NEWARK — Beating his fist on a lectern Wednesday, Mayor Cory A. Booker railed not only at three men charged with forcing another man to strip naked before savagely whipping him and capturing it on video, but especially at those who knew about the attack and did not tell the police.
Mel Evans/Associated Press
Mayor Cory A. Booker at a news conference Wednesday.
“In the face of evil, those who remain quiet are participants in that evil,” Mr. Booker said. “We’re better than this.”
Mr. Booker, a Democratic Senate candidate who has made improving the hardscrabble image of the state’s largest city a cornerstone of his two terms as mayor, held a news conference at the police communications center to address the crime, which took place in August and came to the attention of the police on Friday.
The Newark police identified the three suspects over the weekend after they saw the video, which had been viewed widely. The video, which has been removed from YouTube, shows the thin victim cowering as he is slashed with a belt. In between the cracking sounds of the belt’s striking flesh, the laughter of accomplices can be heard.
The suspects, all from Newark, are each charged with armed robbery and aggravated assault. The police said Ahmad Holt, 22, did the whipping and was incarcerated in Trenton on an unrelated charge. Raheem Clark, 31, is accused of giving Mr. Holt his belt, the police said, and was arrested in Newark on Tuesday. The police said that the cameraman, who can be seen squirting water on the victim, was Jamaar Gray, 23, and that he turned himself in on Tuesday.
For Mr. Booker, the fact that this attack went unreported for months despite being witnessed, videotaped and uploaded added insult to injury. On Wednesday, he struck the lectern, sending a loud bleat of microphone feedback through speakers.
“Others saw this brutality and said nothing; this vicious crime was not reported,” he said, also paraphrasing the dictum attributed to the British orator Edmund Burke: “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
Newark’s police director, Samuel DeMaio, said that after the police saw the video, they identified the spot where the assault took place as an alley off Irvine Turner Boulevard. Mr. DeMaio said officers canvassed the neighborhood and found several people who knew about the attack, then used that information to find the victim, who the police said was 21 and had moved away out of concern for his safety. Mr. DeMaio said the victim had not reported the assault because he feared his assailants.
The police director said the victim’s father had owed $20 to the suspects, who all had gang affiliations and had stolen that amount from the victim.
Carolyn Murray, acting prosecutor for Essex County, said the men could each face 10 to 20 years in prison if convicted of armed robbery, and 5 to 10 years if convicted of aggravated assault. They could also be charged with crimes for uploading the video, she said, but it was unclear who had uploaded the video.
Of more than a dozen people interviewed on Wednesday afternoon near the spot where the victim was whipped, none would give their names. A young man who said he had seen the assault described it as “not a big deal,” adding, “The mayor just made it a problem because it made him look bad.”
Mr. Booker said he had received hundreds of calls, e-mails and Twitter messages from people who had seen the video and were aghast.
“There is a brutal culture in this community,” he said. “It’s not the city’s culture, but it’s a subculture of violence and crime. And the reality is it’s something I think we could fight a lot better if more people who were not involved found a way to speak up, engage and do something.”
http://www.nytimes.com/20....html?_r=0