independent and unofficial
Prince fan community
Welcome! Sign up or enter username and password to remember me
Forum jump
Forums > Prince: Music and More > For shits and giggles... Thriller vs. Purple Rain track for track...
« Previous topic  Next topic »
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
Author

Tweet     Share

Message
Thread started 01/30/15 1:17am

MattyJam

avatar

For shits and giggles... Thriller vs. Purple Rain track for track...

Two seminal 9-track albums from the biggest stars of the eighties.

Wanna Be Startin Somethin vs. Let's Go Crazy - Wanna Be Startin Somethin
Both rousing and anthemic openers, but WBSS sounds funkier and has aged better. Also additional points for coining the phrase "mama say mama sa ma mon coo sa."
Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U - Take Me With U
Not the strongest track on either album, Baby Be Mine sounds a bit twee in comparison to Take Me With U.
The Beautiful Ones vs. The Girl Is Mine - The Beautiful Ones
The worst track on Thriller vs the best on Purple Rain. No contest with this one.
Thriller vs. Computer Blue - Thriller
Both solid tracks, but Thriller edges it out.
Beat It vs. Darling Nikki - Beat It
Both the edgiest song on their respective albums and both brilliant rock tracks. But Beat It has one of the greatest guitar solos of all time so MJ wins this one for me.
Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry - Billie Jean
The hardest choice to make. Both centrepieces of their respective albums and two of the greatest pop songs ever written. I feel time has been kinder to Billie Jean. The production values on Doves sound very of its time, whereas BJ sounds timeless.
Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U - Human Nature
Both great tracks, but I prefer HN.
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing vs. Baby I'm A Star - Baby I'm A Star
Two fun, fairly throwaway pop songs, Baby I'm A Star doesn't feature the Chipmunks.
Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain - Purple Rain
No contest. Purple Rain every time.

So all in all, that's five for Thriller and four for Purple Rain.
[Edited 1/30/15 2:18am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #1 posted 01/30/15 1:26am

LiveToTell86

Wanna Be Startin' Somethin' vs. Let's Go Crazy
Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U
The Girl Is Mine vs. The Beautiful Ones
Thriller vs. Computer Blue
Beat It vs. Darling Nikki
Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry
Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing) vs. Baby I'm A Star
The Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #2 posted 01/30/15 1:41am

FragileUnderto
w

avatar

9 out of 9 For purple rain cool

Let's Go Crazy
Take Me With U
The Beautiful Ones
Computer Blue
Darling Nikki
When Doves Cry
I Would Die 4 U
Baby I'm A Star
Purple Rain


In before the lock lock peace!

Cant believe my purple psychedelic pimp slap pimp2

And I descend from grace, In arms of undertow
I will take my place, In the great below
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #3 posted 01/30/15 1:42am

thedance

avatar

As much as I love Thriller, Prince is second to none.. heart


Wanna Be Startin' Somethin' vs. Let's Go Crazy
Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U
The Girl Is Mine vs. The Beautiful Ones
Thriller vs. Computer Blue
Beat It vs. Darling Nikki
Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry
Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing) vs. Baby I'm A Star
The Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain



This is after all not michaeljacksom.org!


- this is a Prince site with Prince-fans... right?!

Thriller is still outstanding and phenomenal.... but Purple Rain is better.


Prince 4Ever. heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #4 posted 01/30/15 1:43am

thedance

avatar

FragileUndertow said:

9 out of 9 For purple rain cool

^ that's it.... end of discussion... boogie

wink

Prince 4Ever. heart
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #5 posted 01/30/15 1:44am

FragileUnderto
w

avatar

thedance said:

FragileUndertow said:

9 out of 9 For purple rain cool

^ that's it.... end of discussion... boogie

wink

highfive

lockdance

Cant believe my purple psychedelic pimp slap pimp2

And I descend from grace, In arms of undertow
I will take my place, In the great below
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #6 posted 01/30/15 1:51am

MattyJam

avatar

FragileUndertow said:


In before the lock lock peace!


Oh come on mods.... Aren't we all a bit too long in the tooth to be locking these kind of threads? It's only a bit of fun....
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #7 posted 01/30/15 2:30am

FragileUnderto
w

avatar

MattyJam said:

FragileUndertow said:
In before the lock lock peace!
Oh come on mods.... Aren't we all a bit too long in the tooth to be locking these kind of threads? It's only a bit of fun....


I have no problem with the topic biggrin but the mods may differ lol
Im not a MJ fan, though i do like select tracks from off the wall cool

Cant believe my purple psychedelic pimp slap pimp2

And I descend from grace, In arms of undertow
I will take my place, In the great below
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #8 posted 01/30/15 2:57am

SuperSoulFight
er

The fact that I know most of the tracks on Thriller without owning the album says something about how succesful it was. But I always found that mamasay-mamasamama-appelsap kinda silly.
[Edited 1/30/15 3:01am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #9 posted 01/30/15 3:09am

Aerogram

avatar

Comparing them sequentially is insane.

There's only two songs on Thriller that are worthy of the best material on Purple Rain: Beat It and Billiie Jean.

Wanna be Starting Something and Thriller are I Would Die 4 You/Baby I'm a Star-worthy (considering these were the "easy ones" for Prince, Jackson's "easy dancey ones" are perhaps better produced, not sure if they are actually better songs).

This is silly, both albums are great, Purple Rain just happens to be a way more personal statement, which makes it better art in my world.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #10 posted 01/30/15 3:21am

KingSausage

avatar

FragileUndertow said:



thedance said:




FragileUndertow said:


9 out of 9 For purple rain cool



^ that's it.... end of discussion... boogie

wink



highfive


lockdance



Fuck yeah. Nailed it.
"Drop that stereo before I blow your Goddamn nuts off, asshole!"
-Eugene Tackleberry
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #11 posted 01/30/15 3:26am

MattyJam

avatar

Aerogram said:

Comparing them sequentially is insane.



There's only two songs on Thriller that are worthy of the best material on Purple Rain: Beat It and Billiie Jean.



Wanna be Starting Something and Thriller are I Would Die 4 You/Baby I'm a Star-worthy (considering these were the "easy ones" for Prince, Jackson's "easy dancey ones" are perhaps better produced, not sure if they are actually better songs).



This is silly, both albums are great, Purple Rain just happens to be a way more personal statement, which makes it better art in my world.



I actually think rating them side by side sequentially works surprisingly well. They both have instantly recognisable opening tracks, kind of throway tracks 2 and 8, mid-tempo track 3, the rock number at track 5, their most famous hit at track 6.

I would say PR has three real masterpieces (Doves, The Beautiful Ones and title track) and Thriller has two (Beat It and Billie Jean). But
I would argue that songs like Startin Somethin, Human Nature and Thriller are stronger than the likes of Computer Blue, I Would Die 4 U and Let's Go Crazy.
[Edited 1/30/15 3:30am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #12 posted 01/30/15 3:28am

KingSausage

avatar

Let's play Thriller in our left ears and Purple Rain in our right ears and then, shit, I don't know, jump around masturbating. We'll get dizzy and see which direction we fall. Who goes first?
"Drop that stereo before I blow your Goddamn nuts off, asshole!"
-Eugene Tackleberry
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #13 posted 01/30/15 3:33am

FragileUnderto
w

avatar

KingSausage said:

Let's play Thriller in our left ears and Purple Rain in our right ears and then, shit, I don't know, jump around masturbating. We'll get dizzy and see which direction we fall. Who goes first?

lol

Cant believe my purple psychedelic pimp slap pimp2

And I descend from grace, In arms of undertow
I will take my place, In the great below
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #14 posted 01/30/15 3:50am

MattyJam

avatar

KingSausage said:

Let's play Thriller in our left ears and Purple Rain in our right ears and then, shit, I don't know, jump around masturbating. We'll get dizzy and see which direction we fall. Who goes first?


See, this is why threads like this get locked, because of dickhead comments like this.

How about actually discussing the music?
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #15 posted 01/30/15 3:54am

Averett

avatar

MattyJam said:

Two seminal 9-track albums from the biggest stars of the eighties. Wanna Be Startin Somethin vs. Let's Go Crazy - Wanna Be Startin Somethin Both rousing and anthemic openers, but WBSS sounds funkier and has aged better. Also additional points for coining the phrase "mama say mama sa ma mon coo sa." Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U - Take Me With U Not the strongest track on either album, Baby Be Mine sounds a bit twee in comparison to Take Me With U. The Beautiful Ones vs. The Girl Is Mine - The Beautiful Ones The worst track on Thriller vs the best on Purple Rain. No contest with this one. Thriller vs. Computer Blue - Thriller Both solid tracks, but Thriller edges it out. Beat It vs. Darling Nikki - Beat It Both the edgiest song on their respective albums and both brilliant rock tracks. But Beat It has one of the greatest guitar solos of all time so MJ wins this one for me. Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry - Billie Jean The hardest choice to make. Both centrepieces of their respective albums and two of the greatest pop songs ever written. I feel time has been kinder to Billie Jean. The production values on Doves sound very of its time, whereas BJ sounds timeless. Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U - Human Nature Both great tracks, but I prefer HN. P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing vs. Baby I'm A Star - Baby I'm A Star Two fun, fairly throwaway pop songs, Baby I'm A Star doesn't feature the Chipmunks. Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain - Purple Rain No contest. Purple Rain every time. So all in all, that's five for Thriller and four for Purple Rain. [Edited 1/30/15 2:18am]

