Cast your vote and make your case!

Natalie Portman's genius IQ edges out Keira's accent.

When I first saw the photos I thought they were the same person.

Natalie is much better.

jerseykrs said:

While Nat's no dumb bunny, I don't know if I'd put her in the "genius" category.

applekisses said:

So did I.

Keira looked hot with a buzzed haircut.

applekisses said:

Ace said:

Neither one of them screams "sex" to me. But I was turned on by that photo that someone snapped up Keira's dress.

So Keira.

Keira seems to be still finding her acting feet whereas Natalie is a pro, i like them both but I'm going to pick Natalie.

Ace said:

Keira Knightly is much hotter. She looked amazing in the last Pirates Movie. She would be perfect if she had bigger boobies. Natalie is too boyish looking. She has the body of a teenage boy. Kiera has a better personality than Natalie as well. Natalie is not very nice and she always comes across like an idiot in talk show interviews.

FunkMistress said:

Yeah, I know: neither particularly gives off an extreme sex vibe, but I just thought "sexy-off" was a better title than "more-appealing-off".

And this photo you speak of... If one were interested in that sort of thing, where might one find that? I'm asking for a friend, of course.

I like Kate Beckinsale better than those two. Shes my top pick!

Neither is what I would call "sexy", but I guess I would choose Keira because I find Natalie has a certain awkwardness about her.

Both are very pretty, though.

LleeLlee said:

No, no, NO! You're not playing by the rules! Get your bitch outta here! She can take part in your own sexy-off!

I like Natalie's eyebrows
Nat's prettier

Ace said:

I can't remember where I saw it!

natalie's snl rap was awesome
so that's my vote

Keira's lips are always just like that.

emmi said:

Like what?

Natalie, not even close, though Kiera has a few inches in her favor.
[Edited 10/3/06 11:02am]

emm said:

"When I was at Harvard, I smoked weed every day / I cheated every test and I snorted all the yay"

lilgish said:

Ace said:

Ace said:

Ace said:

Natalie has the smarts. Better Face. Kiera, while pretty, doesn't have great teeth. Natalie has a much better smile. Natalie also can rock different hair styles.

Natalie is the better actor, probably has better connections, more money, if that's your thing...

It's a wash on the breat, though natalie is a little fuller. Kiera only wins on height.
[Edited 10/3/06 11:11am]

Ace said:

I HATE Keira. It looks like she eating her face when she talks. Natalie all the way.

CarrieLee said:

Natalie all the way. She was the hottest in "Closer"

natalie!!!!!

oh! and because natalie is smart,beautiful & a great actress
[Edited 10/3/06 11:52am]

kinda leaning toward kiera. she seems to have an edge to her.

Keira's too skinny for me, and her personality kind of puts me off.

Natalie is beautiful.

NATALIE!!!!!





I personally can't stand Keira.

they're both okay, but Natalie for me!