Publisher cancels disputed Holocaust love story

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - A publisher has canceled a Holocaust memoir with an amazing love story publicized by Oprah Winfrey after the writer admitted he made up parts, adding the book to a growing list of fabricated memoirs.

Berkley Books, an imprint of the Penguin Group, said it was canceling "Angel at the Fence, The True Story of a Love that Survived" after writer Herman Rosenblat admitted to his agent Andrea Hurst that he had invented part of the book.

Rosenblat, 79, appeared twice on Oprah's TV show to tell a story about meeting his wife when she threw apples to him over a fence at a Nazi concentration camp in Germany but it transpired he made up the story for a newspaper contest about a decade ago.

"Berkley will demand that the author and the agent return all money that they have received for this work," said Berkley Books spokesman Craig Burke in a statement.

Rosenblat's agent Andrea Hurst said in a statement that the writer had revealed to her that he invented the crux of the love story in which he claimed he met his wife when he was a teenage prisoner in a camp at Schlieben, Germany, and she threw him food.

He wrote that after the war he moved to New York and by chance met Polish immigrant Roma Radzicki who turned out to be the girl who threw him food. They fell in love and got married.

Hurst said Rosenblat's story about being in the concentration camps and the survival of the writer and his brothers was true but the retired electrical contractor from North Miami Beach, Florida, had made up the love story that had won such attention.

SAD ENDING TO A LOVE STORY

"Like millions of others who read this story or saw Herman and Roma on Oprah, I never for a moment questioned the authenticity of the widely circulated story," said Hurst.

"I know that everyone who has worked so hard with Herman this past year is as stunned and disappointed as I am that this story of hope has such a sad ending."

Polish-born Rosenblat could not be contacted for comment.

The memoir, due to be published in February, came under public scrutiny after several scholars in The New Republic challenged the book, saying Rosenblat's description of the camp was inaccurate and throwing food over the fence impossible.

Harris Salomon, president of Atlantic Overseas Pictures is pushing ahead with plans to make a $25 million movie about Herman Rosenblat with filming to start in Hungary in March.

"There are some thing in life you don't question, like a Holocaust survivor. I believed it," said Salomon who had spoken to Rosenblat since the book was canceled.

"He claimed he did it because he thought it would help him tell the story about the Holocaust. It was something that helped young people understand. It was the right message but a bad messenger. But the core of this story is really wonderful."

Salomon said the movie would portray the full story. "In essence there will be two stories -- the fantasy of what he created in his mind intercut with the real life Herman Rosenblat, a man who made it up," said Salomon. "I will portray him as someone who did something very wrong."

Historian Deborah Lipstadt, a professor of Modern Jewish and Holocaust Studies at Emory University, Atlanta, wrote on her blog that the book had upset some other Holocaust survivors and could also give fodder to Holocaust deniers.

The book is the latest in a list of memoirs in which the author has been accused of fabrication and could put greater pressure on publishers to fact check books more carefully.

In 2006, U.S. author James Frey admitted he had fabricated key parts of his drug and alcohol memoir "A Million Little Pieces," the top selling non-fiction book in the United States in 2005.

In February, Misha Defonseca admitted most of her bestselling autobiography, which told of a young Jewish girl saved by wolves while hiding from the Nazis in wartime Europe, was made up.

"Love and Consequences," a memoir by a Margaret B. Jones about a mixed-raced girl growing up in a gang-ridden neighborhood of Los Angeles, was revealed to be a fabrication and distributed copies of the book recalled this year.

TonyVanDam said:

Pretty much like the rest of us dont u think?

chillichocaholic said:

tru dat .

Why would anyone blame Oprah?

dreamfactory313 said:

Who's blaming Oprah?

TonyVanDam said:

More like publishers will. Maybe they need to do some basic fact-checking before they buy just any "nonfiction" story that comes their way.

chillichocaholic said:

I don't read the same kind of books that Oprah has been placing in her book club.

SCNDLS said:

Its the implication that by having these people on her show she is at fault for them lying. I saw a news report that seemed to blame her for "blowing up" these people.

TonyVanDam said:

Ummm what I mean is that every now and then we all fall for someones BS in life in general

TonyVanDam said:

All of her books are about a woman scorn. Or they are all set in before 1950. Start featuring some E. Lynn Harris, Eric Jerome Dickey or any other author that writes current material, then you might get my attention.

You would think that sources are checked very thoroughly

luv4u said:

From my understanding, there were not that many sources to check. Especially since the author supposedly lived the story.

YOU get a fake memoir! And YOU get a fake memoir! You ALL get fake memoirs!!!!

FunkMistress said:

dreamfactory313 said:

No, just that it's happening AGAIN considering that she was instrumental in blowing them up.
[Edited 12/30/08 7:33am]

daPrettyman said:

Black authors???? Oh hell to tha naw, unless they're talking about being on the DL. I can't stand Oprah.

Oprah

bless her heart

SCNDLS said:

Or Toni Morrison.

I'm sure if she had a new book, it would be featured.

Oprah runs from any black authors.

daPrettyman said:

Or Maya but that's more like her hookin' up her homegirls. Actually Toni does have new book out.

SCNDLS said:

Well, I'm sure it will be featured on the show at some point.

A good "story" is a good story.....

Graycap23 said:

I just wish people would have originally said it was either "based on a true story" or was a work of "fiction".

daPrettyman said:

Does it really matter?

daPrettyman said:

They did: "Angel at the Fence, The True Story of a Love that Survived"

It just wasn't so true.
[Edited 12/30/08 8:50am]