independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > General Discussion > Episode III title announced!
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 4 of 6 <123456>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #90 posted 07/29/04 7:49am

BorisFishpaw

avatar

Here's the new 'orange' look Star Wars logo that will be gracing Episode III
merchandise in the new year (they've dispensed with the 'metallic' look from
the previous movies, and gone with a more 'comic book' vibe)

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #91 posted 07/29/04 12:20pm

teller

avatar

JediMaster said:

Marrk said:



His organic part is ysalamari i've heard (a creature that repels the force. also saps the force from Jedi when in close proximity)


Oh wow! That I didn't know! That would make sense (although I've never been a fan of the ysalamari. If The Force emenates from life, then how could a living creature "repel" it? I always thought this was one of the dumber ideas from the Zahn books. Maybe they are just able to block the user's access to the Force?).

Still, its cool that there is an explanation.

Wait a minute...if he's part ysalamiri, then how can he be a Sith at all? Wouldn't he jam the force from himself? hmm

Oh, and I thought the Zahn books were horrible.
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #92 posted 07/29/04 12:35pm

JediMaster

avatar

teller said:

JediMaster said:



Oh wow! That I didn't know! That would make sense (although I've never been a fan of the ysalamari. If The Force emenates from life, then how could a living creature "repel" it? I always thought this was one of the dumber ideas from the Zahn books. Maybe they are just able to block the user's access to the Force?).

Still, its cool that there is an explanation.

Wait a minute...if he's part ysalamiri, then how can he be a Sith at all? Wouldn't he jam the force from himself? hmm

Grievous isn't a Sith. He's a cybernetic/organic hybrid, created to lead the droid army for Dooku. His main design is the execution of Jedi


Oh, and I thought the Zahn books were horrible.

Totally agree! I think they are INCREDIBLY overrated. About the only thing I like about them is that they introduced the character of Mara Jade. I really think the only reason they got the attention they did was due to the fact that they were the first foray back into the SW universe in many years. Fan boys and girls latched on, simply because they had been craving new SW stories so bad.




jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #93 posted 07/29/04 12:46pm

teller

avatar

JediMaster said:

Grievous isn't a Sith. He's a cybernetic/organic hybrid, created to lead the droid army for Dooku. His main design is the execution of Jedi

Oooooh...heh...I just assumed, ya know...because of the lightsabers and all...redface


JediMaster said:

teller said

Oh, and I thought the Zahn books were horrible.


Totally agree! I think they are INCREDIBLY overrated. About the only thing I like about them is that they introduced the character of Mara Jade. I really think the only reason they got the attention they did was due to the fact that they were the first foray back into the SW universe in many years. Fan boys and girls latched on, simply because they had been craving new SW stories so bad.

Glad I'm not the only one...man, they were just flat-out boring. It felt like the author wasn't really a fan. I didn't read much after that--only the Jedi Academy trilogy, which I thought was OK. At that point I decided that the books were all over the place, just stuff made up by various authors and presumably approved by Lucas--but not really canonical.
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #94 posted 07/29/04 12:55pm

JediMaster

avatar

teller said:

Oooooh...heh...I just assumed, ya know...because of the lightsabers and all...redface

Understandable. In fact, I thought he was a new Sith Lord the first time I saw him. The lightsabers are his trophies he takes from Jedi he slays

Glad I'm not the only one...man, they were just flat-out boring. It felt like the author wasn't really a fan. I didn't read much after that--only the Jedi Academy trilogy, which I thought was OK. At that point I decided that the books were all over the place, just stuff made up by various authors and presumably approved by Lucas--but not really canonical.

Definitely not the only one. I've read most of the books, and Zahn's are actually my least favorite. To me, it seemed like he really didn't get SW at all. It was like really bad fan fiction. (Luke fights a clone, made from his severed hand??? rolleyes Puh-leeze!!!

As for the other novels, I did enjoy the whole New Jedi Order series. I liked that it focused so much on the new generation, and the Yuzhaan Vong were great villians! Only thing I didn't care for was Chewie dying, but I have to admire that they were willing to take out such a beloved character. It showed that all bets were off, and that ANYTHING could happen in the series. All the previous SW novels really didn't hold any suspense for me, since you KNEW they wouldn't kill any of the characters


jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #95 posted 07/29/04 10:47pm

MrJoker

I still like the Zahn books. boxed
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #96 posted 07/29/04 11:58pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

I must admit that I've never read any of the Star Wars books.
So I can't really comment on them, but I do remember George Lucas saying only things
that happened in the movies are considered strictly cannon, and everything else is up
for revision if he feels it's nesessary. I did hear a rumor that he's finally allowed the go
ahead on a series of books that will be set in what would have been Episodes 7-9's
timeframe. So I guess that means that the final trilogy is a definite NO (shame, I can
but dream though).
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #97 posted 07/30/04 1:56am

teller

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

I must admit that I've never read any of the Star Wars books.
So I can't really comment on them, but I do remember George Lucas saying only things
that happened in the movies are considered strictly cannon, and everything else is up
for revision if he feels it's nesessary. I did hear a rumor that he's finally allowed the go
ahead on a series of books that will be set in what would have been Episodes 7-9's
timeframe. So I guess that means that the final trilogy is a definite NO (shame, I can
but dream though).