And yet MJ has slim to no "real" B-sides to go toe-to-toe with Prince, so:

17 days beats Can't Get Outta the Rain

Erotic City beats It's the Falling In Love/Can't Get Out of The Rain

Another Lonely Christmas beats Get On The Dance Floor

GOD (Love Theme from Purple Rain) beats Rock With You (Live)

GOD (vocal) beats Baby Be Mine

Baby I'm Star* versus Workin' Day and Night (Yet another Off the Wall rehash - sigh) - win goes to the fresher material

In my mind, you cannot omit the B-sides unless you are a MJ fan in which case, you kinda want to ignore that Michael phoned in his B-sides unlike Prince.

Just sayin' eek

[Edited 1/30/15 4:17am]

A robin sings a masterpiece that lives and dies unheard...
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #16 posted 01/30/15 4:04am

dopedog

I fell to the right, so Purple Rain it is.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #17 posted 01/30/15 4:18am

jdcxc

MattyJam said:

Two seminal 9-track albums from the biggest stars of the eighties.

Wanna Be Startin Somethin vs. Let's Go Crazy - Wanna Be Startin Somethin
Both rousing and anthemic openers, but WBSS sounds funkier and has aged better. Also additional points for coining the phrase "mama say mama sa ma mon coo sa."
Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U - Take Me With U
Not the strongest track on either album, Baby Be Mine sounds a bit twee in comparison to Take Me With U.
The Beautiful Ones vs. The Girl Is Mine - The Beautiful Ones
The worst track on Thriller vs the best on Purple Rain. No contest with this one.
Thriller vs. Computer Blue - Thriller
Both solid tracks, but Thriller edges it out.
Beat It vs. Darling Nikki - Beat It
Both the edgiest song on their respective albums and both brilliant rock tracks. But Beat It has one of the greatest guitar solos of all time so MJ wins this one for me.
Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry - Billie Jean
The hardest choice to make. Both centrepieces of their respective albums and two of the greatest pop songs ever written. I feel time has been kinder to Billie Jean. The production values on Doves sound very of its time, whereas BJ sounds timeless.
Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U - Human Nature
Both great tracks, but I prefer HN.
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing vs. Baby I'm A Star - Baby I'm A Star
Two fun, fairly throwaway pop songs, Baby I'm A Star doesn't feature the Chipmunks.
Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain - Purple Rain
No contest. Purple Rain every time.

So all in all, that's five for Thriller and four for Purple Rain.
[Edited 1/30/15 2:18am]


I feel PR has aged way more gracefully than Thriller. When Doves Cry, Computer Blue and Nikki were so ahead of there time that they would fit perfectly in the contemporary music scene. All you have to do is look at the recent covers by Rihanna, Beyonce, Foo Fighters. Thriller has so many cheesy elements- it's for the amusement park crowd.
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #18 posted 01/30/15 4:28am

MattyJam

avatar

jdcxc said:

MattyJam said:

Two seminal 9-track albums from the biggest stars of the eighties.

Wanna Be Startin Somethin vs. Let's Go Crazy - Wanna Be Startin Somethin
Both rousing and anthemic openers, but WBSS sounds funkier and has aged better. Also additional points for coining the phrase "mama say mama sa ma mon coo sa."
Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U - Take Me With U
Not the strongest track on either album, Baby Be Mine sounds a bit twee in comparison to Take Me With U.
The Beautiful Ones vs. The Girl Is Mine - The Beautiful Ones
The worst track on Thriller vs the best on Purple Rain. No contest with this one.
Thriller vs. Computer Blue - Thriller
Both solid tracks, but Thriller edges it out.
Beat It vs. Darling Nikki - Beat It
Both the edgiest song on their respective albums and both brilliant rock tracks. But Beat It has one of the greatest guitar solos of all time so MJ wins this one for me.
Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry - Billie Jean
The hardest choice to make. Both centrepieces of their respective albums and two of the greatest pop songs ever written. I feel time has been kinder to Billie Jean. The production values on Doves sound very of its time, whereas BJ sounds timeless.
Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U - Human Nature
Both great tracks, but I prefer HN.
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing vs. Baby I'm A Star - Baby I'm A Star
Two fun, fairly throwaway pop songs, Baby I'm A Star doesn't feature the Chipmunks.
Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain - Purple Rain
No contest. Purple Rain every time.

