independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > General Discussion > Celibacy
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 4 of 4 <1234
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #90 posted 09/29/08 8:50am

Genesia

avatar

Stymie said:

I'm cool for the simple fact that I want to be in love and be loved in return by the person I sleep with. I've done the sex without a connection thing. It blows. It's been about 2 years now and I don't miss it.


And you so deserve to be loved. hug
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #91 posted 09/29/08 8:53am

CarrieMpls

Ex-Moderator

avatar

meow85 said:

Flowers2 said:




but Meow, that's your opinion (thinking it's not good to be celibate) and plus, you're an agnostic, so you won't see the spiritual side of it (or other people's view point). I too, believe a spiritual connection happens during sex, but how is somebody else choosing celibate affecting your life? if a person feels sex is sacred, and they want to be celibate for the right one.. that's them... now, if somebody else wants to have a bunch of partners, hey.. that's their life too...if somebody posted right now that they have 7 sexual partners, it's none of my business..that won't affect me in any kind of way, that's their life...


I find it pretty insulting that you equate my agnosticism with a failure to understand spirituality and a blindness to other views. confused

I understand spirituality fine, thanks, even if I can't honestly say for sure whether there is a god or gods. What I don't understand is assigning one bodily function spirituality. If sex is spiritual, then so is eating or breathing or sweating or taking a shit. What makes sex so special that it's elevated above everything else our bodies do?


oh, eating can absolutely be a positively spiritual experience. And I'm an atheist. lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #92 posted 09/29/08 9:00am

JustErin

avatar

Genesia said:

meow85 said:



I find it pretty insulting that you equate my agnosticism with a failure to understand spirituality and a blindness to other views. confused

I understand spirituality fine, thanks, even if I can't honestly say for sure whether there is a god or gods. What I don't understand is assigning one bodily function spirituality. If sex is spiritual, then so is eating or breathing or sweating or taking a shit. What makes sex so special that it's elevated above everything else our bodies do?


Oh, honey - if you don't see the difference between those things...

Eating, breathing, sweating and taking a shit are solitary activities. (Some are actually involuntary.) There might be other people around when you do them, but you do them alone.

Sex is not a solitary activity. It is a giving and sharing of the most intimate and vulnerable parts of you.

If you truly believe that sex is just "bodies bumping together," or a purely physical thing, you don't know what you're missing. It might feel good (really good), but it will never truly be mindblowing. For that to happen, all of you needs to be engaged - not just your genitalia.

And I say this as someone who has been where you are - and thought as you think.
[Edited 9/29/08 7:57am]


At first when I read this I was like, wtf??

But then, I thought a bit more about it and even I have to agree that it's absolutely more then just physical. That I wouldn't compare it to eating or breathing.

However, for me it has nothing to do with spirituality or even love...but there is a lot to be said about chemistry. I've also experienced both being in love with a person and also actually not really liking a person all that much...and really, there is no difference between the two...one is not better than the other.

But the one thing that made the sex mind-blowing - no matter who I was with - was that there was incredible physical chemistry and really when it comes to that kinda thing, isn't it mostly all in the brain?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #93 posted 09/29/08 9:10am

Genesia

avatar

JustErin said:

Genesia said:



Oh, honey - if you don't see the difference between those things...

Eating, breathing, sweating and taking a shit are solitary activities. (Some are actually involuntary.) There might be other people around when you do them, but you do them alone.

Sex is not a solitary activity. It is a giving and sharing of the most intimate and vulnerable parts of you.

If you truly believe that sex is just "bodies bumping together," or a purely physical thing, you don't know what you're missing. It might feel good (really good), but it will never truly be mindblowing. For that to happen, all of you needs to be engaged - not just your genitalia.

And I say this as someone who has been where you are - and thought as you think.
[Edited 9/29/08 7:57am]


At first when I read this I was like, wtf??

But then, I thought a bit more about it and even I have to agree that it's absolutely more then just physical. That I wouldn't compare it to eating or breathing.

However, for me it has nothing to do with spirituality or even love...but there is a lot to be said about chemistry. I've also experienced both being in love with a person and also actually not really liking a person all that much...and really, there is no difference between the two...one is not better than the other.