He said the movies were canonical, the radio show was 2nd most canonical, and the books were somewhere in 3rd place or so... hmmm

Those radio shows were kick ass, btw. nod
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #98 posted 07/30/04 2:05am

Natsume

avatar

you guys should ask that this thread be made into a sticky



mr.green
I mean, like, where is the sun?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #99 posted 07/30/04 2:09am

teller

avatar

Natsume said:

you guys should ask that this thread be made into a sticky



mr.green

Man...it'll be next summer before we stop jerking off all over ourselves! lol
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #100 posted 07/30/04 2:19am

MrJoker

BorisFishpaw said:

I must admit that I've never read any of the Star Wars books. So I can't really comment on them, but I do remember George Lucas saying only things that happened in the movies are considered strictly cannon, and everything else is up for revision if he feels it's nesessary. I did hear a rumor that he's finally allowed the go ahead on a series of books that will be set in what would have been Episodes 7-9's timeframe. So I guess that means that the final trilogy is a definite NO (shame, I can but dream though).

The series of books referred to is probably what's out there already. Just about everything from Return of the Jedi to 30 years later (NJO: The Unifying Force) has been covered with yet another series of books forthcoming to cover the post-New Jedi Order era.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #101 posted 07/30/04 12:44pm

JediMaster

avatar

teller said:

Natsume said:

you guys should ask that this thread be made into a sticky



mr.green

Man...it'll be next summer before we stop jerking off all over ourselves! lol


Talk about "sticky"!!!!
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #102 posted 07/30/04 12:49pm

JediMaster

avatar

MrJoker said:

BorisFishpaw said:

I must admit that I've never read any of the Star Wars books. So I can't really comment on them, but I do remember George Lucas saying only things that happened in the movies are considered strictly cannon, and everything else is up for revision if he feels it's nesessary. I did hear a rumor that he's finally allowed the go ahead on a series of books that will be set in what would have been Episodes 7-9's timeframe. So I guess that means that the final trilogy is a definite NO (shame, I can but dream though).

The series of books referred to is probably what's out there already. Just about everything from Return of the Jedi to 30 years later (NJO: The Unifying Force) has been covered with yet another series of books forthcoming to cover the post-New Jedi Order era.


Well, suppossedly Episodes VII-IX were going to focus on Jacen and Jaina in their twenties or so, which would place them squarely post-NJO (they were in their late teens during the course of those books). The rumour is that Lucas IS allowing a trilogy of books that would be based on the rough outline he had for the third trilogy.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #103 posted 07/30/04 1:31pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:

MrJoker said:


The series of books referred to is probably what's out there already. Just about everything from Return of the Jedi to 30 years later (NJO: The Unifying Force) has been covered with yet another series of books forthcoming to cover the post-New Jedi Order era.


Well, suppossedly Episodes VII-IX were going to focus on Jacen and Jaina in their twenties or so, which would place them squarely post-NJO (they were in their late teens during the course of those books). The rumour is that Lucas IS allowing a trilogy of books that would be based on the rough outline he had for the third trilogy.


That's what I heard too. Kinda depressing cuz it totally pulls the plug on Episodes VII-IX
ever getting made. Not that there really was much hope of that happening anyway, but
it least it was an outside possibility before.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #104 posted 07/30/04 1:56pm

teller

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

JediMaster said:



Well, suppossedly Episodes VII-IX were going to focus on Jacen and Jaina in their twenties or so, which would place them squarely post-NJO (they were in their late teens during the course of those books). The rumour is that Lucas IS allowing a trilogy of books that would be based on the rough outline he had for the third trilogy.


That's what I heard too. Kinda depressing cuz it totally pulls the plug on Episodes VII-IX
ever getting made. Not that there really was much hope of that happening anyway, but
it least it was an outside possibility before.

Is there no chance that Lucas will eventually pass the baton to someone else?
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #105 posted 07/30/04 2:10pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

teller said:

BorisFishpaw said:



That's what I heard too. Kinda depressing cuz it totally pulls the plug on Episodes VII-IX
ever getting made. Not that there really was much hope of that happening anyway, but
it least it was an outside possibility before.

