Okay,

they found out that Scott Savol had a misdemeanor charge for assaulting his baby-mama. American Idol is not kicking him off.

When they found out that Frenchie, on a previous American Idol season, had posed nude on a web site she got kicked out.

I DON'T THINK THAT'S FAIR AT ALL.

Scott's da bomd, he's better then all those uys. I like the dude wit da dreads, forgot his name and Nadia, they are the only good ones. But Scott should win the IDOL. Anyway, back to topic, I don't think it's fair either, but he should stay in my eyes
[Edited 4/1/05 19:48pm]

didn't they have a scandal every single season?

I never have and never will watch this crappy ass show. It's a glorified kareoke hour.

Whatever happened to Frenchie? Thats who Burger King shoulda got to do their new ads, not Darius Rucker. Anyone agree?

Tish4 said:

seriously ??? scott ???? the heavyset white guy ?????

we would have a blast watching american idol together, cuz in my house we all agree hes gotta be the next to go

the one with the dreads, thats anwar... and i love him but, thats maybe because hes so damn sexy he can sing yes, and hes sweet as hell (so it seems) but DEAR GOD is he yummy to look at

im also thinking that nikko is really starting to steal the show... his last performances have been FANTASTIC !!! imo, of course.

nadia, love, love, LOVE the hair !!!!! cant say it enough... shes got flair, shes got style, and shes got a great voice however, vonzell i think can far out sing her her voice gives me chills... what an incredible gift

now i have to say, the other one im pullin for is carrie, the little farm girl... shes got a hell of a voice too this season is gonna be tough to judge, there are a lot of great ones on there only time will tell, but, i wish them all *including scott * the best of luck, and i hope they all continue with their dreams.....

that being said, my final three picks will be ----

anwar, vonzell, and nikko

i cant guess the winner yet... its too close, but, i believe it will be one of these

He told producers ahead of time. Frenchie didn't

nakedpianoplayer said:

You really think Scott is white?

Janfriend said:

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/

i thought he was

maybe im wrong..

Why should did it even mattered if Frenchie posed nude? That shouldnt even have counted.

She did that earn money when she was college. Thats a good reason cause alot of college students can't even be bothered with having a real part-time job due to their studying.

Has anyone noticed how strange Paula has been acting. Paula has been slurring her words in the past two episodes. THAT GIRL IS HIGH!!!!!

i dont know but did anyone see fantasia on there last night ??? i truely cried... honestly, i had tears running down my face when she was done !! that girl can sing her ass off and i love her story.. single mom, made it big, you know..

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

High as a KITE!!! We've been laughing at this for weeks too. At first we thought it was too much Captain in her Coke, but now we're leaning towards pain killers. It's the glassy, droopy eyes.

As for the Frinchie/Scott thing - it's LAME LAME LAME!! Who cares who told producers ahead of time?? To send millions of teenage americans the message that its not ok to strip to pay for college but it IS ok to abuse the mother of your child is SO messed up I can't even begin to fathom their ideology here.

and in other news. I'm pissed at America. Nikko was one of my favorites. Scott, Anthony and Anwar ALL deserved to go home before he did. harrumph.

CarrieMpls said:

yeah, i was pretty pissed to see Nikko go too scott or anthony i thought would be the first outta there - and that one rocker dude, i really cant STAND him i do love me some anwar though but, again, that may be because hes just so damn beautiful to look at

now, im down to anwar and vonzell.... those are my picks i would love to see anwar take it all the way, but vonzell can sing her ASS off - so, i think shes gonna go all the way this year....

carrie's great too though, they have some great folks up there this year, but, im sticking with my picks

I was surprised Nikko got the boot last night...
my husband and I have been laughing for a few weeks saying paulas's drunk! she really does seem like she's on something.
I like Nadia! she's got it! but farm girl really can sing and so can vonzell but...she's kinda boring to me I'm surprised the rockers are still in it although they do tend to surprise me with their performances too...

nakedpianoplayer said:

when vonzell did that whitney tune a couple a weeks ago....phew! I nearly fell outta my chair!

seriously, i dont think Nikko deserved to go home, he had the look and the attitude

But i dont know about the Scott thing, but isnt there more facts to the story, like shes wasnt the one that pressed charges, or somethign like that, I dont know all the facts, so Im not sure.. but didnt he pull a Naomi Campbell or something


Im thinking Bo is going to go pretty far, simon really seems to like him
[Edited 4/7/05 9:12am]

CarrieMpls said:

I don't think I have ever agreed to someone's post in its entirety.

AMEN!!!!!

The pain killers have to be from HER hit-and-run tour. heeheeee!!

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

...Paula has been straight fucked up lately..whatever she's doin', she doesn't hide it well...

Shorty said:

in a good way, right ?

cuz, that was INCREDIBLE !

nakedpianoplayer said:

yes in a good way!

OnionJuice said:

I guess a criminal record of domestic assault is better than posing nude.




twisted

It's very twisted. I was mad to see Nikko get booted. He was way better than Anthony and Scott bores me and he should have been gone. I'm getting fed up with this show. The wrong people are getting ahead and it just irks me to no end.

Shorty said:

MIGUELGOMEZ said:

I agree. There is also a thread in the music section about this and the fact that another guy had a want ad looking for a guy on BlackPlanetLove.com. I think Frenchie should have stayed as well. What they allow and don't is absurd.

does anyone know why they arent having guest judges this season ???

and WHO picks these horrible themes that they have to sing ???

i say, let them choose their own, and have their own style, thats what its all about right ?? so, why restrict them ?? i wanna see if set free at this stage of the game what they would do

nakedpianoplayer said:

In the second season Simon got really pissy about the quest judges (although they came back in the third...including a favorite of mine, Donna Summer, although I didn't see her judging but saw her perform the next day). I guess they are going to try and do it without them and see what happens. If ratings slip (and apprently they aren't so far) they won't do that anymore. I find myself watching it every so often if I'm not busy. There is just nothing else on!