But the one thing that made the sex mind-blowing - no matter who I was with - was that there was incredible physical chemistry and really when it comes to that kinda thing, isn't it mostly all in the brain?


You say "chemistry," I say "spiritual connection." To me, that's just a to-may-to, to-mah-to thing.

But how can physical chemistry be in the brain? Physical (to me) is about body parts. Emotional/spiritual/chemical is a brain thing. shrug
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #94 posted 09/29/08 10:03am

JustErin

avatar

Genesia said:

JustErin said:



At first when I read this I was like, wtf??

But then, I thought a bit more about it and even I have to agree that it's absolutely more then just physical. That I wouldn't compare it to eating or breathing.

However, for me it has nothing to do with spirituality or even love...but there is a lot to be said about chemistry. I've also experienced both being in love with a person and also actually not really liking a person all that much...and really, there is no difference between the two...one is not better than the other.

But the one thing that made the sex mind-blowing - no matter who I was with - was that there was incredible physical chemistry and really when it comes to that kinda thing, isn't it mostly all in the brain?


You say "chemistry," I say "spiritual connection." To me, that's just a to-may-to, to-mah-to thing.

But how can physical chemistry be in the brain? Physical (to me) is about body parts. Emotional/spiritual/chemical is a brain thing. shrug



Well, I see it as the body physically responding to the brain responding to chemistry. If it was just a body response thing, anyone would be able to just turn you on...and that's definitely not the case for me. Some people can just drive me nuts, and (again for me) that has nothing to do with spirituality or even an emotional attachment.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #95 posted 09/29/08 1:29pm

NDRU

avatar

meow85 said:

Sex is one of the healthiest ... acts a being can engage in.


not so sure, as childbirth, STD's, HPV can be quite dangerous. I'd say drinking water is much healthier smile



I've heard of athletes and performers who practice celibacy before an important game or show, in the belief that they're saving up their energy, but there's no science behind that. There's never been any evidence that not abstaining drains energy away from other faculties.



have you ever walked down stairs after sex and your legs shake? I think that's what these athletes are thinking. If nothing else, sex is exercise. That's fine & healthy, but you wouldn't want to play three sets of tennis on the same day you have a swimming meet, would you? You might be worn out.

As a man I also think sex takes your mental edge away because you've "fulfilled your special purpose" at least for today lol So the competitive drive is lessened. I'm no scientist, but it feels as real to me as hunger, fatigue, etc.

Can't speak for women.
[Edited 9/29/08 13:33pm]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #96 posted 09/30/08 1:26am

meow85

avatar

Genesia said:



Oh, honey - if you don't see the difference between those things...

Eating, breathing, sweating and taking a shit are solitary activities. (Some are actually involuntary.) There might be other people around when you do them, but you do them alone.

Sex is not a solitary activity. It is a giving and sharing of the most intimate and vulnerable parts of you.

If you truly believe that sex is just "bodies bumping together," or a purely physical thing, you don't know what you're missing. It might feel good (really good), but it will never truly be mindblowing. For that to happen, all of you needs to be engaged - not just your genitalia.

And I say this as someone who has been where you are - and thought as you think.
[Edited 9/29/08 7:57am]


So having a companion is what makes sex spiritual? On what grounds?

No, I don't think sex is purely physical. Good sex -hell, even bad sex -engages the mind as well as the body. I have had mindblowing sex, thanks. I love how you seem to think the mind and some ether we call spirituality are the same thing, and assume that since I don't see spirituality in sex that I'm simply bumpin' uglies. If all sex was was physical gratification, why ever bother with a partner at all? Your argument is full of holes.

And don't call me, honey. Oddly enough, knowing you think you have a more enlightened view of sex than I makes that endearment come off as more sour than sweet. confused
[Edited 9/30/08 1:27am]
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #97 posted 09/30/08 1:29am

meow85

avatar

Genesia said:

JustErin said:



At first when I read this I was like, wtf??

But then, I thought a bit more about it and even I have to agree that it's absolutely more then just physical. That I wouldn't compare it to eating or breathing.

However, for me it has nothing to do with spirituality or even love...but there is a lot to be said about chemistry. I've also experienced both being in love with a person and also actually not really liking a person all that much...and really, there is no difference between the two...one is not better than the other.