Is there no chance that Lucas will eventually pass the baton to someone else?


I'm sure I heard him say that he would never let anyone else make a Star Wars movie.

It's a shame, cuz I'd like to have seen Episodes VII-IX on the big screen. If what I heard
about the basic plotline was correct, it would make a great finale to the series. Plus all the
original trilogy actors would be the right age to play their respective characters again
one last time.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #106 posted 07/30/04 2:15pm

teller

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

teller said:


Is there no chance that Lucas will eventually pass the baton to someone else?


I'm sure I heard him say that he would never let anyone else make a Star Wars movie.

It's a shame, cuz I'd like to have seen Episodes VII-IX on the big screen. If what I heard
about the basic plotline was correct, it would make a great finale to the series. Plus all the
original trilogy actors would be the right age to play their respective characters again
one last time.

Well...he could always change his mind after the dust settles and he gets old...especially if one of his children became a filmmaker.
Fear is the mind-killer.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #107 posted 07/30/04 2:33pm

JediMaster

avatar

teller said:

BorisFishpaw said:



I'm sure I heard him say that he would never let anyone else make a Star Wars movie.

It's a shame, cuz I'd like to have seen Episodes VII-IX on the big screen. If what I heard
about the basic plotline was correct, it would make a great finale to the series. Plus all the
original trilogy actors would be the right age to play their respective characters again
one last time.

Well...he could always change his mind after the dust settles and he gets old...especially if one of his children became a filmmaker.


If one of his kids wants to be a filmmaker, then I could completely see it happening. Otherwise I wouldn't count on it. I know his good buddy Speilberg wanted to do one of the prequels, but was pretty much shot down (not that that is a bad thing. All I have to do is watch "AI" or "Minority Report" to know that Steveo can't do Sci-Fi anymore).

As for the novels idea, I have to look at the positive side. If we are DEFINITELY not getting to see those movies, then at least we can read the story and imagine what could have been. Better than nothing, I suppose.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #108 posted 07/30/04 2:35pm

JediMaster

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

teller said:


Is there no chance that Lucas will eventually pass the baton to someone else?


I'm sure I heard him say that he would never let anyone else make a Star Wars movie.

It's a shame, cuz I'd like to have seen Episodes VII-IX on the big screen. If what I heard
about the basic plotline was correct, it would make a great finale to the series.
Plus all the
original trilogy actors would be the right age to play their respective characters again
one last time.


Do share. What did you hear was the plot outline?? I've heard so many rumours over the years, but you seem to get fairly reliable info.
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #109 posted 07/30/04 4:07pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:

BorisFishpaw said:



I'm sure I heard him say that he would never let anyone else make a Star Wars movie.

It's a shame, cuz I'd like to have seen Episodes VII-IX on the big screen. If what I heard
about the basic plotline was correct, it would make a great finale to the series.
Plus all the
original trilogy actors would be the right age to play their respective characters again
one last time.


Do share. What did you hear was the plot outline?? I've heard so many rumours over the years, but you seem to get fairly reliable info.


Well, from what I heard, it centres around the final attempt by the Sith to retake the galaxy.
In a nutshell it's this - After the failure of the Emperor, the true power behind the Sith decides
to reveal himself and finish the job himself: enter Darth Bane...

Now, there should be a 'reveal' in Episode III that ties in with this final trilogy where we learn
that Palpatine is actually the willing host of the spirit of Darth Bane, and Darth Sidious is the
manifestation of this alter-ego. The Emperor as seen in Episode VI is now more Bane than
Palpatine, and is changing physically and becoming more Bane-like (hence the yellow eyes).
(If this is not revealed, then I think that would confirm that Lucas won't make the final trilogy)

Bane's 'real' body (now over 2000 years old) resides in a kind of stasis on the secret Sith
homeworld while his conciousness has been using a series of hosts over the years. To cut a
long story short, Bane now masterminds a plot to overthrough the New Republic by force
(since his attempt to take it over from the inside failed).

Jacen and Jaina Solo become the central heroes in this new battle against evil as they fight
against Darth Bane's new Sith army. We get to see Han and Leia as figureheads of the New
Republic organising the galaxy's defense, while the action centers around Jacen and Jaina.
During this time, Luke Skywalker has gone 'walkabout' (in search of the truth), and when he
reappears (I think in Episode VIII), he's discovered that he's actually a descendant of Bane,
and that's why his family are so strong in the force.

Bane has a plan to turn the Force itself to his own ends (I don't know exactly how), and it's
up to Jacen, Jaina and Luke to find the Sith homeworld and thwart Bane once and for all,
returning balance to the Force forever.

Of course there's a lot more to it than that, but my info is a bit hazy (and sometimes
contradictory) about exactly 'how' it's all resolved. There's also a few twists along the way,
and a bit more history about why the Sith want 'Revenge' (apparently they were persecuted
in the early days by Jedi 'Crusades' for some of their beliefs, and driven to the Darkside,
whereas originally they were a balance of Light and Dark... or something like that). The
revelation of this knowledge almost turns Luke to the Darkside at one point.
[This message was edited Fri Jul 30 9:08:16 2004 by BorisFishpaw]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #110 posted 07/30/04 4:59pm

JediMaster

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

Well, from what I heard, it centres around the final attempt by the Sith to retake the galaxy.
In a nutshell it's this - After the failure of the Emperor, the true power behind the Sith decides
to reveal himself and finish the job himself: enter Darth Bane...

Now, there should be a 'reveal' in Episode III that ties in with this final trilogy where we learn
that Palpatine is actually the willing host of the spirit of Darth Bane, and Darth Sidious is the
manifestation of this alter-ego. The Emperor as seen in Episode VI is now more Bane than
Palpatine, and is changing physically and becoming more Bane-like (hence the yellow eyes).
(If this is not revealed, then I think that would confirm that Lucas won't make the final trilogy)

Bane's 'real' body (now over 2000 years old) resides in a kind of stasis on the secret Sith
homeworld while his conciousness has been using a series of hosts over the years. To cut a
long story short, Bane now masterminds a plot to overthrough the New Republic by force
(since his attempt to take it over from the inside failed).

Jacen and Jaina Solo become the central heroes in this new battle against evil as they fight
against Darth Bane's new Sith army. We get to see Han and Leia as figureheads of the New
Republic organising the galaxy's defense, while the action centers around Jacen and Jaina.
During this time, Luke Skywalker has gone 'walkabout' (in search of the truth), and when he
reappears (I think in Episode VIII), he's discovered that he's actually a descendant of Bane,
and that's why his family are so strong in the force.

Bane has a plan to turn the Force itself to his own ends (I don't know exactly how), and it's
up to Jacen, Jaina and Luke to find the Sith homeworld and thwart Bane once and for all,
returning balance to the Force forever.

Of course there's a lot more to it than that, but my info is a bit hazy (and sometimes
contradictory) about exactly 'how' it's all resolved. There's also a few twists along the way,
and a bit more history about why the Sith want 'Revenge' (apparently they were persecuted
in the early days by Jedi 'Crusades' for some of their beliefs, and driven to the Darkside,
whereas originally they were a balance of Light and Dark... or something like that). The
revelation of this knowledge almost turns Luke to the Darkside at one point.
[This message was edited Fri Jul 30 9:08:16 2004 by BorisFishpaw]



Interesting. Some of it makes sense, and some doesn't. Much of this jives with Expanded Universe continuity, while other details not so much. Jacen and Jaina are there, but where are Mara Jade and Ben Skywalker? I'm doubtful that Lucas would use some major elements, while completely ignoring others. Its true that he has done some of that in the past, namely using Coruscant from the novels, but ignoring all the various Boba Fett origins. The latter isn't all that big of a deal, since there were so many contradictions about this (and they did a brilliant job of explaining this away in the novels, stating that the different origins were stories that Fett had spread to add to his reputation). Still, would he ignore a fan favorite character like Mara?? Would he erase their child? If this is made into novels, I highly doubt it. Most likely, the author would wind up incorporating all those details into Lucas's story.

As for the Darth Bane bit, this is quite intriguing. Is what he tells Luke just a deception, or were the Sith actually persecuted? If the latter is correct, then so much of the established history of the SW Universe is actually false. Established continuity states that the Sith were once Jedi. At one point, a group of Jedi who believed that The Force should be used for personal gain split off to form the Order Of The Sith. They battled the Jedi for control over the galaxy for centuries. This culminated in the Sith War, roughly 1000 years prior to Episode I. This last stand of the Sith was led by Darth Bane, who attempted to unite the various factions of his order against the Jedi. Infighting and backstabbing amongst the Sith led to their defeat. Darth Bane, the sole survivor of The Sith, then declared that only two Sith would exist at a time: a master and an apprentice. While the Jedi ran afoul of Bane once or twice thereafter (thus explaining how Yoda knew of the "two at a time" rule), for the most part he went underground. From that point on, the Dark Lords would plot their revenge in secret, leading the Jedi to believe that The Sith were now extinct.

Now, it could be that Bane and the Sith BELIEVE that they were persecuted for their belief in the Dark Side, but I tend to think this would be a manipulitive ploy to lure Luke away from the Jedi Order he had resurrected. Is Bane his ancestor? Very intriguing if so, and the implications for the Skywalker and Solo clans are pretty staggering (since Jacen and Jaina would also be decendants of Bane!!!)