So all in all, that's five for Thriller and four for Purple Rain.
[Edited 1/30/15 2:18am]


I feel PR has aged way more gracefully than Thriller. When Doves Cry, Computer Blue and Nikki were so ahead of there time that they would fit perfectly in the contemporary music scene. All you have to do is look at the recent covers by Rihanna, Beyonce, Foo Fighters. Thriller has so many cheesy elements- it's for the amusement park crowd.


I would say the worst songs on Thriller (Baby Be Mine, The Girl Is Mine and PYT) have aged badly. But the best songs (Billie Jean, Startin Somethin, Beat It) have aged better than anything on Purple Rain. People still go crazy for those songs, not so much for PR or Doves, unless you're at a Prince concert.

Thriller too has been sampled and covered by loads of artists ranging from Rhianna, SWV, Chris Brown to rock/indie bands like Fall Out Boy, Chris Cornell and Bumblefoot.
[Edited 1/30/15 4:30am]
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #19 posted 01/30/15 4:34am

KingSausage

avatar

MattyJam said:

KingSausage said:

Let's play Thriller in our left ears and Purple Rain in our right ears and then, shit, I don't know, jump around masturbating. We'll get dizzy and see which direction we fall. Who goes first?


See, this is why threads like this get locked, because of dickhead comments like this.

How about actually discussing the music?



Just trying to add some levity. Sorry!

I thought your track-by-track approach was interesting. I never realized how similarly structured both albums' sequencing is. It makes it a different contest than a simple album-to-album comparison. I love Thriller, and it's one of the greatest pop albums ever. EVER. But Purple Rain is so much more than a pop album. It has creative experimentation and artistic depth that blows Thriller away. Again, I love Thriller. But Purple Rain is the kind of album that should be put on satellites and launched into deep space just so we can prove to aliens that their music is balls compared to ours.
"Drop that stereo before I blow your Goddamn nuts off, asshole!"
-Eugene Tackleberry
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #20 posted 01/30/15 4:37am

KingSausage

avatar

I would not say that Wanna Be Startin Something has aged well.
"Drop that stereo before I blow your Goddamn nuts off, asshole!"
-Eugene Tackleberry
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #21 posted 01/30/15 4:51am

FragileUnderto
w

avatar

Beat It has not aged well either

Cant believe my purple psychedelic pimp slap pimp2

And I descend from grace, In arms of undertow
I will take my place, In the great below
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #22 posted 01/30/15 5:05am

pdiddy2011

Interesting thread, but... - you're dead to me lol - for making two unforgivable mistakes:

Darling Nikki is significantly better than Beat It.

When Doves Cry is exponentially better than Billie Jean.

Otherwise, I'd take I Would Die For You over Human Nature any day of the week, and maybe, I don't know, possibly PYT over Baby I'm A Star, but not so emphatically that you would be dead to me for choosing the other.

MattyJam said:

Two seminal 9-track albums from the biggest stars of the eighties. Wanna Be Startin Somethin vs. Let's Go Crazy - Wanna Be Startin Somethin Both rousing and anthemic openers, but WBSS sounds funkier and has aged better. Also additional points for coining the phrase "mama say mama sa ma mon coo sa." Baby Be Mine vs. Take Me With U - Take Me With U Not the strongest track on either album, Baby Be Mine sounds a bit twee in comparison to Take Me With U. The Beautiful Ones vs. The Girl Is Mine - The Beautiful Ones The worst track on Thriller vs the best on Purple Rain. No contest with this one. Thriller vs. Computer Blue - Thriller Both solid tracks, but Thriller edges it out. Beat It vs. Darling Nikki - Beat It Both the edgiest song on their respective albums and both brilliant rock tracks. But Beat It has one of the greatest guitar solos of all time so MJ wins this one for me. Billie Jean vs. When Doves Cry - Billie Jean The hardest choice to make. Both centrepieces of their respective albums and two of the greatest pop songs ever written. I feel time has been kinder to Billie Jean. The production values on Doves sound very of its time, whereas BJ sounds timeless. Human Nature vs. I Would Die 4 U - Human Nature Both great tracks, but I prefer HN. P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing vs. Baby I'm A Star - Baby I'm A Star Two fun, fairly throwaway pop songs, Baby I'm A Star doesn't feature the Chipmunks. Lady In My Life vs. Purple Rain - Purple Rain No contest. Purple Rain every time. So all in all, that's five for Thriller and four for Purple Rain. [Edited 1/30/15 2:18am]

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #23 posted 01/30/15 5:10am

NouveauDance

avatar

Prince wins on everything except WBSS and Human Nature.

zipppppp!

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #24 posted 01/30/15 5:50am

Militant

avatar

moderator

My two favorite artists, but I can't get with a sequential comparison for the primary reason that Purple Rain is the soundtrack to a movie and Thriller isn't. Meaning, the sequence of Purple Rain was for the most part defined by the movie (of course, Purple Rain doesn't come last in the film).

But both the tracklisting and the choice of songs themselves would be different if it weren't for the film. If anything I'd suggest that 1999 VS Thriller would be a better comparison since neither records were made for a film, and were both released in the same year, both had songs/videos that broke out to a crossover audience thanks to MTV, and both were made with that intention, to break the artist out to a wider audience, and both were successful with that.

The key difference, in my mind, is that Michael chose to squeeze every last drop out of that record, because he didn't make records as quickly as Prince did. So the promotional campaign for Thriller lasted throughout the end of 1982, all of 1983, all of 1984, and into 1985. The record label actually werent willing to keep funding it after the first year, which is why Michael financed the Thriller video himself.

Whereas Prince had not only started, but almost completed filming Purple Rain, a year after the release of 1999, and most of the songs had been recorded too! Remember, the basic tracks for half that album were done in August 1983 at the Dance Benefit Concert in Minneapolis. That's a mere 10 months after the release of 1999.

So Michael chose to capitalize on the MTV crossover platform by making sure that audience heard the record he'd already released, whereas Prince had already made another one by that time.

  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #25 posted 01/30/15 6:05am

KingSausage

avatar

Militant said:

My two favorite artists, but I can't get with a sequential comparison for the primary reason that Purple Rain is the soundtrack to a movie and Thriller isn't. Meaning, the sequence of Purple Rain was for the most part defined by the movie (of course, Purple Rain doesn't come last in the film).

But both the tracklisting and the choice of songs themselves would be different if it weren't for the film. If anything I'd suggest that 1999 VS Thriller would be a better comparison since neither records were made for a film, and were both released in the same year, both had songs/videos that broke out to a crossover audience thanks to MTV, and both were made with that intention, to break the artist out to a wider audience, and both were successful with that.

The key difference, in my mind, is that Michael chose to squeeze every last drop out of that record, because he didn't make records as quickly as Prince did. So the promotional campaign for Thriller lasted throughout the end of 1982, all of 1983, all of 1984, and into 1985. The record label actually werent willing to keep funding it after the first year, which is why Michael financed the Thriller video himself.

Whereas Prince had not only started, but almost completed filming Purple Rain, a year after the release of 1999, and most of the songs had been recorded too! Remember, the basic tracks for half that album were done in August 1983 at the Dance Benefit Concert in Minneapolis. That's a mere 10 months after the release of 1999.



So Michael chose to capitalize on the MTV crossover platform by making sure that audience heard the record he'd already released, whereas Prince had already made another one by that time.




Excellent post.
"Drop that stereo before I blow your Goddamn nuts off, asshole!"
-Eugene Tackleberry
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
Reply #26 posted 01/30/15 7:03am

luv4u

Moderator

avatar

moderator

FragileUndertow said:

9 out of 9 For purple rain cool

Let's Go Crazy
Take Me With U
The Beautiful Ones
Computer Blue
Darling Nikki
When Doves Cry
I Would Die 4 U
Baby I'm A Star
Purple Rain


In before the lock lock peace!



[detects MJ seepage]


Please use the MJ sticky in the music: non-Prince forum, thanks. lock

canada

Ohh purple joy oh purple bliss oh purple rapture!
REAL MUSIC by REAL MUSICIANS - Prince
"I kind of wish there was a reason for Prince to make the site crash more" ~~ Ben
  - E-mail - orgNote - Report post to moderator
  New topic   Printable     (Log in to 'subscribe' to this topic)
« Previous topic  Next topic »
Forums > Prince: Music and More > For shits and giggles... Thriller vs. Purple Rain track for track...