But the one thing that made the sex mind-blowing - no matter who I was with - was that there was incredible physical chemistry and really when it comes to that kinda thing, isn't it mostly all in the brain?


You say "chemistry," I say "spiritual connection." To me, that's just a to-may-to, to-mah-to thing.

But how can physical chemistry be in the brain? Physical (to me) is about body parts. Emotional/spiritual/chemical is a brain thing. shrug


Emotional and chemical are not the same as spiritual.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #98 posted 09/30/08 1:33am

meow85

avatar

NDRU said:


not so sure, as childbirth, STD's, HPV can be quite dangerous. I'd say drinking water is much healthier smile


You haven;t had much tap water to drink lately, have you? razz

Sex, in and of itself, is healthy and natural. Take the proper precautions and it's fairly low risk.



have you ever walked down stairs after sex and your legs shake? I think that's what these athletes are thinking. If nothing else, sex is exercise. That's fine & healthy, but you wouldn't want to play three sets of tennis on the same day you have a swimming meet, would you? You might be worn out.

As a man I also think sex takes your mental edge away because you've "fulfilled your special purpose" at least for today lol So the competitive drive is lessened. I'm no scientist, but it feels as real to me as hunger, fatigue, etc.

Can't speak for women.
[Edited 9/29/08 13:33pm]


shrug Sex always revs up my energy levels. I've never felt tired or drained after the fact. I've even felt the urge to go out running afterwards, and I am not the jogging type.

Makes me hungry too. fter sex, I pack food away like there's a famine coming. lol
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #99 posted 09/30/08 10:27am

NDRU

avatar

meow85 said:

NDRU said:


not so sure, as childbirth, STD's, HPV can be quite dangerous. I'd say drinking water is much healthier smile



have you ever walked down stairs after sex and your legs shake? I think that's what these athletes are thinking. If nothing else, sex is exercise. That's fine & healthy, but you wouldn't want to play three sets of tennis on the same day you have a swimming meet, would you? You might be worn out.

As a man I also think sex takes your mental edge away because you've "fulfilled your special purpose" at least for today lol So the competitive drive is lessened. I'm no scientist, but it feels as real to me as hunger, fatigue, etc.

Can't speak for women.
[Edited 9/29/08 13:33pm]


shrug Sex always revs up my energy levels. I've never felt tired or drained after the fact. I've even felt the urge to go out running afterwards, and I am not the jogging type.

Makes me hungry too. fter sex, I pack food away like there's a famine coming. lol


My legs always feel weak after sex and I don't have the drive to push myself has hard if I go jogging. Maybe men & women are different (you are a woman, right?)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #100 posted 09/30/08 10:31am

CarrieMpls

Ex-Moderator

avatar

NDRU said:

meow85 said:



shrug Sex always revs up my energy levels. I've never felt tired or drained after the fact. I've even felt the urge to go out running afterwards, and I am not the jogging type.

Makes me hungry too. fter sex, I pack food away like there's a famine coming. lol


My legs always feel weak after sex and I don't have the drive to push myself has hard if I go jogging. Maybe men & women are different (you are a woman, right?)


I've heard it said there are people who GET energy from sex and those who are drained of energy from sex. I don't think it necessarily runs down gender lines.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #101 posted 09/30/08 10:40am

Mach

CarrieMpls said:

NDRU said:



My legs always feel weak after sex and I don't have the drive to push myself has hard if I go jogging. Maybe men & women are different (you are a woman, right?)


I've heard it said there are people who GET energy from sex and those who are drained of energy from sex. I don't think it necessarily runs down gender lines.


I have had both happen and even in the same 24 hrs

and it's not always about what time of day it is either lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #102 posted 09/30/08 10:42am

CarrieMpls

Ex-Moderator

avatar

Mach said:

CarrieMpls said:



I've heard it said there are people who GET energy from sex and those who are drained of energy from sex. I don't think it necessarily runs down gender lines.


I have had both happen and even in the same 24 hrs

and it's not always about what time of day it is either lol


So there ya go!

lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #103 posted 09/30/08 10:43am

NDRU

avatar

CarrieMpls said:

NDRU said:



My legs always feel weak after sex and I don't have the drive to push myself has hard if I go jogging. Maybe men & women are different (you are a woman, right?)


