Hi guys, just wondered if anyone had stayed in any of these hotels in NYC-the Carter and the Mount Royal. I dont want to stay there but just curious to know who has or if you know of them. Thanks.

Nope, not those ones.

I trust Trip Advisor because the reviews are not edited out when they are bad like on some other sites. I have had very good luck finding hotels based on reviews. I personally recommend the Comfort Inn in Midtown if you are looking for a decent clean room in the midtown area for a reasonable (NYC reasonable) rate.

Here is the Carter (the reviews aren't great):

http://www.tripadvisor.co..._York.html

Trip advisor didn't have a listing for Mount Royal which is odd because they have had every hotel I've ever checked. Hmmmmm....

Check out the Comfort Inn reviews.

http://www.tripadvisor.co..._York.html

Paramount and Hudson Hotels but bedrooms are tiny!

Or Murray Hill Hotel on Lexington Ave is pretty good too.

W Times Square Hotel

Get a corner room on a high floor and it's superb.....and that's even without the waitresses in their miniscule skirts

REDBABY said:

Hudson rocks!! and not all the rooms are tiny... just the econo priced ones

sosgemini said:

Its still fab!!!

lovemachine said:

I'm not surprised the Mount Royal was listed! I'd be really interested to here from those who have stayed at it though or the Carter.

JDINTERACTIVE said:

Is it actually a hotel or a MOTEL??

REDBABY said:

oh fuck yeah...u walk in and you feel like a rock star.....you know, i decorated my bedroom to look like their rooms....i gotta post a pic so you can tell me if i pulled it off or not..

JDINTERACTIVE said:

Not those ones bruv, but I checked out loads before I went over last year.

Let us what sort you're after and I'll see if I can dig up me old notes

senik said:

Well, I'm not so much after a hotel but just interested to here the stories really. I know their reputation and well, quite frankly I'm not surprised that nobody has heard of them thus far. I'll wait for say, another 10 responses and if nobody has stayed at either/or I will reveal what I've heard.

JDINTERACTIVE said:

1...

sosgemini said:

REDBABY said:

Just 2 more responses before all is revealed

Intriguing.

Mildly.

REDBABY said:

why is that crazy? those rooms are beautiful....

REDBABY said:

Umm when are YOU finally making it here so we can finally go and have some ?????

BabyCakes said:

You know what? MY ppl at work are going on Wednesday.. except I am not going.. they are going for a week to shop for shoes.. all paid for by work.. I really hope to come this year.. I have a friend who has been working in NY for 15 months and is due to come back to the UK soon.. so I definitely want to go before she leaves..

senik said:

No, well I'd still love to here some experiences first! No cheating Senik!

JDINTERACTIVE said: