why does reunion show have to be only step back?

Some orgers think that Prince and the Revolution reunion isn't what Prince should do,because its only about nostalgy and a step back
in his musical evolution.
But why should we look only like that?

Can we see it from another perspective as how would those 80's songs sound today,what kind of energy Prince and the Revolution could produce?

Few years ago Eric Clapton reunited with his fellow Cream band mates and guess what,they didn't sound nostalgic at all ,no big marshall stacks no acid influanced riffs ,they sounded like Cream of today.
If Lennon was still alive,the Beatles would probably reunite.
Commodores are reuniting this year also .

So don't you wanna hear where are Prince and the Revolution today in music?
I think they should reunite only because they can still do it,everybody is still alive from that band and they matured as musicians and people.

thebanishedone said:

I don't look at Prince's decisions as backward thinking...Whatever reuinion is down the line, is Prince's current day.

Whatever Prince does is welcomed with an open heart and ears.

thebanishedone said:

Hmmmmm lets say it did happen.

I wonder if he would perform his explicit songs - Erotic City/Head/etc. understanding his current religious beliefes and his stand on explicit lyrics...Hmm i wonder if he could get around it by allowing another band member to sing the lyrics????

Oh if only

Anxiety said:

thebanishedone said:

Some orgers think that Prince and the Revolution reunion isn't what Prince should do,because its only about nostalgy and a step back
in his musical evolution.
But why should we look only like that?

i think that's how PRINCE looks at the idea.

you know what i'd love to see?

i'd be into a revolution reunion WITHOUT prince.

most of them have released solo records anyway, so it's not like most of them are shy about singing. what's the problem then?

it'd be cool to see them write some new original material together, and maybe even re-record one or two old prince & the revolution songs that never made their way past bootleg limbo (you-know-who willing, of course).

and while it would be cool enough to have this be just a reunion of the purple rain-era revolution, why not bring on other revolutionaries? bring dez into the mix, bring in eric and eddie m. and sheila and atlanta bliss and heck, even gayle and andre if they'll dare to be part of such a thing!

and they could do like talking heads did in the 90s when they wanted to reunite but david byrne wasn't having it - the other three band members made an album anyway, and they invited a bunch of people to sing lead vocals on each song. could you imagine...erykah badu and the revolution? (your favorite singer here) and the revolution??? and then one big killer of a concert where all the guest vocalists come together to perform their songs, backed by the revolution?

that would be hot.

there are totally ways they could reunite without having to "look back".

Anxiety said:[quote]

The dark purple cloud rolls in, once again.

Anxiety said:

Anxiety said:[quote]you know what i'd love to see?

i'd be into a revolution reunion WITHOUT prince.

most of them have released solo records anyway, so it's not like most of them are shy about singing. what's the problem then?

it'd be cool to see them write some new original material together, and maybe even re-record one or two old prince & the revolution songs that never made their way past bootleg limbo (you-know-who willing, of course).

and while it would be cool enough to have this be just a reunion of the purple rain-era revolution, why not bring on other revolutionaries? bring dez into the mix, bring in eric and eddie m. and sheila and atlanta bliss and heck, even gayle and andre if they'll dare to be part of such a thing!

and they could do like talking heads did in the 90s when they wanted to reunite but david byrne wasn't having it - the other three band members made an album anyway, and they invited a bunch of people to sing lead vocals on each song. could you imagine...erykah badu and the revolution? (your favorite singer here) and the revolution??? and then one big killer of a concert where all the guest vocalists come together to perform their songs, backed by the revolution?

that would be hot.

there are totally ways they could reunite without having to "look back".[/quot

I welcomed this idea during the celebration times.... now it's just best to let what was stellar remain as it was.

it was still nice to have a few of the members around get the opportunity to take pics with Dr.Fink(in his blue scrubs) and Bobby Z.

Anxiety said:

thebanishedone said:[quote]
If Lennon was still alive,the Beatles would probably reunite.


Don't you think George Harrison would have something to do with a reunion, rest his soul?!

I used to want a reunion a whole lot but the way Prince has been lately...no thanks! I'd rather just hold onto my found memories of the Revolution and not let them be tainted by whatever trick bag Prince would come out of!

Of course, I'm a Liberal! I'm an American, damn it!

This country was founded on the premise of Liberty and Justice for ALL...remember?

My wallet is STILL on hiatus!

If I remember correctly there was a time when Prince was up for the idea of a Rev reunion- I can't remember how long ago it's been but I swear I remember Wendy or Lisa saying in an interview that Prince wanted some huge crazy production at an awards show whith like balloons and elaborate costumes and a marching band down the aisles (it's been a LONG time so don't quote me on this but I know it was something like that ) but W&L wanted something less flashy and the whole idea fizzled cuz they couldn't see eye to eye.

Anyone else remember this or know what I'm talking about?

.
[Edited 6/11/09 9:52am]

cause the revolution can't hold on stage like michael b and sonny t that's y it's a step back

if i was at the conga room in person hearing what these 3 did alone on the stage by themselves..this is what a REAL BAND sounds like. and even prince knows this, thus he's always inviting these 2 back in2 the studio and stage with him as compared 2 any other member of the revolution sans eric leeds. the only member of the revolution that would b a welcomed comeback is fink and dez

[Edited 6/11/09 10:43am]

C:\Otaassk~.exe




Seriously, this thread makes no fucking sense: http://prince.org/msg/15/321025

vivid is my new boo!

Anxiety said:

thebanishedone said:

Some orgers think that Prince and the Revolution reunion isn't what Prince should do,because its only about nostalgy and a step back
in his musical evolution.
But why should we look only like that?

i think that's how PRINCE looks at the idea.

contrapposto said:

If I remember correctly there was a time when Prince was up for the idea of a Rev reunion- I can't remember how long ago it's been but I swear I remember Wendy or Lisa saying in an interview that Prince wanted some huge crazy production at an awards show whith like balloons and elaborate costumes and a marching band down the aisles (it's been a LONG time so don't quote me on this but I know it was something like that ) but W&L wanted something less flashy and the whole idea fizzled cuz they couldn't see eye to eye.

Anyone else remember this or know what I'm talking about?

.
[Edited 6/11/09 9:52am]