I've heard it said there are people who GET energy from sex and those who are drained of energy from sex. I don't think it necessarily runs down gender lines.


That makes sense. I've seen the same thing with smoking pot. Some go catatonic and some act as if they've smoked crack
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #104 posted 09/30/08 10:44am

Genesia

avatar

meow85 said:

Genesia said:



You say "chemistry," I say "spiritual connection." To me, that's just a to-may-to, to-mah-to thing.

But how can physical chemistry be in the brain? Physical (to me) is about body parts. Emotional/spiritual/chemical is a brain thing. shrug


Emotional and chemical are not the same as spiritual.


Again, your opinion.
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #105 posted 09/30/08 11:00am

Genesia

avatar

meow85 said:

Genesia said:



Oh, honey - if you don't see the difference between those things...

Eating, breathing, sweating and taking a shit are solitary activities. (Some are actually involuntary.) There might be other people around when you do them, but you do them alone.

Sex is not a solitary activity. It is a giving and sharing of the most intimate and vulnerable parts of you.

If you truly believe that sex is just "bodies bumping together," or a purely physical thing, you don't know what you're missing. It might feel good (really good), but it will never truly be mindblowing. For that to happen, all of you needs to be engaged - not just your genitalia.

And I say this as someone who has been where you are - and thought as you think.
[Edited 9/29/08 7:57am]


So having a companion is what makes sex spiritual? On what grounds?

No, I don't think sex is purely physical. Good sex -hell, even bad sex -engages the mind as well as the body. I have had mindblowing sex, thanks. I love how you seem to think the mind and some ether we call spirituality are the same thing, and assume that since I don't see spirituality in sex that I'm simply bumpin' uglies. If all sex was was physical gratification, why ever bother with a partner at all? Your argument is full of holes.

And don't call me, honey. Oddly enough, knowing you think you have a more enlightened view of sex than I makes that endearment come off as more sour than sweet. confused


Good Lord. rolleyes

It is you who has continually and repeatedly (in this thread and others) talked about sex as merely being a physical activity - comparing it to something as base as taking a shit.

If you want to stake out a position, at least be consistent. You're talking out both sides of your face.
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #106 posted 09/30/08 12:23pm

dseann

meow85 said:

Simply put, why?

I don't mean when a person is celibate and it wasn't their idea. Circumstance can certainly enforce celibacy on just about anyone.

But purposeful, deliberate celibacy. What for? Sex is one of the healthiest, most natural acts a being can engage in.

I've heard of athletes and performers who practice celibacy before an important game or show, in the belief that they're saving up their energy, but there's no science behind that. There's never been any evidence that not abstaining drains energy away from other faculties.

Religious reasons also baffle me. The idea that sex is somehow more sacred than any other bodily function doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Given that the concept of virginity is entirely abstract, a person is neither losing or giving anything away by engaging in coitus.


So, how come? What for?



Some people just like to be different. Some girls are giving in to parental pressures for outdated ideals. Some haven't tried it and are scared while others have had bad experiences and are trying to heal emotionally before jumping into bed again.

The religious fanatics anger me. I went to a Catholic high school and those fuckers are warped. They have priests who haven't had sex in their entire lives (heterosexual sex that is) or haven't had sex for decades who think they are qualified to counsel others on sex. They are fucking crazy. Even their bible said "God said to be fruitful and multiply" ... I don't think God was talking about math.

Give up the drawers ladies and men, please act like men and drop yours. Without the act of fucking, none of us would be here to post on the org.

lol
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #107 posted 09/30/08 12:28pm

meow85

avatar

Genesia said:

meow85 said:



So having a companion is what makes sex spiritual? On what grounds?

No, I don't think sex is purely physical. Good sex -hell, even bad sex -engages the mind as well as the body. I have had mindblowing sex, thanks. I love how you seem to think the mind and some ether we call spirituality are the same thing, and assume that since I don't see spirituality in sex that I'm simply bumpin' uglies. If all sex was was physical gratification, why ever bother with a partner at all? Your argument is full of holes.

And don't call me, honey. Oddly enough, knowing you think you have a more enlightened view of sex than I makes that endearment come off as more sour than sweet. confused


Good Lord. rolleyes

It is you who has continually and repeatedly (in this thread and others) talked about sex as merely being a physical activity - comparing it to something as base as taking a shit.