Thanks for the info, Boris!!! Love to speculate on this kind of stuff!!!
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #111 posted 07/30/04 10:02pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:


Interesting. Some of it makes sense, and some doesn't. Much of this jives with Expanded Universe continuity, while other details not so much. Jacen and Jaina are there, but where are Mara Jade and Ben Skywalker? I'm doubtful that Lucas would use some major elements, while completely ignoring others. Its true that he has done some of that in the past, namely using Coruscant from the novels, but ignoring all the various Boba Fett origins. The latter isn't all that big of a deal, since there were so many contradictions about this (and they did a brilliant job of explaining this away in the novels, stating that the different origins were stories that Fett had spread to add to his reputation). Still, would he ignore a fan favorite character like Mara?? Would he erase their child? If this is made into novels, I highly doubt it. Most likely, the author would wind up incorporating all those details into Lucas's story.

As for the Darth Bane bit, this is quite intriguing. Is what he tells Luke just a deception, or were the Sith actually persecuted? If the latter is correct, then so much of the established history of the SW Universe is actually false. Established continuity states that the Sith were once Jedi. At one point, a group of Jedi who believed that The Force should be used for personal gain split off to form the Order Of The Sith. They battled the Jedi for control over the galaxy for centuries. This culminated in the Sith War, roughly 1000 years prior to Episode I. This last stand of the Sith was led by Darth Bane, who attempted to unite the various factions of his order against the Jedi. Infighting and backstabbing amongst the Sith led to their defeat. Darth Bane, the sole survivor of The Sith, then declared that only two Sith would exist at a time: a master and an apprentice. While the Jedi ran afoul of Bane once or twice thereafter (thus explaining how Yoda knew of the "two at a time" rule), for the most part he went underground. From that point on, the Dark Lords would plot their revenge in secret, leading the Jedi to believe that The Sith were now extinct.

Now, it could be that Bane and the Sith BELIEVE that they were persecuted for their belief in the Dark Side, but I tend to think this would be a manipulitive ploy to lure Luke away from the Jedi Order he had resurrected. Is Bane his ancestor? Very intriguing if so, and the implications for the Skywalker and Solo clans are pretty staggering (since Jacen and Jaina would also be decendants of Bane!!!)

Thanks for the info, Boris!!! Love to speculate on this kind of stuff!!!


I'm pretty sure my info dates from way back (probably before most of the expanded universe
stuff had been written), as there's no mention of Mara Jade, or Luke having any offspring.
There's also no mention of Anakin Solo either. Though interestingly, Bane's main hench'man'
in the final trilogy is a female Sith who I'm pretty sure was called Darth Jade, and who wielded
2 lightsabers (very much like the Sith Witch in the Clone Wars cartoon). And the initial plot
in Episode VII was with her leading the new Sith assault with an alien army of allies from
some of the outer rim worlds. This was possible because of rampant discimination and
racism against non-human aliens in the days of the Empire, causing a lot of the outlying
alien worlds to harbour understandable bad feeling towards the richer human dominated
central planets (a situation which of course was engineered by Bane in the first place).

I do remember hearing George Lucas himself say in an interview a loooong time ago
(sometime soon after Return Of The Jedi) that he had completed draughts for all 9 films.
And the reason he'd made them out of sequence was that they actually work well in that
order. You start in the middle with the small band of rebels fighting small battles to
overthrough the evil empire. Then you go back to the start to see how this situation occured
and see some of the bigger clone war battles. Then you fast forward to the future and see
the massive battles that finish the story. So that in the end, what we've seen in (the original)
Star Wars trilogy is just a small scale smal part of a much bigger and epic story arc.
(or something like that).
[This message was edited Fri Jul 30 15:02:55 2004 by BorisFishpaw]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #112 posted 07/30/04 10:23pm

MrJoker

BorisFishpaw said:

JediMaster said:


Interesting. Some of it makes sense, and some doesn't. Much of this jives with Expanded Universe continuity, while other details not so much. Jacen and Jaina are there, but where are Mara Jade and Ben Skywalker? I'm doubtful that Lucas would use some major elements, while completely ignoring others. Its true that he has done some of that in the past, namely using Coruscant from the novels, but ignoring all the various Boba Fett origins. The latter isn't all that big of a deal, since there were so many contradictions about this (and they did a brilliant job of explaining this away in the novels, stating that the different origins were stories that Fett had spread to add to his reputation). Still, would he ignore a fan favorite character like Mara?? Would he erase their child? If this is made into novels, I highly doubt it. Most likely, the author would wind up incorporating all those details into Lucas's story.

