I love Janet and all but shes starting to look really fat. What do you think?

I wouldn't quite call that obese but it's hard to tell in that pic.

dreamfactory313 said:

I think that, like me, you have too much time on your hands.

Also, if Janet had a baby every time she gained weight in the past, she had like 20 kids.

Also, WRONG FORUM!

HamsterHuey said:

LOL. You're probably right.

HamsterHuey said:

I think she has been trying to become pregnant and since she turned 30 in 1995, she would probably be using methods that recommend weight gain before implantation.

Janet's never been known for sharing her business. I don't think she would say to her fans on a TV interview with Ellen "listen up everybody, I had a miscarriage in 2005" or whatever.

She's just fat again. She'll be skinny by July. Yo-Yo dieting is just a part of Janet's life.

Janet seems to be a person that, if she's not promoting anything, just struggles to keep weight off. But she's always been able to take it off when she needs to. I just wonder how healthy that is to yo-yo like that with your weight.

Maybe she can join Oprah's "I fell off the wagon" program.

To be honest..does it really matter?

MoniGram said:

Not really as Ive never even met her before but its weird seeing her this heavy, thats all.

violator said:

It's not healthy at all. I'm not a doctor and I may be off on this but I believe all of that fluctuation with weight can mess with your heart. I heard that's a big reason why Luther Vandross had that stroke in 2003.

purplecam said:

Yes, this cant be healthy at all. It can increase ones risk for heart disease, hypertension, diabetes, and gallstones.
[Edited 1/23/09 9:45am]

I guess if that is obese - then I am totally screwed

dreamfactory313 said:

Exactly. It's very scary.

Where's the "c) Dressed in bulky winter clothes" option?

This was taken a few days before:

Like her I yo-yo, and its not healthy at all. One month I can be 120, the next 130, then back at 118.

When food is an addiction its a struggle everyday. But I think she can be preggers this time. She has one that is about 20 and Im sure she wants another.

The first one is this big secret cause of the debarge family.....

She's thicker but I don't think she's obese.

Naturally, shes always been a big girl.
I would expect it to be harder to control as one ages.

horatio said:

MoniGram said:

seriously...

I'd still give her a back rub...

In this last photo she looks like a normal woman to me. I think the celebs have twisted the way the rest of society judges "normal". They are so tiny that even a size 8 would look big next to them.

That's NOT obese. C'mon.
And it just look's like mama's put on some weight, not pregnant or obese.

JustErin said:

So, she's not pregnant? I thought people were saying she was?

If so, pregnant women are not encouraged to diet.

If not, who cares? Does it really affect your life if she's fat or not?

If I was a women I would love to look like her, fat OR skinny.

HamsterHuey said: