Ace - it was just okay. Very pitchy.

Kellie - it was a mess and the lighting was scary.


Updates to come.


M

Ace was alright...

i really liked kelly's tonight...but, damn that girl is not so bright


i really enjoyed Chris and Taylor...

Chris totally rocked. I loved the eyeliner!!!! He's beautiful.


I'm doing this in real time I'm on the West Coast.


M

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

ahhhhh, ok then, i'll be quiet now

nakedpianoplayer said:

I didn't mean that baby!! I can't wait to see Taylor.



M

ok, but, i did like chris' look this week... the eyeliner at first looked a bit strange, but with the new facial hair it was lookin pretty damn hot i must say

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

i just dont wanna spoil anything for ya


and i LOVE Taylor he makes me smile...

Katharine was pretty good. I love her and want her to win, but she was just okay.


M

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

she was the one in the red shirt, right ?


i thought she did really well.. not sure what else she could have done being that a loud 'rock' song would be HORRIBLE for her...

I want to marry Elliott. I know he's SEXY UGLY to me. And the boy can sing. He did pretty well. The ending was awesome!!


M

Taylor was incredible!!!!! He rocked. THE BEST TONIGHT!!!!!Woo hoo!!!!!

woo hoo edit!
m
[Edited 4/11/06 20:51pm]

Paris was really really good. She looked like a woman tonight. Go ahead girl.


M

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

i spit my beer out when he almost busted his ass trying to kick that mic stand over (yaay, live tv)..that being said-i think it's SO LONG ACE TONITE! (although i'm still seething that kellie and bucky are still on and not mandisa )

meltwithu said:

I feel u! Mandisa should've stayed(regardless of the controversy). Yeah, I think Ace is out of there. Poor Kellie, she's so dumb.
We'll see what happens tonight.

M

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

Controversy? Can somebody clue me in on the controversy surrounding Mandisa? I was upset too that she was kicked off the show. As long as Chris stays on, I'll continue to watch American Idol, but if he goes, I'm not watching anymore.

meltwithu said:

Me too, can't stand that Bucky kid, he just annoys me.

loved Elliotts performance and Taylor amuses the hell outta me. Chris is as hot as balls.

psychodelicide said:

I tried to summarize, but just click here i'm lazy

http://www.advocate.com/n...d28426.asp

and a follow-up interview:

http://www.advocate.com/e...d29157.asp

whle it's not clear cut that she's anti-gay, she's close enough that she won't be seeing any of my money if she finds a career after this show.

Chris was HAWT last nite even if I wasn't 100% loving his performance.

Elliot was my fave. He picked a GREAT Queen song,the hardest of the night and did a damn good job. I LOVED it.

Paris- although she sang very well, the whole thing was weird to me. I didn't really like her JanetJacksonBlackCat style. I didn't hate it, it was just weird. I think she's in big trouble though. While I appreciate he constant changes of style (both fashion and musically) I think she may fail to draw a huge support base due to the constant change. WHile she's almost always GREAT, she hasn't carved out a definable persona. Works for me, but I'm afriad it won't work for "america"

Ace and Bucky sucked. One of them needs to go.

if Paris goes tonight, then there is no need for to finish watching the damn thing...

nakedpianoplayer said:

"Whaddya mayn own payper?"

NDRU said:

That was the final thing to convince me it's almost all an act. She's not THAT stupid.

catherine is dreamy


ace is a disaster


kellie needs to go

i dont mean to be ruuddeee!

I lovvvvveeeee QUuuuuueeeeennnn!
I Loooooveeeee FFFFFfffffrrrrreeeeedddddiiiiieeeee MMMMMeeeeerrrrrcccccuuuuurrrrryyyyy sooooo muccccchhhhh it's scary.

So who got kicked off???

buhbye Bucky!



I really want Ace to go next.

endorphin74 said:

My sentiments exactly. He's outworn his prettyness.


m

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

I'm starting to like Bucky more than Ace.

NDRU said:

Simon: It was a very ballsey performance

Kelly: "whussa bawlsay"?




-ding dong.....

-"nobodys home."

clarification edit
[Edited 4/13/06 11:36am]
[Edited 4/13/06 11:38am]