As for the Darth Bane bit, this is quite intriguing. Is what he tells Luke just a deception, or were the Sith actually persecuted? If the latter is correct, then so much of the established history of the SW Universe is actually false. Established continuity states that the Sith were once Jedi. At one point, a group of Jedi who believed that The Force should be used for personal gain split off to form the Order Of The Sith. They battled the Jedi for control over the galaxy for centuries. This culminated in the Sith War, roughly 1000 years prior to Episode I. This last stand of the Sith was led by Darth Bane, who attempted to unite the various factions of his order against the Jedi. Infighting and backstabbing amongst the Sith led to their defeat. Darth Bane, the sole survivor of The Sith, then declared that only two Sith would exist at a time: a master and an apprentice. While the Jedi ran afoul of Bane once or twice thereafter (thus explaining how Yoda knew of the "two at a time" rule), for the most part he went underground. From that point on, the Dark Lords would plot their revenge in secret, leading the Jedi to believe that The Sith were now extinct.

Now, it could be that Bane and the Sith BELIEVE that they were persecuted for their belief in the Dark Side, but I tend to think this would be a manipulitive ploy to lure Luke away from the Jedi Order he had resurrected. Is Bane his ancestor? Very intriguing if so, and the implications for the Skywalker and Solo clans are pretty staggering (since Jacen and Jaina would also be decendants of Bane!!!)

Thanks for the info, Boris!!! Love to speculate on this kind of stuff!!!


I'm pretty sure my info dates from way back (probably before most of the expanded universe
stuff had been written), as there's no mention of Mara Jade, or Luke having any offspring.
There's also no mention of Anakin Solo either. Though interestingly, Bane's main hench'man'
in the final trilogy is a female Sith who I'm pretty sure was called Darth Jade, and who wielded
2 lightsabers (very much like the Sith Witch in the Clone Wars cartoon). And the initial plot
in Episode VII was with her leading the new Sith assault with an alien army of allies from
some of the outer rim worlds. This was possible because of rampant discimination and
racism against non-human aliens in the days of the Empire, causing a lot of the outlying
alien worlds to harbour understandable bad feeling towards the richer human dominated
central planets (a situation which of course was engineered by Bane in the first place).

I do remember hearing George Lucas himself say in an interview a loooong time ago
(sometime soon after Return Of The Jedi) that he had completed draughts for all 9 films.
And the reason he'd made them out of sequence was that they actually work well in that
order. You start in the middle with the small band of rebels fighting small battles to
overthrough the evil empire. Then you go back to the start to see how this situation occured
and see some of the bigger clone war battles. Then you fast forward to the future and see
the massive battles that finish the story. So that in the end, what we've seen in (the original)
Star Wars trilogy is just a small scale smal part of a much bigger and epic story arc.
(or something like that).
[This message was edited Fri Jul 30 15:02:55 2004 by BorisFishpaw]

Not mentioning Anakin Solo isn't too big of a deal since he died before the NJO series ended.

As for Bane being related to Luke...

Bane: "Luke, I am your great great great great great great great great great great grandfather."
Luke: "NOOOoooooOOOOOooooo!"

giggle
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #113 posted 08/01/04 11:08pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:


As for the Darth Bane bit, this is quite intriguing. Is what he tells Luke just a deception, or were the Sith actually persecuted? If the latter is correct, then so much of the established history of the SW Universe is actually false. Established continuity states that the Sith were once Jedi. At one point, a group of Jedi who believed that The Force should be used for personal gain split off to form the Order Of The Sith. They battled the Jedi for control over the galaxy for centuries. This culminated in the Sith War, roughly 1000 years prior to Episode I. This last stand of the Sith was led by Darth Bane, who attempted to unite the various factions of his order against the Jedi. Infighting and backstabbing amongst the Sith led to their defeat. Darth Bane, the sole survivor of The Sith, then declared that only two Sith would exist at a time: a master and an apprentice. While the Jedi ran afoul of Bane once or twice thereafter (thus explaining how Yoda knew of the "two at a time" rule), for the most part he went underground. From that point on, the Dark Lords would plot their revenge in secret, leading the Jedi to believe that The Sith were now extinct.

Now, it could be that Bane and the Sith BELIEVE that they were persecuted for their belief in the Dark Side, but I tend to think this would be a manipulitive ploy to lure Luke away from the Jedi Order he had resurrected. Is Bane his ancestor? Very intriguing if so, and the implications for the Skywalker and Solo clans are pretty staggering (since Jacen and Jaina would also be decendants of Bane!!!)