If you want to stake out a position, at least be consistent. You're talking out both sides of your face.


You seem to be confusing mental and spiritual. I never said sex was purely physical -it engages the mind just as much as, if not more, than the body. But your brain is not your soul.

Sex is base. It's part of what makes us animals.

I have a question for you. If sex is such a heightened, spiritual event for us, then is it for other species?
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #108 posted 09/30/08 12:34pm

Genesia

avatar

meow85 said:

Genesia said:



Good Lord. rolleyes

It is you who has continually and repeatedly (in this thread and others) talked about sex as merely being a physical activity - comparing it to something as base as taking a shit.

If you want to stake out a position, at least be consistent. You're talking out both sides of your face.


You seem to be confusing mental and spiritual. I never said sex was purely physical -it engages the mind just as much as, if not more, than the body. But your brain is not your soul.

Sex is base. It's part of what makes us animals.

I have a question for you. If sex is such a heightened, spiritual event for us, then is it for other species?


No, it isn't.

I believe human beings are more than mere animals. We are able to control our instincts and act on the basis of reason and intellect. Animals are not.

If you have no problem thinking of yourself as nothing more than an animal, that's up to you.
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #109 posted 09/30/08 12:54pm

NDRU

avatar

meow85 said:

Genesia said:



Good Lord. rolleyes

It is you who has continually and repeatedly (in this thread and others) talked about sex as merely being a physical activity - comparing it to something as base as taking a shit.

If you want to stake out a position, at least be consistent. You're talking out both sides of your face.


You seem to be confusing mental and spiritual. I never said sex was purely physical -it engages the mind just as much as, if not more, than the body. But your brain is not your soul.

Sex is base. It's part of what makes us animals.

I have a question for you. If sex is such a heightened, spiritual event for us, then is it for other species?


but humans treat sex kind of differently than animals. For us it's an event, something we dress up and celebrate and do just for fun. We do it out of instinctive drives, yes, but we also plan it and use it to be closer to one another--or on the flip side, to use & degrade one another. We don't only do it when women are in heat, or at a certain time of the year/month.

I don't argue that sex is either spiritual or base, but just that we treat it a little differently than animals because of our developed consciousness.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #110 posted 09/30/08 4:55pm

ZombieKitten

meow85 said:

in the belief that they're saving up their energy

mainly the south americans, right?

I should NEVER have married a south american doh!
he is obviously saving up his energy for something confused
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #111 posted 09/30/08 4:58pm

Amaxx

ZombieKitten said:

meow85 said:

in the belief that they're saving up their energy

mainly the south americans, right?

I should NEVER have married a south american doh!
he is obviously saving up his energy for something confused

I was hoping U'd post! U'd back me up on the "Celibacy isn't a choice when it's thrust upon you" argument!nod
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #112 posted 09/30/08 5:02pm

ZombieKitten

Amaxx said:

ZombieKitten said:


mainly the south americans, right?

I should NEVER have married a south american doh!
he is obviously saving up his energy for something confused

I was hoping U'd post! U'd back me up on the "Celibacy isn't a choice when it's thrust upon you" argument!nod


stop that mad
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #113 posted 09/30/08 5:29pm

Amaxx

ZombieKitten said:

Amaxx said:


I was hoping U'd post! U'd back me up on the "Celibacy isn't a choice when it's thrust upon you" argument!nod


stop that mad

What I do????confuse
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #114 posted 09/30/08 11:48pm

meow85

avatar

NDRU said:

meow85 said:



You seem to be confusing mental and spiritual. I never said sex was purely physical -it engages the mind just as much as, if not more, than the body. But your brain is not your soul.

Sex is base. It's part of what makes us animals.

I have a question for you. If sex is such a heightened, spiritual event for us, then is it for other species?


but humans treat sex kind of differently than animals. For us it's an event, something we dress up and celebrate and do just for fun. We do it out of instinctive drives, yes, but we also plan it and use it to be closer to one another--or on the flip side, to use & degrade one another. We don't only do it when women are in heat, or at a certain time of the year/month.

