independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Deliverance EP appreciation thread
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Page 2 of 2 <12
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Reply #30 posted 03/15/18 7:39am

jdcxc

databank said:

If (and I say "if" as I cannot verify this) Ian Boxill indeed co-authored and co-arranged the songs he has a certain legitimacy when it comes to "finishing" them, in the sense that they're as much "his" as Prince's, even if Prince legally owned the masters from the fact that he paid for the sessions and that Ian was contractually tied to him as a session musician. In that sense, the "finishing" would be more legitimate than any posthumous remix.


.


Regardless, as a Prince fan, I'd rather hear the tracks as Prince left them, because it is quite uncertain that he'd have approved of those final mixes as they are, and I want his work to be left untouched. In a similar way, I wouldn't like the Revolution or any past bandmembers to "finish" vault tracks even if they co-wrote or co-arranged them. But if Boxill is really co-author, I can understand his perspective as an artist: it's, after all, his work too.

[Edited 3/14/18 22:30pm]



I agree
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #31 posted 03/15/18 11:25am

laurarichardso
n

recordmanben said:

Interesting reading both sides of this coin.
In my opinion Ian does own some intellectual property of these songs and in some degree owns the right to do what he wishes with songs as much as Prince would have.
He was the engineer, he has posession of the tapes rightfully and he was working on the material just as much as Prince was.
He screwed up by not telling the estate and working with them to get this material out as a Prince release. I'm sure nobody would have said much if it came out under the Engineers name featuring Prince.

[Edited 3/14/18 13:29pm]


—well the law does not see it that way. Ian signed a agreement that he would share in no profit of the material he worked on with Prince. That alone tells you he was not going to be an owner of anything. He simply believed the estate was in disarray and he could slip this work and profit from it and rework so he could claim some credit. He is pathetic.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #32 posted 03/15/18 10:52pm

databank

avatar

Tangerine17 said:

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:



I wonder how Mathieu heard the original tracks?

Maybe by his association with Lenny, Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and others?

Actually, it has nothing to do with any of my friends/collaborators that you listed although they were all friends with Prince. I actually got some CDs back in 06 that were early configurations of Lotusflow3r, Planet Earth and 3121 when I was working on Ultimate, When 2 R In Love and some other secret projects. Of course I’ve never copied them but I can attest to the fact that Boxil did overdubs on the original tracks but those are Prince’s tracks on Boxil’s version. He just added background vocals and some keyboard strings and things. Hope this helps. [Edited 3/14/18 22:14pm]

Thanks a lot for sharing those infos Mathieu hug

A COMPREHENSIVE PRINCE DISCOGRAPHY (work in progress ^^): https://sites.google.com/...scography/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #33 posted 03/16/18 8:07am

ISaidLifeIsJus
tAGame

avatar

Tangerine17 said:

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:



I wonder how Mathieu heard the original tracks?

Maybe by his association with Lenny, Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and others?

Actually, it has nothing to do with any of my friends/collaborators that you listed although they were all friends with Prince. I actually got some CDs back in 06 that were early configurations of Lotusflow3r, Planet Earth and 3121 when I was working on Ultimate, When 2 R In Love and some other secret projects. Of course I’ve never copied them but I can attest to the fact that Boxil did overdubs on the original tracks but those are Prince’s tracks on Boxil’s version. He just added background vocals and some keyboard strings and things. Hope this helps.



Thanks!

BTW I love your work.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #34 posted 03/16/18 10:10am

Doozer

avatar

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:



Tangerine17 said:


ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:




I wonder how Mathieu heard the original tracks?


Maybe by his association with Lenny, Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and others?



Actually, it has nothing to do with any of my friends/collaborators that you listed although they were all friends with Prince. I actually got some CDs back in 06 that were early configurations of Lotusflow3r, Planet Earth and 3121 when I was working on Ultimate, When 2 R In Love and some other secret projects. Of course I’ve never copied them but I can attest to the fact that Boxil did overdubs on the original tracks but those are Prince’s tracks on Boxil’s version. He just added background vocals and some keyboard strings and things. Hope this helps.



Thanks!

BTW I love your work.



Ditto!

This EP was a great surprise. It would only have been better if it had been sanctioned by the estate. But they’re too busy wasting time and money, so I’ll take what I can get, gladly. I’d like to pay the estate for vault tracks, but until they get their act together, the market will be there for projects like this one.
[Edited 3/16/18 10:10am]
Check out The Mountains and the Sea, a Prince podcast by yours truly and my wife. More info at https://www.facebook.com/TMATSPodcast/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #35 posted 03/16/18 10:39am

pricetag

coldasice said:

You do realize P is only on lead vocals and some guitar right?

Even if that's the case, surely enough to recommend the track, no?

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #36 posted 03/16/18 10:41am

pricetag

laurarichardson said:

TrivialPursuit said:


I never claimed anything he played on it or not.

—Well That is the problem with the whole project

Wait. You think the track is limited ONLY because it has a stellar Prince vocal and guitar: How odd.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #37 posted 03/16/18 11:05am

Tangerine17

Doozer said:

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:



Tangerine17 said:


ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:




I wonder how Mathieu heard the original tracks?


Maybe by his association with Lenny, Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and others?