Just to add a bit more info about the apparent discrepancy between the Expanded Universe
story about how the Sith came to be and what is revealed in Episodes VII-IX. Basically there
are 2 'Siths'. The 'Sith' that split from the Jedi order over 1,000 years before Episode I were
not the original Sith that are talked about in Episodes VII-IX. The 'Original' Sith predate them
by a looong time and had been alegedly exterminated by the first Jedi in 'crusades'. It's also
implied that they were a specific race from a particular planet (the long lost Sith homeworld
where Bane now resides). It was the discovery of this ancient ruined Sith homeworld and it's
archives of Sith techniques and history that prompted the first 'dark' Jedi to study their ways
and take on the 'Sith' name as their own. I even remember seeing some rough sketches
of ancient ruined cathedral like buildings on the Sith homeworld ages ago (all very 'gothic').

Maybe I ought to look into the expanded universe a bit, just to see if this really contradicts
what has been written or not. Does it say who the first 'Dark Jedi'/Sith was, and what prompted
them to turn to the darkside?
[This message was edited Sun Aug 1 16:10:15 2004 by BorisFishpaw]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #114 posted 08/03/04 1:28pm

JediMaster

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

JediMaster said:


As for the Darth Bane bit, this is quite intriguing. Is what he tells Luke just a deception, or were the Sith actually persecuted? If the latter is correct, then so much of the established history of the SW Universe is actually false. Established continuity states that the Sith were once Jedi. At one point, a group of Jedi who believed that The Force should be used for personal gain split off to form the Order Of The Sith. They battled the Jedi for control over the galaxy for centuries. This culminated in the Sith War, roughly 1000 years prior to Episode I. This last stand of the Sith was led by Darth Bane, who attempted to unite the various factions of his order against the Jedi. Infighting and backstabbing amongst the Sith led to their defeat. Darth Bane, the sole survivor of The Sith, then declared that only two Sith would exist at a time: a master and an apprentice. While the Jedi ran afoul of Bane once or twice thereafter (thus explaining how Yoda knew of the "two at a time" rule), for the most part he went underground. From that point on, the Dark Lords would plot their revenge in secret, leading the Jedi to believe that The Sith were now extinct.

Now, it could be that Bane and the Sith BELIEVE that they were persecuted for their belief in the Dark Side, but I tend to think this would be a manipulitive ploy to lure Luke away from the Jedi Order he had resurrected. Is Bane his ancestor? Very intriguing if so, and the implications for the Skywalker and Solo clans are pretty staggering (since Jacen and Jaina would also be decendants of Bane!!!)


Just to add a bit more info about the apparent discrepancy between the Expanded Universe
story about how the Sith came to be and what is revealed in Episodes VII-IX. Basically there
are 2 'Siths'. The 'Sith' that split from the Jedi order over 1,000 years before Episode I were
not the original Sith that are talked about in Episodes VII-IX. The 'Original' Sith predate them
by a looong time and had been alegedly exterminated by the first Jedi in 'crusades'. It's also
implied that they were a specific race from a particular planet (the long lost Sith homeworld
where Bane now resides). It was the discovery of this ancient ruined Sith homeworld and it's
archives of Sith techniques and history that prompted the first 'dark' Jedi to study their ways
and take on the 'Sith' name as their own. I even remember seeing some rough sketches
of ancient ruined cathedral like buildings on the Sith homeworld ages ago (all very 'gothic').

Maybe I ought to look into the expanded universe a bit, just to see if this really contradicts
what has been written or not. Does it say who the first 'Dark Jedi'/Sith was, and what prompted
them to turn to the darkside?
[This message was edited Sun Aug 1 16:10:15 2004 by BorisFishpaw]


Actually, all of that is consistent with the EU. The whole thing with the Sith being a specific race, who became power-hungry and tried to take over the galaxy, is in the EU continuity. The Sith were a race of force users who turned to the Dark Side and tried to conquer the galaxy. The Jedi took them on, and wound up pretty much eradicating them in the process (this was actually more due to the fact that the Sith were determined to take the galaxy at all cost). The "Dark Jedi" who split from the order took the Sith name because they had adopted their philosphies (think of them as being much like Neo-Nazis. They used their name and philosophies, regardless of whether or not they were German)
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #115 posted 08/04/04 1:49pm

JediMaster

avatar

So Boris, you heard any rumours as to what film they plan to attach the teaser trailer to??
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #116 posted 08/04/04 4:54pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:

So Boris, you heard any rumours as to what film they plan to attach the teaser trailer to??


