass murderers are pieces of shit in my book, and since I started this thread...

a person who finally succumbs to his/her inner demons and suicidal thoughts and kills her/himself has all my sympathy and pity

a piece of shit who kills 150 individuals can go fuck him/herself wherever he/she is now

guy wanted to be somebody...the easy way, by killing innocent children, men and women

FUCK HIM

[Edited 3/30/15 19:15pm]

looks like Lufthansa knew Lubitz had a serious bout of depression before they readmitted him to pilot training - so I guess they will get sued - and Lufthansa looks like the guilty one here - meanwhile a depressed co-pilot with suicidal tendencies killed himself and others just happened to be on the plane when he did it........."FUCK YOU" won't solve anything and doesn't lead the discussion anywhere

Thank you for bringing it back around to the issue. I can understand Joe's anger, but ultimately, nothing's achieved by not looking at causes and influences.

^^and that's the problem with some folks these days

so goddamn obsessed at PC that they cannot see the differenceS between depression, suicidal tendencies and straight up MURDER

whatever

[Edited 3/31/15 19:54pm]

JoeTyler said:

^^and that's the problem with some folks these days

so goddamn obsessed at PC that they cannot see the differenceS between depression, suicidal tendencies and straight up MURDER

whatever

[Edited 3/31/15 19:54pm]

You seem to be intentionally misrepresenting my points. Where did I say that he did not MURDER these people? Of course he killed them. You are conflating the words "understand" and "condone." If I were to look for the sources of a cancer case, would you accuse me of being "soft on cancer?"

I can only imagine (and dont want to) the horror those folks on that plane went thru. My God...all I know is I am NEVER flying again. With this "copycat" society, we have not seen the last of these "incidents".

Chancellor said:

What's even more interesting is the fact that the Co-pilot kept his family out of harms way and intentionally Murdered other peoples families. He has hurt and devastated his Family in the most Evil way possible...My heart always go out to suicide victims that feel their problems are too much to bear. The Co-pilot's act is Selfish and we will forever see him as a Murderer and Terrorist.

Exactly.

The only thing this man struggled with...

At what point, which flight would he get the opportunity to crash a commercial airplane.

Graycap23 said:

second black box

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/03/germanwings-co-pilot-accelerated-plane-during-descent