Actually, it has nothing to do with any of my friends/collaborators that you listed although they were all friends with Prince. I actually got some CDs back in 06 that were early configurations of Lotusflow3r, Planet Earth and 3121 when I was working on Ultimate, When 2 R In Love and some other secret projects. Of course I’ve never copied them but I can attest to the fact that Boxil did overdubs on the original tracks but those are Prince’s tracks on Boxil’s version. He just added background vocals and some keyboard strings and things. Hope this helps.



Thanks!

BTW I love your work.



Ditto!

This EP was a great surprise. It would only have been better if it had been sanctioned by the estate. But they’re too busy wasting time and money, so I’ll take what I can get, gladly. I’d like to pay the estate for vault tracks, but until they get their act together, the market will be there for projects like this one.
[Edited 3/16/18 10:10am]


That is incorrect. He plays all the instruments pre-overdubs by Boxill
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #38 posted 03/17/18 3:38am

Romeoblu

I really enjoy these tracks. Shame there wasn't more.

I added some stray tracks from this period 2007-2009 to pad out the listening experience, still a little short but a great listen.

Deliverance
The Morning After
I am
Touch Me
Sunrise, sunset
No one Else
In a large room with no light (2009)
F.U.N.K
[Edited 3/17/18 3:41am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #39 posted 03/17/18 10:16am

MIRvmn

avatar

Yes I like this EP smile
Welcome 2 The Dawn
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #40 posted 03/19/18 12:04pm

laurarichardso
n

Doozer said:

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said:



Thanks!

BTW I love your work.

Ditto! This EP was a great surprise. It would only have been better if it had been sanctioned by the estate. But they’re too busy wasting time and money, so I’ll take what I can get, gladly. I’d like to pay the estate for vault tracks, but until they get their act together, the market will be there for projects like this one. [Edited 3/16/18 10:10am]

How could it be scantioned by the estate if Ian stole it? The estate is being overseen by a court and no court is going to allow copyright and infringement go on without stepping up.

You do realize that what Ian was doing is a crime? I doubt he was going to turn one penny over to the estate without a long drawn out court battle which would have cost more money.

The handled it correctly and if some of you would have some patience they will get around to putting it out. The right way without Ian's fuckery.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #41 posted 03/19/18 2:03pm

BalladofPeterP
arker

I love Deliverance. It's one of my favorite Prince tracks of the last 15 years.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #42 posted 03/19/18 2:17pm

Doozer

avatar

laurarichardson said:

Doozer said:

ISaidLifeIsJustAGame said: Ditto! This EP was a great surprise. It would only have been better if it had been sanctioned by the estate. But they’re too busy wasting time and money, so I’ll take what I can get, gladly. I’d like to pay the estate for vault tracks, but until they get their act together, the market will be there for projects like this one. [Edited 3/16/18 10:10am]

How could it be scantioned by the estate if Ian stole it? The estate is being overseen by a court and no court is going to allow copyright and infringement go on without stepping up.

You do realize that what Ian was doing is a crime? I doubt he was going to turn one penny over to the estate without a long drawn out court battle which would have cost more money.

The handled it correctly and if some of you would have some patience they will get around to putting it out. The right way without Ian's fuckery.

Like I said, it would have been better had it been sanctioned by the estate. As in, it would be nice if there had been a plan of any kind left behind. There wasn't, so shit like this is going on. That's the reality of it all at this point.

Check out The Mountains and the Sea, a Prince podcast by yours truly and my wife. More info at https://www.facebook.com/TMATSPodcast/
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #43 posted 03/19/18 3:37pm

luvsexy4all

he said he had more tracks....shame he wont contact estate and release them with estate

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #44 posted 03/23/18 2:45pm

thx185

avatar

coldasice said:

You do realize P is only on lead vocals and some guitar right?

I don't believe that. I do think it's one of the best things I've heard from him since the 80s, and that's coming from someone that likes a whole lot of stuff he did since then.

"..free to change your mind"
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #45 posted 03/23/18 3:53pm

GrayDorian

luvsexy4all said:

he said he had more tracks....shame he wont contact estate and release them with estate

Oddly enough, I surprise myself by feeling a bit ambivalent about this EP. confuse

I remember how exciting it was at first to hear a brief clip of a new Prince song on the news on the radio, but then it was a huge disappointment to find out almost immediately that it was completely unofficial, and that sadly Ian had gone ahead and done this without the consent of the estate.

It's not that I dislike the Deliverance EP (far from it in fact), but, if Ian had say accepted a modest fee for his work, and agreed with the estate for the proceeds to go to one of Prince's charities, I am sure I would feel far more comfortable with and enthusiastic about this (eventually unofficial) release.

It seems to have been pretty well received widely, so I feel like maybe it's a bit of an opportunity missed, and I can't help but wonder whether perhaps Ian may now regret how he went about trying to release it. shrug


Nevertheless, I am grateful to have been able to get the chance to hear it, though I always feel a bit guilty about bootlegs, as Prince didn't seem to like them, so I can't get over the feeling it's perhaps a tad disrespectful for me to listen to them (though I admit that regrettably I used to buy lots of them as a young man). Well, I suppose that's another topic entirely.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Page 2 of 2 <12
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > Deliverance EP appreciation thread