Not yet (I think it's a bit too early for that yet)
But I hear that it should start appearing sometime in November
(have to check out what big Fox pictures open in November that might be likely contenders)

From what I hear there's now several 'chunks' of the movie finished, and the whole thing
has already been strung together into a rough cut to check length and pacing. From what I've
heard the opening 10 minute space battle sequence is pretty mindblowing (think final battle
in Return Of The Jedi, only even more full-on and with the camera flying through the action
like some demented 3D rollercoaster ride too), and this has now been completed.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #117 posted 08/04/04 5:07pm

JediMaster

avatar

BorisFishpaw said:

JediMaster said:

So Boris, you heard any rumours as to what film they plan to attach the teaser trailer to??


Not yet (I think it's a bit too early for that yet)
But I hear that it should start appearing sometime in November
(have to check out what big Fox pictures open in November that might be likely contenders)

From what I hear there's now several 'chunks' of the movie finished, and the whole thing
has already been strung together into a rough cut to check length and pacing. From what I've
heard the opening 10 minute space battle sequence is pretty mindblowing (think final battle
in Return Of The Jedi, only even more full-on and with the camera flying through the action
like some demented 3D rollercoaster ride too), and this has now been completed.


Well, last time out the teaser DIDN'T appear on a Fox movie! It was attached to the Pixar flick Monster's Inc! Isn't The Incredibles from Pixar due around then????

I've also heard great things about the opening, as well as the Anakin vs Obi-Wan Saber duel, which is suppossed to be the longest swordfight ever on film!!!
jedi

Do not hurry yourself in your spirit to become offended, for the taking of offense is what rests in the bosom of the stupid ones. (Ecclesiastes 7:9)
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #118 posted 08/04/04 5:08pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:

BorisFishpaw said:



Just to add a bit more info about the apparent discrepancy between the Expanded Universe
story about how the Sith came to be and what is revealed in Episodes VII-IX. Basically there
are 2 'Siths'. The 'Sith' that split from the Jedi order over 1,000 years before Episode I were
not the original Sith that are talked about in Episodes VII-IX. The 'Original' Sith predate them
by a looong time and had been alegedly exterminated by the first Jedi in 'crusades'. It's also
implied that they were a specific race from a particular planet (the long lost Sith homeworld
where Bane now resides). It was the discovery of this ancient ruined Sith homeworld and it's
archives of Sith techniques and history that prompted the first 'dark' Jedi to study their ways
and take on the 'Sith' name as their own. I even remember seeing some rough sketches
of ancient ruined cathedral like buildings on the Sith homeworld ages ago (all very 'gothic').

Maybe I ought to look into the expanded universe a bit, just to see if this really contradicts
what has been written or not. Does it say who the first 'Dark Jedi'/Sith was, and what prompted
them to turn to the darkside?
[This message was edited Sun Aug 1 16:10:15 2004 by BorisFishpaw]


Actually, all of that is consistent with the EU. The whole thing with the Sith being a specific race, who became power-hungry and tried to take over the galaxy, is in the EU continuity. The Sith were a race of force users who turned to the Dark Side and tried to conquer the galaxy. The Jedi took them on, and wound up pretty much eradicating them in the process (this was actually more due to the fact that the Sith were determined to take the galaxy at all cost). The "Dark Jedi" who split from the order took the Sith name because they had adopted their philosphies (think of them as being much like Neo-Nazis. They used their name and philosophies, regardless of whether or not they were German)


Very interesting. I'll definitely have to look into the expanded universe further, as it seems
to not be in contradiction with what I've heard about the final trilogy (which I'd always asumed
it would be). I wish Lucas would change his mind about Episodes VII-IX. It would be great see
Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher and Mark Hamill return to their characters again, even if they are
little more than glorified cameos (apart from Luke, who plays a big part in the final 2).
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #119 posted 08/04/04 5:10pm

BorisFishpaw

avatar

JediMaster said:

BorisFishpaw said:



Not yet (I think it's a bit too early for that yet)
But I hear that it should start appearing sometime in November
(have to check out what big Fox pictures open in November that might be likely contenders)

From what I hear there's now several 'chunks' of the movie finished, and the whole thing
has already been strung together into a rough cut to check length and pacing. From what I've
heard the opening 10 minute space battle sequence is pretty mindblowing (think final battle
in Return Of The Jedi, only even more full-on and with the camera flying through the action
like some demented 3D rollercoaster ride too), and this has now been completed.


Well, last time out the teaser DIDN'T appear on a Fox movie! It was attached to the Pixar flick Monster's Inc! Isn't The Incredibles from Pixar due around then????

I've also heard great things about the opening, as well as the Anakin vs Obi-Wan Saber duel, which is suppossed to be the longest swordfight ever on film!!!


I think you're right!
Sounds like The Incredibles is a pretty good bet.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 4 of 6 <123456>
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > General Discussion > Episode III title announced!