I don't argue that sex is either spiritual or base, but just that we treat it a little differently than animals because of our developed consciousness.


A lot of animals use sex as a way to bond too, and there are species besides humans that have sex merely for fun and not just procreation.

And there's been more and more evidence that humans actually do have something of a mating season. Studies on sexuality have shown that hetero women tend to actively go after or initiate sex more during times of their cycle most likely to result in pregnancy, and it's been statistically shown that more babies are born during the spring and autumn than winter or summer, suggesting something of a mating season. So our mating schedule isn't set in stone as many other species are, but we seem to have one too.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #115 posted 09/30/08 11:50pm

meow85

avatar

Genesia said:

meow85 said:



You seem to be confusing mental and spiritual. I never said sex was purely physical -it engages the mind just as much as, if not more, than the body. But your brain is not your soul.

Sex is base. It's part of what makes us animals.

I have a question for you. If sex is such a heightened, spiritual event for us, then is it for other species?


No, it isn't.

I believe human beings are more than mere animals. We are able to control our instincts and act on the basis of reason and intellect. Animals are not.

If you have no problem thinking of yourself as nothing more than an animal, that's up to you.



Humans ARE animals. More cognitive development than other species, for sure. But we're just mammals. On what basis are you arguing we're another subset of species? That's a pretty big claim, and one that's going to need something to back it up to have any validity.
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #116 posted 10/01/08 4:42am

Genesia

avatar

meow85 said:

Genesia said:



No, it isn't.

I believe human beings are more than mere animals. We are able to control our instincts and act on the basis of reason and intellect. Animals are not.

If you have no problem thinking of yourself as nothing more than an animal, that's up to you.



Humans ARE animals. More cognitive development than other species, for sure. But we're just mammals. On what basis are you arguing we're another subset of species? That's a pretty big claim, and one that's going to need something to back it up to have any validity.


I didn't say human beings were "another subset of species" - a phrase that makes absolutely no sense by the way. Human beings are a separate and distinct subspecies - Homo sapiens sapiens.

I know human beings are mammals. (Every fourth-grader knows that.) But I think we have a little more going for us than warm blood, hair and an ability to bear live young. rolleyes

If you want to put yourself on the same level with a warthog or a hyena or what have you, by all means, do. I think your ability to reason is about on a par with theirs, so it isn't that far-fetched.

I will confine my dealings to people who believe they are more than the sum of their baser instincts and desires.
[Edited 10/1/08 5:21am]
We don’t mourn artists because we knew them. We mourn them because they helped us know ourselves.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #117 posted 10/01/08 9:53am

morningsong

eek
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #118 posted 10/01/08 12:40pm

meow85

avatar

Genesia said:

meow85 said:




Humans ARE animals. More cognitive development than other species, for sure. But we're just mammals. On what basis are you arguing we're another subset of species? That's a pretty big claim, and one that's going to need something to back it up to have any validity.


I didn't say human beings were "another subset of species" - a phrase that makes absolutely no sense by the way. Human beings are a separate and distinct subspecies - Homo sapiens sapiens.

I know human beings are mammals. (Every fourth-grader knows that.) But I think we have a little more going for us than warm blood, hair and an ability to bear live young. rolleyes

If you want to put yourself on the same level with a warthog or a hyena or what have you, by all means, do. I think your ability to reason is about on a par with theirs, so it isn't that far-fetched.

I will confine my dealings to people who believe they are more than the sum of their baser instincts and desires.
[Edited 10/1/08 5:21am]



But on what basis are you claiming humans are different than other animals? That we're more than just instincts? Of course we are. So are several species. That we engage the higher faculties in thought? Again, that isn't exclusive to us, in spite of what we used to believe. We now know thought and deductive reasoning are traits shared among many species.

I think your reason is based on the fallacy of human uniqueness, something evolutionary scientists and especially not you have been able to prove. Cute how I'm the one with the inability to reason, yet you're the one whose consistently been unable to back up your claims, has deliberately confused two seperate things (mind and soul), accused me of an inability to understand spirituality because I am not a strict theist, and resorted to saying I'm no more intelligent than a hyena. Meanwhile I'M the one being complained about for a lack of humility...
"A Watcher scoffs at gravity!"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 4 of 4 <1234
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > General Discussion > Celibacy